Saxophones Pork Tales: Saxophone Repair DIY Adventures.

Life around the barn.
Tales from a pig that likes to stick his nose into everything.

Paint that S. How difficult could it be ?
1747869014621.webp


1) Search the net.
2) Find the color.
3) Order color.
4) Study task on University of YouTube, aka; For destruction by DYI presented by pro tech.
1747869824677.webp



1747869909688.webp


Do the cleaning & prep.
1747870236970.webp


Paint and cleanup / detail the edges with hard cotton swabs. Sounds easy……:confused:
1747870401847.webp


Yeah tha guy Matt makes it look easy.
Anyone remember your first experience cooking bacon crispy while still in the frying pan !
 
So i faffed around with the “Perma Blue” today. Several attempts worth. Different mixes & time. Following the instructions on preparing & cleaning. I used 0000 steel wool and denatured alcohol as recommended. Funny stuff to use. Photographing to what I see in hand is completely different. Still the appearance of new shiny brass is gone.
View attachment 38099

Looks black then blue then brown depending on light reflection. Blotchy then not. Funky effect.
View attachment 38100
View attachment 38101
View attachment 38102

I tried 🤷‍♂️.
FWIW I had a conversation with @Stephen Howard several years back about faux patina. Exactly for the reason attempted here. Not having a repair standout. “I’ve never been satisfied” was the nature of his response. So ! ?
Maybe patina PA-40 in the future. 38 attempts still to go….
I'd be very pleased with that. I know it's not invisible -but it perhaps is a subtle reminder of 'this is a new bit, that is not' like they do on reconstructed amphorae from ancient Greek wrecks off Crete!
 
Why not try one of the many commercial solutions? They aren’t that expensive, 2-3 gallons of gas depending on which kind you get.
Yes true. The thing is every alloy mix is different. Like people and medications….your results may vary 😤.
Please tell me what Martin brass mix was in 1934 so I can patina match 2026 brass (probably from China) today on this task🤪. Seems simple. But in reality this is insanely difficult. Even John Talcott (RIP) tried like heck for years.
A mouthpiece guy told me he uses Jax (I think) to patina an unplated brass mouthpiece.
The attempt was done with the solution the customer suggested and had past experience with.
1792922784514.webp


My only exposure to “Jax” was from a customer.
1792922624529.webp


This was reporting his positive results treating a copper neck with the above “Silver Plating Solution”. The treatment was durable after a few applications and (IMHO) a great match to a 1918 Conn NW1 tenor I serviced a month earlier.
1792924066384.webp
1792924133970.webp


Thanks for suggesting to look up other JAX products ! Honestly I’ve not looked into them yet.
 
I'd be very pleased with that. I know it's not invisible -but it perhaps is a subtle reminder of 'this is a new bit, that is not' like they do on reconstructed amphorae from ancient Greek wrecks off Crete!
Thanks for your nod In observing an “in range” visible grade. These tasks are not consistently easy.
Across the globe individuals have different levels of what’s acceptable in quality/ visual appearance.

To all.
My task was to make a cheerful pleasing part. The owner/ buyer was unfortunate in not noticing the bit missing in the auction listing.
If anyone is interested in an action item and would like a second set of eyes. Please contact me by PM / DM.
I DO NOT BID ON ANY LISTING SOMEONE INQUIRIES ON ! EVER !
That’s just wrong to do so ! Nuff said.
 
Don't sweat the patina issue. I think that looks better than the bare brass. Most importantly, it's an exact copy of the original in shape and functions to support the neck.

When the owner is playing a packed stadium venue in front of thousands of adoring fans who are at least 30 feet away behind security barricades, no one will notice.:mrcool
 
Today it’s Spring time.
View attachment 38115
Springs are another deceiving task that on the surface appears to be really easy. Difficult no.

Starting off right matters. Beginning with the spring itself. Quality matters. Too hard and they can break off / chip just making them to size. They need to be hard but not brittle. Malleable enough to hammer a little dovetail end without shattering. The above picture showing a broken end, dovetail and a few common tools I use.

There are task specific tools and optional techniques for spring removal and installation. Look them up. I’m not going into details on tools here. Whatever you do ware safety glasses!

One comment about removal. Don’t try to knock them out with a punch. If you do, plan on realigning the pillars later.
Don’t do it ! ⬇️🚫
View attachment 38122
 
Three things...

When measuring up a replacement spring, poke it through the hole in the pillar and align the tip with the spring cradle - then bend the part of the spring that remains on the outside of the pillar to around 45 degrees. This performs two functions; it shows you where to cut the spring....and it puts a huge amount of strain on it. If it breaks at this point, chuck it away and use a different spring...because the tempering is off.

Once you've cut the spring heat the cut end to red hot. You have about 5mm of length to play with before you knacker the spring - so aim to get only the extreme cut edge red hot and then instantly onto the anvil with it to create the flat. It'll hammer out much more evenly and will be far less likely to splinter when compressing it in to place.

If you need to punch a spring out - refit the relevant keys behind the direction of force. Doesn't matter if you fit them back to front or inverted - you only need to spread the force of the impact from the punch. The more keys you can fit, the better. Even a piece of wood will do (wedges are cool).
 
OK PS, I've got a question for you. You seem to be able to work out tricks for difficult situations. THAT OTHER forum didn't turn up anything.

I've got a needle spring, in the lower stack, that is too weak. I remember that when I put this horn back together, I thought "wow, I sure am having to put a lot of curve on this thing". Comparing it to the other springs on the stack, it's a far smaller diameter spring. Now the question is, how can I enlarge the hole in the post?

Obviously I can unsolder the post, drill the hole larger, and reinstall the post. But I'd rather not do that if I don't have to. The post in question has posts to the left and right. The space between the posts is just about enough to be able to get the springs in - so let's say 1~1.25". No way I could fish, say, a teeny twist drill in a pin vise, in there and line it up. I saw those Ferree's "broaches" for spring holes, but again, way too long.

The best I could come up with so far would be either: 1) break off a teeny twist drill in the fluted part, so I could get it in between the posts, and grab it with some needle nose pliers and work it back and forth to crudely drill out the hole, or 2) take a short piece of sacrificial spring and grind a flat on it so it can act as a reamer, and grab IT with some needle nose pliers and ream out the hole to size.

Someone did kindly point out that the hole might actually be bigger than the current spring and I might be able to just go up a size or two in spring diameter and it'd fit through the hole as is - which of course would be first prize, but I'm not going to count on it.

I haven't torn into this thing in detail yet, but I was hoping that someone could say "oh yeah, what I do when I'm faced with needing to make a spring hole bigger and there are posts on either side, is THIS" and it would be something I haven't already thought of. (I mean other than of course "Well, bucky, you're screwed, gotta unsolder the post and get it up on the bench where you can work on it standing on your hind legs".

This is the RH middle finger key, which operates the fork Eb on the back, so I also thought "well, just spring that little devil closed and glue the finger touch to the pad cup and it won't matter" but closing the fork Eb makes the F natural just HORRIBLY flat and stuffy. So that's not an option.
If I were to attempt this I would go the DIY reamer route made from a long spring. Three flats. Spin the thing with a bow. Press on end with a thimble on fingertip.
I had a chance to test the bow & spring as reamer idea. It works. Although further testing is needed on string choice for better performance/ grip/ drive force.
The Lo C & Eb needed minor upsizing. Both were around .048-.049 . Between the new spring kit and my stock inventory, I only had .050’s. So there wasn’t much material to ream out.

The bow I made from a windshield wiper flat spring. This works best on pulling direction.
View attachment 38124
The spring was a 1-1/2 too long, so using the exact spring was no issue. I gave it four faces about 1/2 in total length on bench grinder.

View attachment 38129

As you can see below access was no problem unlike your task. I was just testing the idea. The yellow on string is wax to prevent chafing. This actually helped grip too.
View attachment 38126
The process is repeatable.
View attachment 38127
View attachment 38128
 
If you need to ream a spring hole out you just take your desired spring, flip it over to the blunt end, grind a very slight taper to the tip then grind a 30 degree flat on it (a D-bit, essentially). Stuff the other end in a drill and there's your reamer. If you're pushed for space always angle the drill/'bit' in the direction the spring will be 'set' in. If you're really pushed for space you can turn the reamer with a pair of pliers. If you're absolutely pushed for space, cut and bend the spring a la Allen key.

And...buy an Archimedes drill, for heaven's sake. Mine cost me less than a tenner. Buy once...etc...etc...
 
Three things...

When measuring up a replacement spring, poke it through the hole in the pillar and align the tip with the spring cradle - then bend the part of the spring that remains on the outside of the pillar to around 45 degrees. This performs two functions; it shows you where to cut the spring....and it puts a huge amount of strain on it. If it breaks at this point, chuck it away and use a different spring...because the tempering is off.
Thanks for your post.
Yes, I do this too. Depends on access as assembled.
But for the DIY home hobby tech things can go sideways in a blink. A tech with a hammer and no side cutters. Makes you wonder how they measured the wire diameter size. Lots of options to knacker an otherwise easy task.
View attachment 38130
Once you've cut the spring heat the cut end to red hot. You have about 5mm of length to play with before you knacker the spring - so aim to get only the extreme cut edge red hot and then instantly onto the anvil with it to create the flat. It'll hammer out much more evenly and will be far less likely to splinter when compressing it in to place.
Yep, still I find not all need heat. I take a wack at the end before trimming to length. If it flattens no heat is used. If it breaks off or doesn’t flatten, I may bin it. Depending on the install needs of bending adjustment. But yeah heat is your friend here. Hope the DIY doesn’t overcook it.
If you need to punch a spring out - refit the relevant keys behind the direction of force. Doesn't matter if you fit them back to front or inverted - you only need to spread the force of the impact from the punch. The more keys you can fit, the better. Even a piece of wood will do (wedges are cool).
Also true. Having the location backed up makes a world of difference.
I cringe at work I’ve seen come in damaged from “a good smart blow”. Experience and finesse counts.
A 4oz hammer or one pound ? Swing and miss 😬. Notice the punch I pictured was a pin punch ? I don’t actually use that type if needed. I use a nail set with the cupped tip. Keeps the tip on the wire.
 
If you need to ream a spring hole out you just take your desired spring, flip it over to the blunt end, grind a very slight taper to the tip then grind a 30 degree flat on it (a D-bit, essentially). Stuff the other end in a drill and there's your reamer. If you're pushed for space always angle the drill/'bit' in the direction the spring will be 'set' in. If you're really pushed for space you can turn the reamer with a pair of pliers. If you're absolutely pushed for space, cut and bend the spring a la Allen key.

And...buy an Archimedes drill, for heaven's sake. Mine cost me less than a tenner. Buy once...etc...etc...
I never have much luck with the “D” bit style. Three or four faces seem to cut better for me.
Pliers to turn 🤣 yeah, that’s being in a tight spot.
I never thought about the right angle Allen style, thanks 👍
Still it was fun testing the bow idea.
I have a Yankee drill. It’s too big.
Completely forgot about a Archimedes. Dunno where mine went 🤷‍♂️.
Smalls I usually do by hand with this vise. Range is .015 to .078”.
1792976091424.webp


Just ordered this pile of junk for $8 with bits & storage box😁
 
The way I like to size springs is by measuring.
The location of caliper against the post and about an 1/8” beyon the cleat / cradle.
1793008936017.webp


Secure the caliper head with locking screw and measure the cut needed from end. Go a bit long if it makes you feel better.
1793009209766.webp


Check the work. 3mm too long is better than 3mm short. Cut or grind off the excess.
1793010042671.webp

Check the work again and plan 1/2-1/4 of pillars width as dovetail.
1793010007848.webp
 
End of material was hammer tested prior to cutting. I already knew no heat was needed. Just a few smart blows on each side will do. 16oz ball-peen hammer on cast iron anvil. AKA back end of bench vise. Do have your safety glasses on.
1793010289773.webp

1793010462029.webp

Placed and lightly pressed into the post. No bending necessary.
1793010660498.webp


One thing to look out for on the cleat is a ware groove. This can cause a spring to click or chirp when playing. As the action is fingered the spring moves in & out of the groove. This can be quite loud. Very lightly dress the location with a file. It doesn’t take much.
1793011711427.webp
 
Anyone been studying the names of action parts / keywork names ??? Don’t post a question asking for help fixing
“That bit or this thingy” ! You don’t eat off a plate with thing things. Do you ask for the thing plate ?
Parts of any machine have names. Some more than one, crook or neck. Same thing. Depending on where you live. Still a proper named bit, not that up by me left hand. Yeah, +/- three fingers.

I’ll send a Squealer Pig anywhere on the globe free of charge to the first member who can name all the keys with cups below. There’s 25. Six have clues attached 😉
View attachment 38046

Can’t count or name them ?
Here’s a checklist to work from.
View attachment 38047
When I'm measuring to order pads (I do this rarely, so I don't have a stock), I just write a number inside each key cup.
 
So i faffed around with the “Perma Blue” today. Several attempts worth. Different mixes & time. Following the instructions on preparing & cleaning. I used 0000 steel wool and denatured alcohol as recommended. Funny stuff to use. Photographing to what I see in hand is completely different. Still the appearance of new shiny brass is gone.
View attachment 38099

Looks black then blue then brown depending on light reflection. Blotchy then not. Funky effect.
View attachment 38100
View attachment 38101
View attachment 38102

I tried 🤷‍♂️.
FWIW I had a conversation with @Stephen Howard several years back about faux patina. Exactly for the reason attempted here. Not having a repair standout. “I’ve never been satisfied” was the nature of his response. So ! ?
Maybe patina PA-40 in the future. 38 attempts still to go….
Looking at it, it seems the new part has come out more blue and shiny while the old part (the tube) is more brown and not that shiny.

What I have done in the past to get a brown color on brass is to use ammonia. Specifically, I suspended the part in question in a bucket over half a cup or so of plain old household ammonia cleaner, and watched it every couple hours; when it got the color I wanted, I took it out, washed it thoroughly with soap and water, and (in the case of what I was doing) sprayed it with lacquer.

Your project there is more challenging in that the new part is attached to the brown part. I think if you were to ammonia-fume the whole neck, you'd end up with the tube near black. Might be worth seeing if actually applying household ammonia cleaner to the sheet brass will darken it. (You've got all the scrap sheet to test with). I can't imagine how you could effectively mask off that neck tube from ammonia vapors.
 
Yes I do this too. Makes it quicker to pluck the pads from my inventory.
View attachment 38161
Ah, I see. I actually do something different; I just number 'em, 1,2 3,4, etc. then I have the paper with sizes for each key cup - this way I don't get wrapped around the axle of "what's the NAME of that key?" Of course, normally it's extremely clear which pad fits which cup, but sometimes there are a couple that are close. But I do like the idea of just writing the actual pad dimension you ordered, in the cup for which you ordered it. Next time I may just do that, and eliminate the piece of paper. (I do pad replacements infrequently, like maybe every couple of years, and a complete re-pad maybe every 10 years, so I don't have a pad inventory.)
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,433
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom