Intonation Playing out of tune

No I don't know. :confused2: Can you offer an explanation that a novice mathematician can understand? I am familiar with the use of the 12th root of 2 (1.05946309436) to determine the distances between pitches in the tempered scale.

Equal intervals correspond to multiplying frequency by the same number.

One octave: multiply (or divide) frequency by 2.
One semitone: multiply by 12th root of 2 (do it 12 times and you've multiplied by two)
One cent: multiply by 1200th root of two.

n'th root of 2 is 2^(1/n), or exp((log 2)/n).
 
Equal intervals correspond to multiplying frequency by the same number.
One octave: multiply (or divide) frequency by 2.
One semitone: multiply by 12th root of 2 (do it 12 times and you've multiplied by two)
One cent: multiply by 1200th root of two.
n'th root of 2 is 2^(1/n), or exp((log 2)/n).

Thank you for that insight. I worked out a spreadsheet to calculate the cents between concert A=440hz and concert Bb=466.16 and found that the value in Hz of each cent rise in pitch does increase very slightly.

The difference between A and the1st cent above is 0.254227384 Hz.

The difference between the 99th cent and the Bb above is 0.269188997 Hz

The difference between these two graduations of cents in a half step is a whopping 0.014961613 Hz or 15/1000 of a vibration rounded. I will certainly sleep better tonight knowing that, like snowflakes no two cents are exactly alike. 🙂
 
Last edited:
Thank you.
I think I have got that.
If your playing room goes from 65 F to 70 F then A 440 will rise by 0.2616 *2.5* 5 = 3.26 so to 443.26.
Can our ears detect that?
Incidentally since I am in Canada and generally work in Centigrade do you happen to know off the top of your head the rise in Cents per degree Centigrade and save me doing the math to work it out. Though the whole thing seems rather academic (but interesting) to me.
The human ear is very sensitive to pitch. I knew someone who had a set of 20 tuned bells - the difference being one tone between the highest and lowest pitched bell. Just about everyone can sort them into the right order.
 
Carrying on the theme of being out of tune - do people find a general difference between how in tune the various Bb alternatives are?

'Long' Bb seems quite flat to me - or perhaps it's in tune and the rest are sharp :confused: I looked at the Larry Teal 'add extra fingers to compensate' chart but it doesn't distinguish between the various B flats.
 
"Tuning" is not generally an absolute as we use equal temperament, which is a compromise to enable us to play in any key, more-or-less in tune, but not quite! There are alternative systems, some are more harmonious than others, but none is 'in tune' for every key. Here's some light entertainment....

You don't need to know about these other systems, I just wish though that people when learning were made aware of the history of this and understand that there are alternatives and that ET is a fudge that good enough most of the time and that major thirds really are horribly out of tune and too wide - relatively speaking...

We do need to listen more, so it is good that you are self-aware of this - many people are not...
 
Carrying on the theme of being out of tune - do people find a general difference between how in tune the various Bb alternatives are?

'Long' Bb seems quite flat to me - or perhaps it's in tune and the rest are sharp :confused: I looked at the Larry Teal 'add extra fingers to compensate' chart but it doesn't distinguish between the various B flats.

In my experience the difference between the 1 & 2 + side key, 1 - 1, and bis fingerings for Bb has more to do with timbre than with pitch. I do know that the low Bb is flat on some makes and models of saxophone and is next to impossible to "lip up". I have never tried that fingering with the octave key to play Bb2.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,385
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom