Theory & Impro Playing minor 7 chords starting on the fifth.

I understand the concept splitting chords up by saying a F#min 11 is F#m7 plus Bm7. Any dom7 b9 is really a diminished or that four of contain the same diminished but I don't actually think it is a good way to learn or view how the harmony is functioning, as opposed to learning the actual chord notes and their voice leading tendencies. You also taking one of the most fundamental elements of how harmony functions by disregarding the root and therefore understanding of root movement. A IIm7 V7 I is strong due to

  • The strong root movement down a fifth
  • The semitone voice leading resolution of 7th down to 3rd of next chord
  • The semitone voice leading resolution of 3rd up to root of next chord.

Employing those melodic tendencies is incredibly fundamental to mainstream jazz impro.

The thing is if you think of the A in Bm7 as the 3rd of F#m7 you lose that.
 
F#m7 has no G# or D#. It is chord IIIm7 of D , therefore it is indeed diatonic in the key of D major.
But F#m7 is also a ii7 chord of E, whereby adding the 9th would certainly give you a G# and a D# and not be diatonic of D; it's also a vi chord in A and

In Ladybird, all the minor7 chords are ii chords, so the Bmin7 mentioned would always be a ii in A. Depending whether we're in Bb or Eb transposition, we're at either bar 11 for Bb (unresolving ii-V that goes to the relative minor of the V) or bar 13 (ii-V-I in A). So in the context, playing that G# is going to sound more "in the key" than a G.
 
And then of course a minor 6 chord is just an inversion of a ii7b5 - Am6 being A, C, E, F#; same as F#m7b5 - F#, A, C, E. So it's the same thing in minor keys, the iv chord and ii chord can be thought of as the same, with the same function; Am6 being iv in E minor, same as F#m7b5 being the ii.
I tend to disagree that they are the same thing - although they contain exactly the same notes.

Those "substitutions" I believe were originally used by sheet music publishers where there was a plan part plus chord symbols for ukulele, banjo or guitar. It was assumed that you average ukulele player would freak out if they had the correct harmony of (e.g. (Dm7b5) so they used the easier representation assuming that even though the root was wrong, it would be covered by the bass, piano, or else wouldn't really affect anything.

But arrangers and jazz improvisors know the value of functional harmony and melodic resolution so we know that (as above)

  • The strong root movement down a fifth
  • The semitone voice leading resolution of 7th down to 3rd of next chord
  • The semitone voice leading resolution of 3rd up to root of next chord.

Employing those melodic tendencies is incredibly fundamental to mainstream jazz impro.

Although introduced to make life simpler for ukulele players, trying to think Fm6 instead of Dm7b5 actually confuses the concept of learning functional harmony and using it as a composer, arranger or improviser. That's what I think because I like things to be simpler and the useful things like guide notes and voice leading to be obvious.
 
Last edited:
I understand the concept splitting chords up by saying a F#min 11 is F#m7 plus Bm7. Any dom7 b9 is really a diminished or that four of contain the same diminished but I don't actually think it is a good way to learn or view how the harmony is functioning, as opposed to learning the actual chord notes and their voice leading tendencies. You also taking one of the most fundamental elements of how harmony functions by disregarding the root and therefore understanding of root movement. A IIm7 V7 I is strong due to

  • The strong root movement down a fifth
  • The semitone voice leading resolution of 7th down to 3rd of next chord
  • The semitone voice leading resolution of 3rd up to root of next chord.

Employing those melodic tendencies is incredibly fundamental to mainstream jazz impro.

The thing is if you think of the A in Bm7 as the 3rd of F#m7 you lose that.

But if you go back to classical harmony, the subdominant - dominant - tonic is considered to be IV - V - I as the strongest cadence.

Go sit at a piano and play root position IV - V - I triads versus ii - V - I triads and tell me which sounds stronger.

The ii is a substitution of the IV when you start adding extensions; it's actually a deliberate disregarding of the root of a IV6 chord and playing it in the 3rd inversion.

But largely this is about reducing pattern practise. You can take practising a major 7 triad in 3rd inversion (starting on the 7th) and use that exact same practise for minor chords where you build that as if the third we're the root. You can apply that same practise to different situations and know it will sound good.
 
But if you go back to classical harmony, the subdominant - dominant - tonic is considered to be IV - V - I as the strongest cadence.
Classical harmony isn't what we are talking about though and to be honest I don't particularly want to go back there. Most people learning jazz improvisation want the mainstream jazz stuff, where IIM7 V7 I or in minor: IIm7b5 V7 I are fairly well endemic.

You can think like that and I have no problem, I just think it's best to be thinking in terms of functional harmony, I believe it's a more musical and melodic way to think..
 
Well maybe you don't want to go back, but it's still where a ii-V-I comes from: a substitution of a classical IV-V-I. It's why it sounds good.

Where the thinking around playing a different scale or chord comes in really useful is with pattern based stuff. It's a lot easier to think Bb major 7 starting on the 7th than the mental juggling of 9th, 3rd, 5th, 7th. The issue with what a 6th or 13th is has already come up. With dominant chords, play the diminished portion and resolve it: let the bassist handle the root. Or sub away; any of the dominants that share the same notes in your diminished 7th will sound good: G7, Bb7, E7, Db7 all interchangeable. Far easier to think play any of the Bb7 E7, Db7 over a G7 than wrestle with G7b9#9#11b13....
 
Honestly, you aren't going to convince me that any supposed quicker, easier, shortcuts are actually better or even quicker if you are going to thoroughly absorb the advantages of understanding the melodic concepts of harmony part of which I've outlined above.

If I was teaching again, telling a student that a major 7 3rd inversion is the same as a minor 7 just wouldn't have fitted into my methodology. I do understand it means the same practice can cover the same fingerings (albeit with a 9th instead of a root if it's aminor. I'd say practice major 7s in all kinds of inversions and also practice minor 7s and minor 7b5s similarly.

The argument against that is there are more arpeggios to practice.

The argument for is that can easily assimilate the chord degrees as you practice.


I need a lie down 😵!
I'd be interested to know what level you consider your theory knowledge to be at. It's always useful to know when trying to give the most helpful replies.
 
But F#m7 is also a ii7 chord of E, whereby adding the 9th would certainly give you a G# and a D# and not be diatonic of D;
I agree in general, so I should have made it clearer I was answering post #4 so we only were talking about the context of F#m7 as chord IIm7 in the key of D.

I think Dr G was raising the point that we should not always assume a minor 7 is chord IIm7, which is quite a common assumption especially in the chord/scale theory were you assume every minor 7 can be associated with a dorian mode. Something many people know I strongly disagree with.
 
I think Dr G was raising the point that we should not always assume a minor 7 is chord IIm7, which is quite a common assumption especially in the chord/scale theory were you assume every minor 7 can be associated with a dorian mode. Something many people know I strongly disagree with
Yeah I agree completely with that, the chord/scale thing is often just wrong.

I don't think the rest of what I'm saying is about shortcuts though, but about being able to use the things you practise in multiple different scenarios and understanding how they sound.

All too often when presented with a chord symbol, players will hit the roots (and especially in ii-V-Is on the ii). Whereas there are loads of sounds available avoiding the root (and let the bass player handle that) that you will already have practised. It's about knowing where and how to apply them. I absolutely find thinking of a more common triad easier than thinking of upper extensions. And they achieve the same end, right?

And there are many great players/teachers out there who encourage this kind of thinking; Bob Reynolds, Dave Pollack etc
 
All too often when presented with a chord symbol, players will hit the roots (and especially in ii-V-Is on the ii). Whereas there are loads of sounds available avoiding the root (and let the bass player handle that)
Sorry to keep disagreeing, but I don't see what's wrong with playing roots, it's just another chord note and avoiding roots could could sound contrived when they are often an important part of any melodic playing. The fact that the bass player may be playing them isn't relevant IMO.

What I do agree with is it's often not great if it becomes too repetitive. Mind you, this is one of my favourite licks which no doubt you'll recognise, and he plays it at least four or five times in the same solo.


ptfl.webp
 
Sorry to keep disagreeing, but I don't see what's wrong with playing roots, it's just another chord note and avoiding roots could could sound contrived when they are often an important part of any melodic playing. The fact that the bass player may be playing them isn't relevant IMO.

What I do agree with is it's often not great if it becomes too repetitive. Mind you, this is one of my favourite licks which no doubt you'll recognise, and he plays it at least four or five times in the same solo.


View attachment 27176
Don't be sorry for disagreeing! This is all subjective. I'm not saying it's wrong to play roots; but, and noted from my own playing, all too often when learning 2-5-1s every line starts with the root of the ii.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,431
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom