I suspect that ramming a pencil down the crook pretty much sealed your fate. The pull-through was probably bunched up around the octave key pip tube, and all you've done is pack it down harder.
There's little point now it trying to push the wad out as a whole - you'll have to resort to picking it apart piece-by-piece until it loosens up enough to be withdrawn.
The tool I use for this is just a steel rod with a slot cut into it, filed to a taper and then splayed out at the end. Whichever way you turn it, it'll grip the cloth and allow you to gently tease the was out into a looser ball - after which time (and it'll likely be a very long time) the cloth should come out.
Because of the position of the wad you have little choice but to go in from mouthpipe end - which means having to tease the cloth out into a narrowing tube. Not fun.
Wetting the cloth isn't likely to make much difference either way at this point but it just might help to soften the fibres. Try a very slightly diluted solution of dishwashing detergent. If it doesn't work, you'll just have to wait for it to dry out, and start over.
If all else fails I suspect you'll need to have the octave key pip removed. Hopefully it hasn't been damaged by hammering a pencil down the crook...
For future reference you're better off leaving the crook wet (just give it a shake at the end of playing) - and then washing it out on a regular basis with a flexible brush. Keeps the crook fresher and does a much better job of preventing the build-up of slime and calcium carbonate deposits.
The crook Pad-Savers are a decent alternative - but unlike the regular Pad-savers for the body of the horn I wouldn't advise leaving them in the crook.