Tech/maintenance Piece of swab stuck inside tenor neck

It’s been my experience in life that things made to absorb liquid swell up when doing so. But then again the inside of the tube was wet when you stuck it in. So ??
Personally I would save that option for last.

My first observation from the pictures. There’s nothing protruding from either end. Was the swab shorter than the total length of the neck or did something break off?

Was this the direction of travel as stuck ?
7D4F29DB-2F13-4FDF-B8C5-C6ED291AAA76.webp


If so it needs to go out the opposite direction.
FE57058D-0769-4C74-8543-8D1D217B181C.webp


As others have mentioned it’s likely stuck on the octave PIP tube. Some protruding more than this.
279DDFA2-8EFC-45E2-9C74-5816E591BD11.webp


With your weapon of choice in hand grab the swab end. Twist-pull-push-repeat. With extreme caution you may have some luck pushing a rod down the octave hole. My thought is pushing it away from the tube inside.
BCD4E4F4-A643-43AC-A46A-DBD278D4802C.webp
440E9829-AFBE-428B-8A8E-3BCAF22CF60E.webp


Safe journey my friend. Look forward to hearing your results soon.
 
What is the make and model of the horn?

That hammer is a worry...
If the neck has been too damaged, what are the odds of a new neck? A damaged octave pip is a long term worry. If the tenon is bent out of round, that is a potential leak waiting to happen.

Definitely remove the octave key before working on it any further.

Wrapping it up in bubble wrap and posting it to a tech may be a quality option?
 
Hello everyone. An update: Finally had some time to work on the neck. Used some cooking oil, a couple of elastic gripping claws, scissors, screwdriver, tweezers etc. After over an hour of pulling and twisting it finally came out. My hands and wrists are aching. I'll use a matte black paint pen to touch up a couple of spots where the lacquer came off from endless hammering and other sorts of assault I hope the neck is still going to work OK. I'll find out tomorrow.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20230902_201935_edit_1861323582006.webp
    IMG_20230902_201935_edit_1861323582006.webp
    32.9 KB · : 156
  • IMG_20230902_202138.webp
    IMG_20230902_202138.webp
    22.8 KB · : 213
As long as the octave key does it's job, it should be fine. Then adjusting the octave key, shouldn't be a big issue.

I can't imagine you damaged anything beyond resurrection... 😉

Pushing the limits is part of learning. :w00t:
 
Last edited:
What is the make and model of the horn?

That hammer is a worry...
If the neck has been too damaged, what are the odds of a new neck? A damaged octave pip is a long term worry. If the tenon is bent out of round, that is a potential leak waiting to happen.

Definitely remove the octave key before working on it any further.

Wrapping it up in bubble wrap and posting it to a tech may be a quality option?
I had it custom made from a Taiwanese saxophone factory years ago, after someone I knew who had done the same and was happy with it. No brand name, but nice engraving. It's a good tenor saxophone🙂
 
Sounds as if it’s pretty impacted. I might try introducing a scalpel blade on a long handle (if it will fit) and seeing if I could make a series of cuts to create some loose bits that can gradually be pulled out and eventually loosen the rest.
That's what I did when I had the same problem - and it worked! I took my time, gently cutting the material into many shreds. It was difficult since you can't see what you are doing, but I eventually managed to extract the blockage using long needle nose pliers. Just be patient (it took me over an hour) and you will hopefully be successful!
 
Coming to this late, if anyone else gets in this sort of situation, you can buy extra long curved medical/dental forceps/clamps, which have scissor-type handles, to get a grip going round corners.

And the stand out lesson - never use a hammer to try to resolve this sort of problem.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,567
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom