Tech/maintenance Overhauled sax

There are caveats to raising key heights, it affects tuning. 12 years ago, I bought a well battered early 1950's Beaugnier Vito Low Bb bari sax, an ex-high school instrument. It played very badly out of tune because the key heights were way off, too high.

Over time after I straightened the bent key racks, removed dents, adjusted key heights. Now it plays very well in tune, it is a sax that is very easy to play in the altissimo register. There is a reason why the factory set those key heights ....

It was my friend, a fine player, who told me that his tech opened up the keys to make his sax sing better. Lots of saxes are opened up because using too thick pads. I have Martin saxes and the need thin pads 3,8 - 4.0 mm and what to do when the pads are too thick?
 
It was my friend, a fine player, who told me that his tech opened up the keys to make his sax sing better. Lots of saxes are opened up because using too thick pads. I have Martin saxes and the need thin pads 3,8 - 4.0 mm and what to do when the pads are too thick?
For one, I am not a seasoned repair tech, just an obsessive compulsive who is meticulous in getting things just right on my own horns. I don't mess with another's horn, except in one case I repaired an in-law's clarinet with a couple of lower bad pads including one pad that came apart, restoring it to playability.

Also 30 years ago, repaired an old King Bb bari of the say late 1950's / possibly early 1960's by replacing a few bad pads, missing cork bumpers and straightening a few keys that was with an Army Reserve band I was a member of. It had been sidelined in the instrument storage room. Played it for two years before moving away. Folks couldn't believe something that looked old and a little rustic could play so well. I learned that the King was one fine instrument.

I think I now see what you are referring to. Appears that in overhauling, the repair tech who replaced pads with thicker ones did not restore pad opening heights making the sax sound stuffier, probably affected intonation as well.

Another tech then readjusted pad heights to more or less OEM, which helped remove that suffiness plus improve intonation.

In my case on the early 1950's hand made red brass Beaugnier Vito Bari, pad heights were off as much as at least double, causing it to play very badly out of tune. Over time, I kept tweaking until now, it plays very well in tune.

It was a learning experience for me, as I was able to turn around an instrument that sold for $315.00 US shipping included as-is. I like to use it as a story of how, something that was battered and considered useless can be made to perform well again, just like people who have went through a lot in their lives and feel now they are useless. With a little help, they can be made valuable again.

Anyway, perhaps we may hear from a vet tech who can further clarify with their experience and observations.
 
It was my friend, a fine player, who told me that his tech opened up the keys to make his sax sing better. Lots of saxes are opened up because using too thick pads. I have Martin saxes and the need thin pads 3,8 - 4.0 mm and what to do when the pads are too thick?
Pad height is often neglected. Try to find out when the 4.0 and 4.2 mm pads became standard.

I have seen old Pierrets that require 3.0 mm pads padded with 4.0 mm , really stuffy. Old German saxophones thar require 3.2 mm pads have the same problem. Recently I saw a 1970 soprano with such thick pads on the bell that the bell tones where 40% too low.
It is possible to measure the pad height required by the construction of a saxophone. The ideal height for the pad is when key cup and tone hole are parallel. Then you should add app, 0.2 mm for the indentation of the leather.

Sometimes you measure ideal pad heights which are extremely thick, thin or not equal on all sides which could be caused by damage or by a construction error in the keys. Often this can only be solved by changing the keys.
My personal solution is to grind (or shim) the pads to the required shape.
 
Last edited:
For one, I am not a seasoned repair tech, just an obsessive compulsive who is meticulous in getting things just right on my own horns. I don't mess with another's horn, except in one case I repaired an in-law's clarinet with a couple of lower bad pads including one pad that came apart, restoring it to playability.
Same for me. I just work on my own saxes.
I think I now see what you are referring to. Appears that in overhauling, the repair tech who replaced pads with thicker ones did not restore pad opening heights making the sax sound stuffier, probably affected intonation as well.
Yes. Sometimes I hear sax players complaining after an "overhaul" ( not complete mechanical overhaul). The overhaul was just new pads, eventually new corks and felts and a set-up. A young Yani owner had new pads (.185" some pads even thicker) with new pads. Needless to write, but his fine sax didn't play well.
To open up a sax, raising the keys, often result in lost key action. Play fast or have a sax that sings better?
 
To open up a sax, raising the keys, often result in lost key action. Play fast or have a sax that sings better?
I think that this is where having resonators on the key pads comes in useful. My Beaugnier Vito, last tech that replaced the pads used non-resonator pads, which may account for its slightly darker sound. It has not stopped me from playing it, and most people don't notice. However, it now needs pads replaced. When I have it overhauled, I will go with resonators.
 
Pictures of rubber stoppers on C clarinet from Paris, last half of 1800s.
Pads and needle springs looked more recent, but the current height of the stoppers are a wee bit too tall and not right. (enlarge pics)
An extra squeeze cleans up G# and A.
Some others keys will be adjusted as well.

FullSizeRender.webp


FullSizeRender.webp
 
Last edited:
I think that this is where having resonators on the key pads comes in useful. My Beaugnier Vito, last tech that replaced the pads used non-resonator pads, which may account for its slightly darker sound. It has not stopped me from playing it, and most people don't notice. However, it now needs pads replaced. When I have it overhauled, I will go with resonators.
I have flat oversized reflectors/resonators on my Martin Committee saxes. I think the oversized reflectors/resonators gives me and my saxes a bigger sound. A more contemporary sound. Martin Committee saxes have low key heights which can sound a little bit closed and resonators/reflectors are helping up.
 
According to some discussions on the net the key heights for the upper stack on a committee ii and iii are 8 mm lower stack 11 mm. There is also a discussion on the pad height.
 
Looks like the conductor wanted the woodwinds to play very soft.
I know this is already old hat to most.

In the community band, I find it very easy for my tenor sax to overpower the upper woodwinds during passages. In an orchestra, I gather that it is easy for the even a clarinet to overpower the strings, why there is only two of them versus the much greater number of strings, even why brasswinds are limited in number.

It is easy to play loud. It is a challenge to play well and at pianissimo.
 
I know this is already old hat to most.

In the community band, I find it very easy for my tenor sax to overpower the upper woodwinds during passages. In an orchestra, I gather that it is easy for the even a clarinet to overpower the strings, why there is only two of them versus the much greater number of strings, even why brasswinds are limited in number.

It is easy to play loud. It is a challenge to play well and at pianissimo.
Luckily for the woodwinds strings in classic orchestra play much louder than 50 years ago.
A

It's hard enough to get two of them playing a good unison, let alone half a dozen.
Imagine a 76 sops orchestra.
 
To open up a sax, raising the keys, often result in lost key action. Play fast or have a sax that sings better?

Lost (or double) action shouldn't be a problem - you just dial it out. In extreme cases it might involve some judicious tweaking of the arc of the Bis Bb lower arm in order to get the best balance between the upper and lower stacks.
 
Lost (or double) action shouldn't be a problem - you just dial it out. In extreme cases it might involve some judicious tweaking of the arc of the Bis Bb lower arm in order to get the best balance between the upper and lower stacks.
You are probably right. It was my friend who told me that he took his YTS 61 to the tech and had the keys opened up. And it sang good after that. He sounded great ..... .
 
There was a slight double action on the old C clarinet's E/B lever.
Placing the cork properly, on the pin, also lowered it for better alignment with the F#/C# lever.
A sax player said, that opening up his horn a wee bit, so it was right, caused him to be slower.
My reply, "get the metronome out and practice".
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,435
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom