Setting myself up for abuse I say...a saxophone is a machine. Some are Ferrari's, some are not. If all your life you've driven a Ford Mondeo a Ferrari will be awkward, daunting and downright ****e compared to your old Ford but the more you drive the red machine the more you will despair of that Ford. Right now the 'Ford' is familiar and comforting, the 'Ferrari' will call to you eventually.
I agree ...up to a point.
A Ferrari is a high-spirited, temperamental beast, rather like a thoroughbred stallion, and it takes skill and experience to drive it safely, and enjoyably.
I don't think this is necessarily true of saxophones ....as a really rank beginner I was allowed to try a new Ref 54 Selmer, and I found it a delight, and not at all difficult or temperamental, when compared with my 'intermediate' Hanson SA-5.
OTOH, the 2 Borganis I tried at the same time were as stubborn as mules (as unpleasant to 'drive' as I found a Morgan Plus 8!); I could barely get a squeek from them.
I now have a 'pro quality' alto, recommended to me by Pete, and approved-of by every open-minded person who's tried it
It would be quite suited to a much better player than I will
ever be, but I see that as a bonus .... I can see no reason whatsoever to feel 'unworthy' of it. In fact, with respect, I find the whole concept rather odd .... it is, after all, only a very good quality 'tool' or implement, with which I try to make music, and the better it works, the easier it is for me to concentrate on things other than 'fighting' with, for example, clunky keys and intonation quirks.
As for anyone who says "You are not a good enough player to own such an instrument" .... well, I would regard that as extremely discourteous, as well as ignorant, stupid, and potentially very de-motivating
π‘
What drives people to say such unpleasant things?
(It's
very different from discouraging a 17yo who wants a Porsche 911 ..... an accident lookiing for somewhere to happen!)
I guess that
some modern pro-quality instruments
may be difficult to play (e.g. the Borganis for me), but I think that is rare .... Of course, YMMV .... the range of such instruments I have tried is very limited.