Saxophones Not worthy of my new Sax!

I love my Selmer Alto Sax but do believe that there is some inconsistency in the brand quality - including mouthpieces, and that they can be rather overpriced. I'd always be a little wary of Meter mouthpieces for similar reasons but there are enough Meyer types out there which are superb. Gilad Atzmon, who plays a Selmer Ref54 Alto uses a Morgan Fry mouthpiece and Marca Jazz reeds to very good effect!
 
Anyway to cut a long story short, when I play the Selmer I just don't feel that I am good enough for it and feel quite disheartened.
Jo x

Setting myself up for abuse I say...a saxophone is a machine. Some are Ferrari's, some are not. If all your life you've driven a Ford Mondeo a Ferrari will be awkward, daunting and downright ****e compared to your old Ford but the more you drive the red machine the more you will despair of that Ford. Right now the 'Ford' is familiar and comforting, the 'Ferrari' will call to you eventually.
 
I sometimes feel the same way about my SML - it should be in the hands of a master; not mine! πŸ™

But then I remember the surge of energy and the swell of pride and enthusiasm it gave me when I first held it and so I try to treat it like Cinderella's evening at the ball - a short time hobnobbing with high society - it pays to make the most of it! πŸ˜€
 
I think my saxes laugh at me behind my back. I may have to start keeping them in separate rooms.

They actually do. I can neatly hear the french accent of two of them while I am the internet.
Chinese made horns are more discreet and the Japanese too respectful.
The American bari is quite loud though.
 
So, lets hear it for decent instruments and the challenge that they can pose for learners and others who have not yet developed the necessary level of skill to make the most of them! C'mon Guys...............!

:bigapplause:

If a more expensive instrument isn't easier to play than a cheap one, it seems to me to be missing the point somewhat.
 
You've gathered I'm not a fan then?

Nick i can see where you are coming from with this,i think Selmer saxes are overrated but there are some great Selmers out there,i own a great markVI i picked it out of 12 VI's free blowing and a great tone and its a players horn,could have sold it a number of times,but there are also a lot of bad VI's out there,i tried a couple recently and they were so much hard work to get them to play and were definatly holding the owner/player back.
I think as players that we are spoilt for choice today with so many good brands at not too expensive prices,horns that are almost a match for the big 4 at half the price although build quality has yet to to be proved but that will answer itself with time.
Going back to the worthy of a sax well these horns just have to be played and enjoyed,after all thats what they were built for.

Brian
 
I'd just like to chip in my 2p to this very interesting thread.

I've only had my sax 3 months or so, so I'm certainly not qualified to say whether you are technically good enough for the new sax, or whether one is better that the other. My gut feeling would be that whichever you like to play best is best for you. However, is this the real issue? My understanding was that you felt that you personally weren't good enough for the new sax, that it was somehow "wasted" on you.

Firstly, I would point out that you say the sax was being sold in memory of someone (presumably now deceased). If it were my sax, I would want to know that the person who got it was enjoying it, whatever their ability or level of experience. So play it and enjoy it!

Secondly, your husband bought it for you as a gift, because he loves you and wanted to give you a token of that love. So maybe you don't sound as good playing it as a pro player, perhaps you never will, but most of the fun in music is the journey and not the destination, so you can enjoy the learning process and look forward to getting to know your new instrument.

I hope you really enjoy the new sax and take it one step at a time. I'm sure you'll reach a stage in your playing career when you think "actually I sound pretty good on this thing".

Very well said, and exactly on topic, and perfectly addresses the issues of the OP.
 
We are all different. We are built differently and have different life's experiences and expectations.

Some of us are large, some small, some like Kenny G >:) some don't, some prefer a bright and centred sound while some go for spread and dark.

So, why should we all like the sound of a Selmer SA80II (or even, GWAD forbid, a Mark VI!) !?!

It's alright not to like it. It ain't necessarily so!

In my previous post I said that this guy (great player) on a Jupiter plays the hell out of it while a lady on her much more expensive Reference 36 doesn't match the sound (.....and playing but that's down to her ability) of this guy on a cheap Jupiter.

Long ago I bought a Selmer Super action 80 II, like new, was priced sympathetically. It didn't do anything to me, exactly as Yanagisawas 901 and 990Β΅ altos....... .

I swapped the Super action 80 II for my King super 20 tenor, the best thing I ever did in my life!


Another time I bought a cheap Amati Super Classic tenor silver plate and goldwash bell. Cheap horn.
It had one f the best sounds that I have ever heard from a Tenor.......not quite in the same league of my Super 20 but close (although different).

You can't ever tell just based on a brad-name, you play the horn and the horn speaks (or not) to you.

Most of us have horns that far exceed our capabilities but that, is not, in itself a bad thing. A super horn, if it speaks to the player, can motivate a player to play more and better. It's something that one has to decide by oneself.
 
I'd just like to chip in my 2p to this very interesting thread.

I've only had my sax 3 months or so, so I'm certainly not qualified to say whether you are technically good enough for the new sax, or whether one is better that the other. My gut feeling would be that whichever you like to play best is best for you. However, is this the real issue? My understanding was that you felt that you personally weren't good enough for the new sax, that it was somehow "wasted" on you.

Firstly, I would point out that you say the sax was being sold in memory of someone (presumably now deceased). If it were my sax, I would want to know that the person who got it was enjoying it, whatever their ability or level of experience. So play it and enjoy it!

Secondly, your husband bought it for you as a gift, because he loves you and wanted to give you a token of that love. So maybe you don't sound as good playing it as a pro player, perhaps you never will, but most of the fun in music is the journey and not the destination, so you can enjoy the learning process and look forward to getting to know your new instrument.

I hope you really enjoy the new sax and take it one step at a time. I'm sure you'll reach a stage in your playing career when you think "actually I sound pretty good on this thing".

Thank you so much for such a heart warming reply πŸ™‚
 
You've gathered I'm not a fan then?

The only Selmer I ever really liked was a MkVI soprano that one of my students owned (great sound but Selmer intonation). Don't get me wrong though - I'd be perfectly happy gigging with a new Selmer (or any other decently built sax). It's just that I have a choice and none of my choices (on sat or b) include Selmers. The sound is nothing special and I especially don't like the effort I have to put in to play them in tune. Some people, of course, parade this as a virtue. "It's flexible, man", with the subtext that the player has the ability to tame this. Much in the same way that some clarinettists regard their instrument as superior to the saxophone purely on the grounds that it's more difficult to play. I subscribe to the opposite view. The instrument should not get in the way of the player - it should facilitate expression not obstruct it.

Yeah, if somebody gave me one, I'd flog it.

Disclaimer:

This may all be an irrational, prejudicial response to the irrational, prejudicial adulation given to the dull old horns known as MkVIs.

You have a lot more experience than me Nick,and I agree that the instrument should not be an obstruction.I recently had a S/H Selmer serie 3 sop and a Yany 991 to play test (before purchase) the Yani won hands down, before they were deliverd to me for trial, I had almost sorted the Selmer (which was dearer) to buy untill I tried them out,The Yani was so user friendly to play all round and good intonation (using a meter) I think the Selmer had an issue with it as the low c sounded , well duff! it hardly played? The sound from the Selmer was no better than the Yani, so I went for the Yani and am still over the moon with it. I did have a Selmer mk 6 tenor years ago and there was one note on it I could not get, (cant remember which one could have been low D or C, I tried hard to make it work, the person who sold it to me said he used to 'play around it/make it work' I wasnt prepared to do that so sold it. I did send it to a tech. and he couldnt fix it.So I havnt had much luck with Selmers (the alto and tenor sa 80, I once owned) were ok but so was my 1st sax a Trevor James alto! lets hope Jo is ok with her Selmer being as she had the opportunity to play test it first.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Jobylou,
I have a Selmer series II tenor which I bought new not all that long after I had started learning.

It's a gorgeous sax with a great sound, fits my small hands well and I love it to bits.
Sounds like you really love yours. :thumb:

You will soon get used to playing it and before long you will really enjoy the music you make on it.

(Practice seems to solve just about everything.) πŸ™‚

all the best,
Pauline
 
I have a Mauriat bari that I don't get the best from yet. I don't do the horn justice, but then I'm still only an intermediate player. When I've been playing for another few years I hope that the bari will really sing her little heart out!

Let yourself grow with the Selmer. Most of all, don't loose sight of why you took up the sax. Enjoyment! Have fun.
 
My Selmer is my pride and joy! Saxophones are very personal, and a lot of criticism of an instrument would be personal to the player, except technical things obviously. It takes a few weeks/months to get used to it, and you will find you begin to sound better too! What mouthpiece do you use? And as to feeling the instrument is better then you, that's nonsense! I reckon you just need a bit of confidence πŸ™‚

Good luck!
Lewis
 
If you look up Gilad Atzmon's website http://www.gilad.co.uk/saxophones-etc/ you will see that he plays a Selmer Alto, Tenor and Baritone, and has settled on his Alto combo after 25 years of playing - a "brilliant Selmer Paris Reference 54..." together with a Morgan Fry mouthpiece and Marca reeds. If Gilad likes Selmers then they are OK for me too!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Setting myself up for abuse I say...a saxophone is a machine. Some are Ferrari's, some are not. If all your life you've driven a Ford Mondeo a Ferrari will be awkward, daunting and downright ****e compared to your old Ford but the more you drive the red machine the more you will despair of that Ford. Right now the 'Ford' is familiar and comforting, the 'Ferrari' will call to you eventually.

I agree ...up to a point.
A Ferrari is a high-spirited, temperamental beast, rather like a thoroughbred stallion, and it takes skill and experience to drive it safely, and enjoyably.
I don't think this is necessarily true of saxophones ....as a really rank beginner I was allowed to try a new Ref 54 Selmer, and I found it a delight, and not at all difficult or temperamental, when compared with my 'intermediate' Hanson SA-5.
OTOH, the 2 Borganis I tried at the same time were as stubborn as mules (as unpleasant to 'drive' as I found a Morgan Plus 8!); I could barely get a squeek from them.
I now have a 'pro quality' alto, recommended to me by Pete, and approved-of by every open-minded person who's tried it
It would be quite suited to a much better player than I will ever be, but I see that as a bonus .... I can see no reason whatsoever to feel 'unworthy' of it. In fact, with respect, I find the whole concept rather odd .... it is, after all, only a very good quality 'tool' or implement, with which I try to make music, and the better it works, the easier it is for me to concentrate on things other than 'fighting' with, for example, clunky keys and intonation quirks.

As for anyone who says "You are not a good enough player to own such an instrument" .... well, I would regard that as extremely discourteous, as well as ignorant, stupid, and potentially very de-motivating 😑
What drives people to say such unpleasant things?
(It's very different from discouraging a 17yo who wants a Porsche 911 ..... an accident lookiing for somewhere to happen!)

I guess that some modern pro-quality instruments may be difficult to play (e.g. the Borganis for me), but I think that is rare .... Of course, YMMV .... the range of such instruments I have tried is very limited.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom