Saxophones Not worthy of my new Sax!

Guys, this is getting out of hand. Please read the first post in the thread before making any more inappropriate negative comments about Selmers.
Indeed ... there are few, if any, 'bad' pro-level saxes out there, but as with cars, we all have our favourites and 'unfavourites'.
The point is that you don't have to be a pro to play and enjoy a pro-quality horn, and you certainly don't need to feel intimidated by it.
Just enjoy its fine handling and intonation ....as someone wrote, you can be assured(unless you are looking for excuses!)that any 'faults' in the sound are down to the player and not the horn 🙂
 
Anyway to cut a long story short, when I play the Selmer I just don't feel that I am good enough for it and feel quite disheartened.

With all due respect 'you probably are not good enough' after only 8 months of playing but that does not mean 'you won't be good enough'
Just keep practicing the basics and eventually you will feel 'good enough' and play the sax that makes you sound better regardless of what make it is.

I was bought a 'Stagg' alto as a present for my 1st sax and believe i produced a nice tone from the stagg and kept using it for 18 months before changing to a Hanson, i only changed the stagg for mainly 1 reason (it was blue in colour) !!! some may like the colour but i didn't 🙁 and still don't, but it got me started playing the sax for which i am very grateful .🙂

I struggled for a while to get a similar tone from the Hanson but i am now getting a nice tone and am happy with it (for now) ;} i have in my mind which alto i eventually want to get, but until i can afford one the Hanson stays.

It's probably hard for you having 2 quality alto's to choose from, i would go with what Mandy says (i think it was her reply) and sell one and you don't have the choice then to go back from one to the other.

But ultimately just enjoy playing 😀
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The sax came with a Meyer 5M but I am sticking to my trusty Yamaha 4C 🙂

Had a great practise with it tonight - thoroughly enjoyed every moment, time to be positive and look to the future - I can only get better (I hope!!!)

Jo x

I'm glad you had a really good practice🙂 It's a fabulous feeling when you really connect with the instrument and with the music and everything just slots into place. Even at my early stage, I sometimes have those sessions where I really feel it's all working well (and of course quite a few where I feel like I probably sound like a duck being squashed by a truck...)
 
If you continue to practise, Jo, you will 'get better', no doubt about it 🙂
It may not happen as quickly as you'd hoped (that was my problem with my previous, short-lived failure to get going on sax....impatience!)
The first thing my teacher said this time was that I must be patient, because progress would be slow(and he was correct) 🙂

(I was always a sprinter, not a marathon man ;} )

But, Trimmy, with equal respect, as I said previously, I don't understand this concept of 'not good enough' to play a pro sax: what qualifies one to do so?
To go back to the car analogy, it would be the same as a newly-qualified driver's buying (say) a Rolls-Royce of the same size and power as his/her Ford Focus .... virtually everything about it would be made to closer tolerances, of better-quality materials, hand-built and carefully tuned.
It would be no harder to drive ... quite the contrary ... and the whole air of quality and luxury would make it a more pleasurable experience.
Of course a beginner is more likely to accumulate 'bumps and scrapes', but, even then, the superior build quality of the Rolls means that it would be more durable.
(Of course, there are pro saxes which are rather 'delicate and fragile' and 'hard to play', but I believe they are the exception.)
 
But, Trimmy, with equal respect, as I said previously, I don't understand this concept of 'not good enough' to play a pro sax: what qualifies one to do so?

I didn't mention pro sax, what i highlighted was 'her' belief that she was not good enough, i was agreeing with jobylou on how she felt, which is why didn't highlight 'for it'
I then went on to say "play the sax that makes you sound better regardless of what make it is". what i was trying to say was practice, practice, practice, and 'your' sound will come regardless of make. 🙂
 
I agree ...up to a point.
A Ferrari is a high-spirited, temperamental beast, rather like a thoroughbred stallion, and it takes skill and experience to drive it safely, and enjoyably.
I don't think this is necessarily true of saxophones ....as a really rank beginner I was allowed to try a new Ref 54 Selmer, and I found it a delight, and not at all difficult or temperamental, when compared with my 'intermediate' Hanson SA-5.
OTOH, the 2 Borganis I tried at the same time were as stubborn as mules (as unpleasant to 'drive' as I found a Morgan Plus 8!); I could barely get a squeek from them.
I now have a 'pro quality' alto, recommended to me by Pete, and approved-of by every open-minded person who's tried it
It would be quite suited to a much better player than I will ever be, but I see that as a bonus .... I can see no reason whatsoever to feel 'unworthy' of it. In fact, with respect, I find the whole concept rather odd .... it is, after all, only a very good quality 'tool' or implement, with which I try to make music, and the better it works, the easier it is for me to concentrate on things other than 'fighting' with, for example, clunky keys and intonation quirks.

As for anyone who says "You are not a good enough player to own such an instrument" .... well, I would regard that as extremely discourteous, as well as ignorant, stupid, and potentially very de-motivating 😡
What drives people to say such unpleasant things?
(It's very different from discouraging a 17yo who wants a Porsche 911 ..... an accident lookiing for somewhere to happen!)

I guess that some modern pro-quality instruments may be difficult to play (e.g. the Borganis for me), but I think that is rare .... Of course, YMMV .... the range of such instruments I have tried is very limited.


I was merely trying to encourage the OP, not imply that a top-of-the-range saxophone was out of their league, that would be silly as anyone who can play a sax can play any saxophone to a greater or lesser extent (soprillo's aside! ;} ).
 
Feelings of inadequacy are misplaced. Rather, one should look upon this opportunity as an impetus towards redoubling one's efforts towards improving one's performance skills. In plain, non-Vulcan english, a sax is a sax so don't be intimidated! You've gotten lucky and now have a better sax than what you had. All that means is that it should be easier to play well on! You now need to keep practicing so that you will live up to the potential that your "new" sax will afford you!
 
You've gathered I'm not a fan then?

The only Selmer I ever really liked was a MkVI soprano that one of my students owned (great sound but Selmer intonation). Don't get me wrong though - I'd be perfectly happy gigging with a new Selmer (or any other decently built sax). It's just that I have a choice and none of my choices (on sat or b) include Selmers. The sound is nothing special and I especially don't like the effort I have to put in to play them in tune. Some people, of course, parade this as a virtue. "It's flexible, man", with the subtext that the player has the ability to tame this. Much in the same way that some clarinettists regard their instrument as superior to the saxophone purely on the grounds that it's more difficult to play. I subscribe to the opposite view. The instrument should not get in the way of the player - it should facilitate expression not obstruct it.

Yeah, if somebody gave me one, I'd flog it.

Disclaimer:

This may all be an irrational, prejudicial response to the irrational, prejudicial adulation given to the dull old horns known as MkVIs.

Don't knock em M8..I bought two good Yamahas..YBS32(used ) & YTS82ZUL(new) and still had a lot of drinking dosh left over with the proceeds of the sale(2004) of a MKVI I bought in Poland in 1977 for the equivalent of £70.00..🙂

Ohhhh...almost forgot the Conn Xbar that I paid £40.00 at the same time...like an idiot I sold that c1980 for I think £270-300 'ish'
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hi Jo, I hope you feel encourage to keep playing the Selmer. I had my first sax, a Tone King, that I have recently learned was made by Keilwerth. I had this 10 years, and it never went for servicing as I couldn't afford it or do it myself. I had the opportunity to buy a second hand Yanigasawa which was a different class of machine. Suited me much better. The only regret I have is not getting a 'better sax' sooner.
I've never owned a Selmer. I've avoided the new ones as I believe there are equally good saxes that suit me for less money. I've played a couple of older altos (a cigar cutter and a Mk VI, I think) and they were nice. If I won the lottery, I'd definitely give them a try.
In short, you are now the proud owner of a good if not great instrumnet, so get playing and enjoy it. You'll only get better by playing it, not talking about whether you're "good enough". Most of the players we all love and admire must have had doubts too, but that's inexperience.
"Wax on, wax off" - practice the small things and contentment will come in time.
 
Hi Doodah!
Thank you for your reply. To be honest I am beginning to think that also sax is not really my instrument at the moment 🙁 When I play it I spend more time changing reeds and mouthpieces and faffing around because I am not keen on the sound that I make, I seem to have issues with alto for some reason. While the Selmer was being checked over I played my Tenor (bought last year but at the time I found it too bulky and awkward), what a difference - I just put the Yamaha 5C that it came with and any old reed , and off I go, no messing just playing and enjoying. I am getting used to its bulkyness more now too 🙂
I so wanted to play alto really well and perhaps in time I will but I have put my altos away for now and am concentrating on Tenor so I use my time more constructively. Perhaps in a few months I can try alto again and wont be so fed up. For now I am enjoying my musical adventure!!!
By the way - Wax on Wax off is very appropriate - I have my Karate Black Belt Grading coming up in 7 weeks! 🙂
Jo x
 
Enjoy the tenor - any playing will develop your sax skills on all sax instruments, so your alto playing will benefit. I certainlythink that getting a good sound on the alto is harder than on the tenor, and benefits from a good airstream together with a sufficiently loose embouchure - i.e. a well developed embouchure. Particularly when you start on alto it is common to create an embouchure through tightening the facial muscles a little too much, which affects tone.

When you have been playing the tenor for a while, it may be useful to briefly switch to the alto and try and play it "as if it were a tenor", just to see how that affects tone. Playing a tenor mouthpiece does open the embouchure somewhat and usually allows a wider airstream, which can produce a good tone.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom