Playing the saxophone New Ruling re Playing at Home

Well... if we're going to class budding musicians as brats, there's very little point to being a musician. I know it annoys the neighbours, but a good concert musician needs at least four hours a day and it's not like you can take a grand piano with you to a practice room.

I give my neighbours a break by going out busking to run through the repertoire, but some pieces are hard won and don't come easily, so need thrashing out. I bought an end terrace so I only have neighbours one side. Ideally a detached dwelling in the middle of nowhere is needed. Second best would be a mobile home. That would work for woodwind. Can't imagine a caravan would handle too well with a concert grand in it.
 
We called them "brats" because they were being selfish.
They have all that money and can well afford to buy a studio for the purpose. It seems to me like a case of self entitlement and disregard of other people. That is "bratty".
Professional rock bands don't practice in their parents homes once they can afford not to.
The opinions and comments made by myself are in context with the original article.
 
Last edited:
By practising? That's not selfish.

How their parents have acted, that would appear to be selfish. They seem to have the financial ability to find a solution if they could be bothered. The children don't have a choice - they either practise where their parents tell them to or they don't practise.

Calling them brats is unfair at best.
 
We should probably be careful of judging either side from what we read in the papers!

The important thing is that there is recognition that musicians need time to practice. Not everyone can afford to buy a detached house and I recall reading here and hearing of others elsewhere struggling to play at home because of neighbours. It is difficult enough earning a living as a musician without having to contend with complaining neighbours.Though I can sympathise with anyone having to listen to serious practising day in day out, as we all know for the listener, scales and repetitive playing of the same piece to get it right can be tiresome.

Let's not judge either side......

Jx
 
I realise that this was discussed 9 years ago. What I found interesting was we have the exact same problem in US. Parties seek resolution through the expensive court system.

After reading through this thread and the news articles regarding the complaint and legal resolution, my first thought was, did either party make an effort to get to know each other?

The family on the other side, perhaps invite them over, teach their kids a little piano keyboarding? Buy them a decent but relatively inexpensive electronic piano? Have them over for a special meal?

Sometimes people are impossibly difficult, but would a little ombudsmanship net a greater tolerance?

These little kind things are certainly much less expensive than hiring lawyers, perhaps even be the impetus for a neighbourhood combo? Start a garage band? 😉
 
Yes, in an ideal world we ought to be able to simply resolve suych things. Unfortunately, some people are unreasonable/intolerant.

I have a friend who is a music teacher. They are in the process of moving from Yorkshire to near here but have had to rent a house temporarily whilst waiting for the sale of their house to go through. Their neighbour won't even tolerate two minutes of playing/singing, despite being perfectly entitled to teach from home. In this case I suspect an elderly person with early signs of dementia which means 'reasoning' isn't going to be effective.
 
I used to rent and organize concerts at a very nice place. An old cinema from c 1910. Built for silent movie. A very cool venue. 120 sitting audience and a small bar. One time an older man, who was living in the building came down and ska me when the concert was going to end. He couldn't sleep. "This song ans one more" I answered him. An then I told the band. Even if the cinema was to allow to have amplified concerts, I could identify with the old man. It was not just the music, it's was also after the music when PA, lights, instruments were loaded into cars at the backyard.

On Saturday I'm going to have my annual dose of Thorbjörn Risager & the Black Tornardo! Another great venue place. In a small village. The music is not distorbing, it's the cars. Solhällan, the name of the venue place, was built when the folks walked or used a bicycle to get to the venue place.

If a person is in the final stage of life and decided to take the last breaths at home and there is a concert in the house or in the neighbourhood. We want live music but ....... . No easy questions .... .
 
When we got married in the mid 1980's, we were living in a small apartment complex shaped like a quad with a central courtyard. It was mostly pensioners living there.

My wife is petite and we married when she in her early 30's, I in my late 20's. They thought I was shacking up with a teen. The pensioner next door to us told them, "No, she is a real woman." :confused:

One senior, a woman was like the defacto "apartment manager". In the flat across from us, a pensioner was having a birthday party. This "Karen" complained about their celebrating in broad daylight. The pensioner celebree told her, "I only have one birthday a year!" 😛

We were only there for about 6 months. (Single, I lived there for a couple years.)

A new owner who purchased the flat at about the time we were leaving, rented it to a bunch of sailors.

My thoughts were, "Deserves them right!" >:)
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,059
Messages
578,324
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom