Tech/maintenance New Neck ‘How to make it fit?’

Paul, be sure to mask off the laquered area of the tenon otherwise the wire wool will scratch the lacquer.

let us know howyou get on.

Thanks Griff! I'll remember to mask off (Its a beautiful looking neck so would be a shame to scratch it).

Hopefully I should able to pick up the materials tomorrow if I haven't got any kicking around in the workshop. I'll post back the results!
 
Paul says that the last 0.25" is very tight, so we are talking about more than couple of thou.
My fear is that the neck sleeve has had a knock during manufacture before being assembled to the crook, and is oval for the last 0.25" inch. (it is unlikely to be tapered). That would mean that it is out of round, being oversize in diametrically opposed areas and undersize in others. Bringing it back to round would mean that that last 0.25" of the diameter will be undersize and possibly leak.

As for not being cross about something like this. In my previous life I was a mechanical inspector in the manufacture of weapons. Finishing up in the Aviation business, inspecting gas turbine components during overhaul (believe me, I know what 0.0001" looks like!). I had two creeds - "Near enough is not good enough", and "Give them an inch and they will take a mile". This crook is a sloppy piece of work, it should fit, and IMOH should be returned. Get the dimensions (as above) and send them off with the crook. Don't take the easy way out Paul, it wasn't cheap. You might live to regret it!!!

Sorry for my rantings everyone, but don't ever be fobbed off. I have seen too many things go downhill because people just couldn't be bothered.

John.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well, without seeing the tenon in question, it is all just guesswork about out of round and lack of taper. Necks that I have seen and measured do have a slight taper on the tenon. As you probably know, when the fit is designed as a tight tolerance, it doesn't take much to make it go from "snug" to "super tight".

Yanagisawa have some of the most accurate manufacturing and best quality control processes in the business, miles better than Selmer, Keilwerth and probably Yamaha too.

It just takes some accurate measurements to settle the reason, or a few minutes adjustment by a decent tech to sort out the problem.

No need to get bent out of shape 🙂

Rhys (former nuclear design engineer who knows a thing or two about measurements and saxophones)
 
Thanks John! I took the vernier to the crook and it is tapered slightly whereas the sax measures straight with an internal micrometer. I'm sure rubbing the neck with wire wool will bring it down to size as it is less than a thou. I'm sure this is what is done regularly when a sax is set-up to ensure connecting and removing the crook is with ease.

As an ex-engineer myself it should be pretty straight forward. Unfortunately I can't seem to find any in my workshop despite knowing I have three huge rolls somewhere. Note to self - tidy up more often!!!
 
I'm sure rubbing the neck with wire wool will bring it down to size as it is less than a thou. QUOTE]

A thou with 0000 - next suggestion will be T cut....

Good luck with this, as a local tech once said to me in reply to my intended repair efforts, just let me have it when your done & I'll do it properly!

I do believe each neck to be hand fitted to the body, therefore custom necks may (rarely) fit..

Hope you post a soundclip of each neck so that we can all guess which is which?!
 
T Cut 🙂)) That's a good one!

I believe the wire wool will work and will post back once I've done it! I agree with you that each neck has to be hand fitted to a body. I also believe the manufacture leave a little extra on to ensure it'll fit any of their sax's as some may have worn over the years. Each one is going to be a little different!

Posting a soundclip of each neck once sorted sounds like a good idea, but I'm sure everyone will be able to tell the difference as the 92 has quite a distinctive warmth to it compared the original 901 neck.
 
As you have already changed the neck you should go the whole hog and change the rest of the sax - you would then have a Yani A992, which is a much better instrument - problem solved........!:shocked::w00t:;}

Love and Cuddles
Tom😎😎😎
 
As you have already changed the neck you should go the whole hog and change the rest of the sax - you would then have a Yani A992, which is a much better instrument - problem solved........!:shocked::w00t:;}

Love and Cuddles
Tom😎😎

🙂)) I've only just got the A901!

However, I did look at the A992 and admit it is a very nice horn but I do actually prefer the sound of the A901 with a 92 Neck, as you know!
 
A few comments.

First up (and please excuse me while I raise my voice) SAXOPHONES ARE NOT WATCHES!!
If you're looking for precision fits and accuracy down to tiny fractions of a millimetre, the saxophone is going to be a source of considerable disappointment.

Second up - never, ever, no not ever attempt to have at the crook socket. Don't even think about it. Don't even think about thinking about it. Stop it right now.
Banging things into it - no. Poking things in the slot - no.
Whenever I have to do work to a socket I always take a long, deep breath...if you make but a single mistake it can prove to be very costly indeed to put right.
Tenon sleeves are no problem - they can be expanded and contracted almost with abandon.

There's usually plenty of 'meat' on a tenon sleeve, so if you find yourself struggling with a stiff crook it's quite acceptable to think in terms of removing a little metal. It's never going to be a great deal if the crook halfway fits.
To put that in perspective - an easily fitting crook can be turned into one that will hardly fit at all by spraying an extremely thin coat of lacquer on the tenon sleeve. It's a common problem with cheap horns, where lacquer has found its way onto the sleeve - all it takes is a few minutes with some quadruple 0 gauge wire wool and it's sorted.

In this case I'd suggest getting hold of a sheet of 800 grade wet and dry paper and slicing it into strips - the width of the strip should be slightly larger than the amount of tenon sleeve left sticking out of the top of the socket when the crook has been pushed in as far as it will easily go. I wouldn't recommend using a grit any coarser - you might be over-surprised at how very little metal you need to remove.
Have an assistant hold the crook with the sleeve facing you - grab each end of the wet and dry strip, place it over the area to be treated, drop your hands down a few inches so that the strip curves around the sleeve then simply 'rag' it back and forth - as though polishing a boot with a strip of cloth.
Give it four or five passes then have the assistant slightly rotate the crook, and repeat.
Go round the circumference once, wipe the tenon clean (sloosh some cigaratte lighter fluid over it to ensure you remove all the grit) then test for fit. Repeat as required.
Once it's a firm fit I would finish up with quad. 0 wire wool - but you could also use a bit of Brasso (or an even finer grade of W&D, such as 1200), just to knock down the scratches. Other than that, a few weeks use will do much the same job.

Regards,
 
Stop it teebones ... your killin me ...

I Don't Belive it
Would That Be a Left or Right Handed Birmingham Screwdriver
.>:) 🙂))🙂))

Wonder What Sunray Thinks ;}

Tony (another old git):mrcool

After getting up off the floor, with a stomach ache from laughing View attachment 675

I decided to check "Urban Dictionary" to see if there was both a left and a right ...

Here is what they say: A Quote ...

Birmingham Screwdriver

A hammer. Usually used on delicate devices when a real screwdriver would be better. Refers to the habit of a Birmingham inhabitant (i.e. a simpleton] to take a rather simplistic view of maintenance.

If it don't work - hit it.

If it still don't work, use a bigger hammer.

Ay, Jimmeh, pass uz tha' Birmingham Screwdriver - Oi can't geh this new graphics card in this bastard compu'er wivaht a slight modifahcation ...

Whack!! There, snug as yo' mum ...

------------------

I did find these though ...
View attachment 676 View attachment 677

Please don't post again teebones ... it hurts soooo much ... 🙂))
 
A few comments.

First up (and please excuse me while I raise my voice) SAXOPHONES ARE NOT WATCHES!!
If you're looking for precision fits and accuracy down to tiny fractions of a millimetre, the saxophone is going to be a source of considerable disappointment.

Second up - never, ever, no not ever attempt to have at the crook socket. Don't even think about it. Don't even think about thinking about it. Stop it right now.
Banging things into it - no. Poking things in the slot - no.
Whenever I have to do work to a socket I always take a long, deep breath...if you make but a single mistake it can prove to be very costly indeed to put right.
Tenon sleeves are no problem - they can be expanded and contracted almost with abandon.

There's usually plenty of 'meat' on a tenon sleeve, so if you find yourself struggling with a stiff crook it's quite acceptable to think in terms of removing a little metal. It's never going to be a great deal if the crook halfway fits.
To put that in perspective - an easily fitting crook can be turned into one that will hardly fit at all by spraying an extremely thin coat of lacquer on the tenon sleeve. It's a common problem with cheap horns, where lacquer has found its way onto the sleeve - all it takes is a few minutes with some quadruple 0 gauge wire wool and it's sorted.

In this case I'd suggest getting hold of a sheet of 800 grade wet and dry paper and slicing it into strips - the width of the strip should be slightly larger than the amount of tenon sleeve left sticking out of the top of the socket when the crook has been pushed in as far as it will easily go. I wouldn't recommend using a grit any coarser - you might be over-surprised at how very little metal you need to remove.
Have an assistant hold the crook with the sleeve facing you - grab each end of the wet and dry strip, place it over the area to be treated, drop your hands down a few inches so that the strip curves around the sleeve then simply 'rag' it back and forth - as though polishing a boot with a strip of cloth.
Give it four or five passes then have the assistant slightly rotate the crook, and repeat.
Go round the circumference once, wipe the tenon clean (sloosh some cigaratte lighter fluid over it to ensure you remove all the grit) then test for fit. Repeat as required.
Once it's a firm fit I would finish up with quad. 0 wire wool - but you could also use a bit of Brasso (or an even finer grade of W&D, such as 1200), just to knock down the scratches. Other than that, a few weeks use will do much the same job.

Regards,

Thanks for the detailed and informative reply!
 
Thank-you guys!

Firstly I'd like to thank everyone that has replied to this thread! It has been a most interesting read :w00t:

I tried Griff's idea first with some Wire Wool (Grade: 000) but it didn't seem to remove as much brass as needed.

So I opted for Stephens method and used 800 grit. However, I also took the advice of the Tech from the dealer and sanded the whole Tenon evenly. It didn't take many passes before it fitted. I used the wire wool to polish it up and cleaned the Socket and Tenon with Meths.

I took Griff's advice to mask up the crook which was very fortunate as I slipped a couple of time which would have put a minute scratches on the crook!

I haven't taken it down to a loose fit though! It is now snug. It glides in smoothly almost all the way then gets a snug the very last 1/64th inch which suits me and no doubt will bed in over the coming weeks!

At least I don't have to fight it to get it on and off now 😀
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,562
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom