Tech/maintenance Need to use low B/Bb when playing low A

Both Weltklangs and Amati to low A had low A pinky key.
The Martin Baritone Magna to low A had lh thumb - and rh hand thumb keys for low A thump.

 
The so-called "Selmer USA" baritones, which are really Buescher 400s, branded also as Bundy, use a similar extension concept as the Conn 11M. I believe these extensions are actually cylindrical and the bell section is identical to the low Bb bell..
Yeah, the B is just a chunk of extra tube, with a tone hole in there somewhere...

The Selmer Signet keywork for the right pinky is really a mess- they kept the Bb compromises
and added another for the low A. I've got one (sorta) working, but the musician in the family
says she won't play it until I remake it so it plays in a less- medieval fashion...
...and I'd like for it to stay in regulation, too...

t
 
Weltklnags low A baris were also a cylindrical extension. UMI Conn baritone 13M had/have the cylindracal extension. The Buescher 400/Bundy like I have seen had the bell key holes on the backside of the bell. But I know that there was a low A Bundy. A bari with low A cylinindeical designhave a more basson voice.
 
Not sure if they were the similar to the 11M which seemed to be a 12M with a (conical?) bell extension and so adapted key. It was always going to be a compromise and yes, I get never get a low without fingering Bb as well.

You've also got to give someone credit for actually thinking of the left thumb A rather than an extra pinky key.
I give them that credit - the problem was...it took around a decade for the kinks to get worked out of the thumb trigger to the degree where the design and shape was stout enough to actually leverage ALL the bellkeys closed. Thus you get that problem on the Bundy/Buescher, 11M, Noblet/Beaugnier/Vito, and I think there was some other maker I have worked on where the same issue existed.

Personally tho...I dunno....I just always preferred the Low A to be under my pinky, as well as under my thumb. I agree that when the trigger moved to the thumb, it would have been preferable to still keep a pinky touch for it as well. Certainly doable, mechanically speaking.
 
Is it me, or do the best baritone sounds come from low Bb baritone saxes?

Also...

Does the venerable low Bb baritone look slicker and more saxy and less like an antediluvian brass Dyson?
When Selmer-Balanced Action baritone the low A was introduced in 1952 the debate of low Bb vs low A started. Today low A is standard for a baritone saxophone. Our ears became used to the low A sound, they contiuned to to wright and arrange music in the key of concert C and baritone specialists didn't have to own two baris. Can we say that the low A bari was a way to make more money? Commercial -, big band - popular music was/is the low A best distance? Our ears and the players wallets got used to low A baris 😉.

A rare "The Martin Magna Baritone" to low A is a powerful machine. Big bell and flare. Blows most other low A baris into the corner.
 
Last edited:
Or just a spiralling cone ?

I expect that someone has made one already.

Rhys
Not quite spiralling

341px-Manifattura_italiana%2C_Serpentone%2C_fine_sec._XVIII._Museo_Civico_di_Modena%2C_foto_P._Terzi.jpg
 
I learned a lot of this thread - basically that there are lot's of hidden problems where I didn't see one yet. On my Jupiter 893 I hit the thumb key and all the low keys close with a solid low A sound.
My Bauhaus bari performs the same satisfying trick

Reading @Stephen Howard's observations on low A mechanisms, it seems my bari low A lever is a Yamaha clone

Does your Jupiter have the same template?
 
It would no longer be an Eb instrument.

It would still be the same tube length as a lowA bari with tone holes in the same relative positions but with the bends in different places
I understand both of these, but it may all depend on semantics.

In order to be a baritone in a different key the tone hole spacing would need to be different.

I took it to mean same length as a “normal” low a baritone but with a shorter bell but longer pigtail and with toneholes in same position relative to the mouthpiece. I suppose the same difference as a short wrap and long wrap bass.

It could potentially make the low A linkage less awkward maybe?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,396
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom