Tech/maintenance Neck/Crook surgery?

There was an idea I was working on many years ago, but never got around to putting into practice - and this involves the use of ball bearings and magnets.
Simply put, pop a pea-sized ballbearing into the crook, stick a magnet on the outside to secure it in place. Move it up and down for best effect. Add more ballbearings if you like, and/or vary the size. Wrap the magnets in tape to prevent scratching.
I have no idea how effective this might be or even if it'll make any difference - but the big thing it's got going for it is that it's dead cheap and easy to fiddle with on the fly.
If a result can be achieved, the process can be moved on to considering how to make the modification permanent.

I like it! Experimental, not permanent. Good thinking! Not sure I have any ball bearings, but have some scrap metal around and hopefully a magnet that's strong enough. We're in total lockdown currently here in New Zealand so I can't go get anything, will just have to see what bits and pieces I've got that could make a difference. Thanks Stephen!
 
In my study of saxophone acoustics I have found that the "effective volume" of the mouthpiece must be a close match to the volume of the "calculated" missing cone. The "effective volume" is the geometric volume inside the mouthpiece past the end of the neck (crook) plus the volume added by the movement of the reed. For anyone interested I have attached a summary of my attempt to replicate Benade's method for calculating the "effective volume" on my Rousseau alto mouthpiece.

My conclusion would be that a "small chamber" mouthpiece therefore would need to be pulled out farther than a large chamber one in order to meet this requirement. Of course changing the length of the instrument by moving the mouthpiece will have an effect upon the overall pitch.

Ferron in "The Saxophone is My Voice" writes that making the tube more conical makes the octaves narrower and making the tube more cylindrical makes the octaves wider. When the tube becomes completely cylindrical, the octaves are widened enough to become 12ths as on a clarinet.

In this instance a case could be made to play lower on the mouthpiece input pitch and push the mouthpiece on farther to compensate which is what some jazz players do, but that changes the number and strength of the harmonics present and therefore the tone quality.
Very kind of you to send this information. Not sure I can find a standard mouthpiece that's got a small enough chamber to correct this. The other consideration is tone, which depends on the specific mouthpiece. What's special about this horn is the tone. Would be a shame to defeat that in order to play in tune. Have you got in mind a relatively inexpensive very small chamber mouthpiece? Maybe I can temporarily fill in the chamber of one of the ones I've got? Thanks btsax.
 
OK, I misjudged. You understand, there are a lot of beginners that come on here complaining about 5 cents here and 10 cents there when they don't even have a stable embouchure.

In that case, the only thing I've got is the small chamber piece, and I'm not sure about that one.
 
OK, have given a try to filling up the chamber of a Morgan Excalibur mouthpiece about 1/3. It works! But is sounds like crap. Thanks to those of you who persisted in seeing this as a potential remedy. It unfortunately puts me back finding a great sounding mouthpiece with a very small chamber. Probably not impossible, but I really like my large chambers for the tone I use. Any suggestions? Oh, and I will still give a try with the magnets and bits in the crook.

Thanks again all.
 
Last edited:
I know that you are an experienced member but because I had a similar question when I tried to adapt to a beugnier sax that has a similar neck geometry with JKs, and with the experience I had with a friends JK tenor ... both "solved" with a slightly different mouthpiece/reed approach please try 2 things:

1) move to a really large chamber and a slightly closer mouthpiece. Those rich tone slightly larger bore saxophones can benefit from that. The closer mouthpiece will lead to playin a harder reed of course BUT .... intonation issues will (hopefuly) be cured and the sound will be fat and powerful.

I'm not a treble ear piercing sound player .... I play with very old school traditional setups and this has been an easy transition for me .

My vintage vibe Yanagisawa needs nothing. It can play anyt setup you want .... but the sound of the Beaugnier is second to none.

I compare my Beaugnier directly to a JK because I have swapped its stock neck with a JK neck and it played without any intonation issues. same bigger diameter and everything. So there must be some resemblance in the geometry.

So try t a truly large chamber - slightly harder reed - smaller tip mouthpiece. It's a cheap "experiment" or even free if anyone can give you an "old fashioned" jazz or classical mouthpiece to try.
 
Maybe I don't understand the suggestion. Wouldn't extending the neck make the instrument longer and lower the pitch even further?
No, you keep the distance from tip of MP to the horn (any point you choose) about the same. If the neck is 3/8" longer, it reduces that effective volume in the MP, but it does so as far away from the tone generating part of the MP as possible. Think about it. If you play your horn with your preferred mouthpiece when it's hot and you're pulled way out, then you play the same setup when it's cold and you're pushed way in, the general tonal quality really isn't affected much if at all. So from the tonal standpoint extending the neck further into the mouthpiece bore is the same thing.

I believe that the closer to the tip you modify the internals of the mouthpiece, the bigger the effect.

The Conn 6M was designed with the micro tuner with the idea that you would determine the best place on the cork for your particular mouthpiece, then screw the tuner in and out to keep that place. I did the experiment, with a tuner, and what I found was that between the tuner screwed all the way in and the MP 1/2" or more out, vs. the MP pushed all the way in and the tuner screwed out about the same distance, made only very small and subtle differences in tone and tuning.

So OP's concern about losing the tone he likes using a larger chamber piece on this particular horn, might not be a problem if the chamber volume reduction happens down where the MP pushes onto the cork. Now that said, note that I also said that variations in tuning were also minor in my 6M experiment. So the chance that OP will get the pitch of the thing to go up as much as he wants, with the same MP position, is probably not that great. But it's an easy thing to simulate - you can cut some shirt cardboard, roll it up in the end of the MP, shove it on and see - or you could temporarily glue some thick sheet cork to the end of the neck. Then shove the MP on to the same distance from tip of MP to [registration point] and see what happens. Easy, fast, fully reversible.

The key dimension for an accurate scale is the distance from the tip of the MP to [registration point of your choice on the horn; I generally use the octave vent].

This is why when people chopped 1/2" off all those Louis Lot flutes in the 1930s that were built to A = 435, and pushed in, to supposedly play them at A=440, all the high notes got sharp and the low notes got flat; and then an entire two generations of flute pedagogy were developed based on people playing A = 435 flutes at A = 440 with a scale too long for the pitch.

Whole point is that some experimentation is going to be required. If your experimental results make the problem WORSE, then you've learned that doing the opposite has a good chance of making it BETTER. I also suspect that in the end, some compromises will have to be made, and OP will have to accept some degree of sharp upper register in order to play the horn "in tune" (compromise).

Might be worth getting a grab bag of cheap necks (from various models), getting them roughly fitted to the horn, and seeing what intonation effect each one has.
 
I know that you are an experienced member but because I had a similar question when I tried to adapt to a beugnier sax that has a similar neck geometry with JKs, and with the experience I had with a friends JK tenor ... both "solved" with a slightly different mouthpiece/reed approach please try 2 things:

1) move to a really large chamber and a slightly closer mouthpiece. Those rich tone slightly larger bore saxophones can benefit from that. The closer mouthpiece will lead to playin a harder reed of course BUT .... intonation issues will (hopefuly) be cured and the sound will be fat and powerful.

I'm not a treble ear piercing sound player .... I play with very old school traditional setups and this has been an easy transition for me .

My vintage vibe Yanagisawa needs nothing. It can play anyt setup you want .... but the sound of the Beaugnier is second to none.

I compare my Beaugnier directly to a JK because I have swapped its stock neck with a JK neck and it played without any intonation issues. same bigger diameter and everything. So there must be some resemblance in the geometry.

So try t a truly large chamber - slightly harder reed - smaller tip mouthpiece. It's a cheap "experiment" or even free if anyone can give you an "old fashioned" jazz or classical mouthpiece to try.
Just happens that one of the mouthpieces I use is a Morgan Jazz with a smaller tip than what I'd normally use (a 5 instead of an 8 or 9) and stiffer reed (Fiberreed MH instead of Fiberreed M). If there is a difference it's not enough as the problem is still there. I'm not sure that going further in that direction would make as much difference as a really small chamber. The problem (from my point of view) is gross, so requires a fairly major shift in the neck or mouthpiece. Swapping necks would be very interesting, but I'm not even sure that a JK neck will fit on a GK horn. Related by blood, but not necessarily by design. This horn is a hand made prototype, which probably explains a lot...especially why it never made it into production. It's quite heavy at 2.6 kg. (my Borgani tenor is only 3.2 Kg.). I checked the Martin neck against the GK and it's quite a lot smaller, so bigger bore geometry. I might try wrapping the Martin neck in a lot of Teflon tape and see what that does (if anything). The octave key configuration is an OK match. Will report back on that if it's better/different.
 
No, you keep the distance from tip of MP to the horn (any point you choose) about the same. If the neck is 3/8" longer, it reduces that effective volume in the MP, but it does so as far away from the tone generating part of the MP as possible. Think about it. If you play your horn with your preferred mouthpiece when it's hot and you're pulled way out, then you play the same setup when it's cold and you're pushed way in, the general tonal quality really isn't affected much if at all. So from the tonal standpoint extending the neck further into the mouthpiece bore is the same thing.

I believe that the closer to the tip you modify the internals of the mouthpiece, the bigger the effect.

The Conn 6M was designed with the micro tuner with the idea that you would determine the best place on the cork for your particular mouthpiece, then screw the tuner in and out to keep that place. I did the experiment, with a tuner, and what I found was that between the tuner screwed all the way in and the MP 1/2" or more out, vs. the MP pushed all the way in and the tuner screwed out about the same distance, made only very small and subtle differences in tone and tuning.

So OP's concern about losing the tone he likes using a larger chamber piece on this particular horn, might not be a problem if the chamber volume reduction happens down where the MP pushes onto the cork. Now that said, note that I also said that variations in tuning were also minor in my 6M experiment. So the chance that OP will get the pitch of the thing to go up as much as he wants, with the same MP position, is probably not that great. But it's an easy thing to simulate - you can cut some shirt cardboard, roll it up in the end of the MP, shove it on and see - or you could temporarily glue some thick sheet cork to the end of the neck. Then shove the MP on to the same distance from tip of MP to [registration point] and see what happens. Easy, fast, fully reversible.

The key dimension for an accurate scale is the distance from the tip of the MP to [registration point of your choice on the horn; I generally use the octave vent].

This is why when people chopped 1/2" off all those Louis Lot flutes in the 1930s that were built to A = 435, and pushed in, to supposedly play them at A=440, all the high notes got sharp and the low notes got flat; and then an entire two generations of flute pedagogy were developed based on people playing A = 435 flutes at A = 440 with a scale too long for the pitch.

Whole point is that some experimentation is going to be required. If your experimental results make the problem WORSE, then you've learned that doing the opposite has a good chance of making it BETTER. I also suspect that in the end, some compromises will have to be made, and OP will have to accept some degree of sharp upper register in order to play the horn "in tune" (compromise).

Might be worth getting a grab bag of cheap necks (from various models), getting them roughly fitted to the horn, and seeing what intonation effect each one has.

I think I get what you're saying and it's about filling up the space from the end of the neck to the mouthpiece. The amount of hot melt I put into the mouthpiece to fill up the chamber which eventually changed the pitch was nearly a full stick or around 10 ml. (a lot!). Unfortunately the mouthpieces are already pushed on nearly to the end where the intonation sweet spot is. There's not much potential difference there maybe 1 ml to fill? Would be much more difference if only half way down, but it's not. The volume to fill/change is fairly gross considering.

Big thanks to all who have been contributing to this discussion. Makes me appreciate the engineering side of what makes for a good sax.
 
OK I wrapped the Martin alto neck tenon with Teflon tape and got a tight fit on to the GK body. Mouthpiece on, tune to itself using B and 3 harmonics. The horn was flat! What a surprise when the diameter of the neck at the tenon is smaller! So I try tuning to compromise between the high register and the low and it's worse than with the GK neck.

Lesson learned: yes the neck can make a difference, and the difference can be worse. I heard back from KB saxophone services who make necks and they didn't know what to do either.

So theoretically, if using the Martin neck can make the problem much worse is it possible that whatever would have been the opposite would have made it much better? Hmmmm...???? Still have to get the bits together to do the neck and magnet experiment. Haven't been able to find more than one magnet, and it's not strong enough. May have to wait a while as we are in total lockdown in New Zealand.
 
Going back through an acoustics folder, I found this study that I did several years ago that I had forgotten about that is related to this topic. From the results shown in the pdf file it appears that Proposition B is the one that is true. It should be noted that even though reducing the mouthpiece interior volume does raise the pitch, it also affects the tuning of the octaves as well.

1630164753190.png


Disclaimer: I am neither an expert in mathematics nor acoustics. This work is just an amateur attempt to gain a better understanding of the effects of mouthpiece volume on tuning and intonation and should be taken in that context. Any additions or corrections to the accuracy or content by those with more knowledge in this area are welcome.
 

Attachments

Last edited:
Going back through an acoustics folder, I found this study that I did several years ago that I had forgotten about that is related to this topic. From the results shown in the pdf file it appears that Proposition B is the one that is true. It should be noted that even though reducing the mouthpiece interior volume does raise the pitch, it also affects the tuning of the octaves as well.

View attachment 18871

Disclaimer: I am neither an expert in mathematics nor acoustics. This work is just an amateur attempt to gain a better understanding of the effects of mouthpiece volume on tuning and intonation and should be taken in that context. Any additions or corrections to the accuracy or content by those with more knowledge in this area are welcome.

The mouthpiece is pretty far up the cork with much less potential to lessen the volume between the end of the neck and mouthpiece than the amount of material added to the Morgan chamber to bring the pitch up. Nevertheless I'll give it a try. I'll use a form and cling film to make an extension to the ID of the neck and add to the outside of that with hot melt. Remove the form, then sand/form to the correct OD contour and then shorten bit by bit until it (hopefully) works. What do you think?

Thanks once again for bring this information to the fore.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,703
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom