Intonation Mouthpiece position & intonation on soprano

So is it fairly normal to not be able to use certain mouthpieces on certain saxes? I mean from a technical standpoint, not because you don't like the sound. I'm getting the impression from you guys that it is fairly common.
Some people seem to think so. The only time I've found it to be an issue is with small chambered mouthpieces on old baris.
 
So anyway I guess my next step is to find a more open mouthpiece that I can get in-tune on this sax. I was looking at the Vandoren V5 Jazz or the Vandoren V16. If anyone has any suggestions, I'd be interested. I don't want to spend much more than $100 (around £80) and jazz is my interest (not looking for a classical sound). I know there are a million mouthpieces but I think those restrictions actually narrow the choices significantly.
Sounds like either a Yamaha Custom or a Bari then. I've not tried the Yamaha but I've had a Bari 66 for years which I still use when I don't want to be as loud as I usually am.
 
Soprano is somewhat special and most people agree on that. As a matter of education, you may want to read what Joe Giardullo ( @Sopranoplanet is a member too) says about it here.

I'm not saying you have to get a mouthpiece from him, but obviously the mouthpiece plays an important role and perhaps it's even more so on the soprano. I struggled for quite a while before I could find a mouthpiece I felt comfortable with on the soprano. I'm not a very experienced player, being only 5 years in the game, but compared with alto, tenor and baritone, soprano didn't come easy.

Now, I'm still having massive arguments with my tenors, much work is obviously still required on my bari before I will feel good with it and since I neglected my altos, they have been retaliating or so I feel right now. And my poor sopranos didn't get as much attention as they deserve, so I'm certain that I will be experiencing some difficulties reuniting with them next time I play them. For what it's worth, I have been enjoying a Berg Larsen 60-1-SMS that came with my Hawkes & son soprano, so I bought a 65-2, but I can't get as much out of it (yet).

So, hang in there and keep faith. In an ideal world, it would be easy to try out many different mouthpieces, but it's not that easy. And I guess you need a certain maturity before you can go and have a mouthpiece tailored to your liking. I am not there yet...
 
Last edited:
I found that I had to push the mouthpiece further onto the cork than other saxes on my soprano to get it to play in tune with itself - ie, not a huge difference between the octaves. I spent some time with a tuner finding the sweet spot, then just marked with a pen on the cork where I needed to push it down to.

Foolishly, this is something I did quite a while after first playing it - I put up with it sounding out of tune for ages, and put it down to a combination of various people that told me "oh, sopranos always have dodgy intonation, they're very hard to play in tune", and it being a cheap sax (it's a John Packer). Any time I feel the need to buy a new sax, I'll do this exercise when I first try the sax!

Since I did this, I absolutely love playing the soprano - usually in quartets and pit bands. Mouthpiece wise I haven't tried much - I've got the stock piece, which was ok but not great. Only other one I've tried is a runyon quantum, which was an ebay bargain and works very well for me, so I've stuck with it.
 
Looks like soprano is in the air! I've been circling around mine for the last few weeks, even picked it up a couple of times. But after reading this I decided to have a little experiment and see where I was with my mouthpieces and check the tuning a bit more carefully than I usually do.

Same thing. Had to push the mouthpiece covering all of the cork in some cases. I still like my Berg Larsen 60-1-SMS the best. So I'll stick to it for now. And I decided to go with soprano for my next conservatoire formal check, instead of the tenor. There are a couple of passages that I'm struggling to play on tenor anyways. Jumps from medium E to low E, medium F to low D and medium D to low D. On tenor I tend to crash rather than land the low notes... 😛

So it's my excuse to make a temporary switch and try to master the sweet little beast. I read that playing soprano improves your tone on the tenor as well, so there is nothing to loose here! 😎
 
Does anyone else find that, once they've had a few weeks exclusively on soprano, that they have to move the mouthpiece slightly further off the cork? Since starting to take soprano seriously about 4 years ago I've found that my tuning position seems to have moved out slightly- I'd assume through better airflow and familiarity with the quirks of the instrument
 
Well I still think Baris are ugly (I don't like that silver band on the bottom, which no ligature or mouth could cover), but I ordered one and four other mouthpieces that were all $100 each. So I'll whack 'em around a bit and see what works.
 
I take more mouthpiece on soprano compared to tenor and baritone. Otherwise I'm not in tune/right pitch. So it was not the soprano/mouthpiece that was wrong, it was me! Just me?
 
Does anyone else find that, once they've had a few weeks exclusively on soprano, that they have to move the mouthpiece slightly further off the cork? Since starting to take soprano seriously about 4 years ago I've found that my tuning position seems to have moved out slightly- I'd assume through better airflow and familiarity with the quirks of the instrument

I think once you get really stuck into soprano, you have to raise the basic pitch at which you set you oral cavity. If you approach the soprano in the same way orally as the tenor or alto, you will have issues with tuning, and also with stability of the upper notes. Quite naturally as you zone in to the soprano you will raise the pitch within your larynx/throat and subtly change your tongue position to work better for the soprano. All this means that you will have to pull the mouthpiece a bit further off the cork because you will be playing a bit sharper generally. Small bore soprano pieces like Vandorens, Selmers and others can help to accelerate the air column and assist in evening out the soprano, but you can pay for that in terms of sound quality. Actually the PPT (although the PPT looks like a small bore piece it is not exactly as small as a Selmer) manages to strike a happy medium in this respect IMO - clever design.
 
Well I still think Baris are ugly (I don't like that silver band on the bottom, which no ligature or mouth could cover)
Nah, that silver band is a really cool design feature, the contrast between the silver ring and the matt black hard rubber of the mpc is nothing short of poetic. The only thing that distrubes the whole picture is the ligature - it covers the whole mpc and I think it's nickel plated which I must admit is a bit iffy miffy. Then there's the cap - credit where credit's due - it's cheapo plastico but at least they've taken the trouble to give it a matt grained finish.
No all in all I think it's very twee. Let's face it - think positive - you don't have to look at it when it's between your lips, just blow the blues away and enjoy the impeccable sound. well yer doo don'tchyer ? 😉
 
Nah, that silver band is a really cool design feature, the contrast between the silver ring and the matt black hard rubber of the mpc is nothing short of poetic. The only thing that distrubes the whole picture is the ligature - it covers the whole mpc and I think it's nickel plated which I must admit is a bit iffy miffy. Then there's the cap - credit where credit's due - it's cheapo plastico but at least they've taken the trouble to give it a matt grained finish.
No all in all I think it's very twee. Let's face it - think positive - you don't have to look at it when it's between your lips, just blow the blues away and enjoy the impeccable sound. well yer doo don'tchyer ? 😉

Haha I didn't realize sax players had such deep feelings about mouthpiece cosmetics. 😀 please don't hit me

I'll keep the Bari if it's the most functional mouthpiece out of the bunch. But I will be biased against it lol.
 
Last edited:
@carburetor - I'm verily thankful that you appreciated my humour, sometimes some of my posts may appear a bit off the wall. And they usually are. 😉 You're touching on a subject that's been going through my mind for quite a while now with respect to many of the threads here on the forum. I think I should start a new thread regarding personal taste and the ability to appreciate. However, it's getting late over here, It's gone dark and my dogs are Bari-king, so I'll sleep on it and open a new discussion in the breakfast room so's not to disrupt this thread any further.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,385
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom