Mouthpieces Mouthpiece help for yanagisawa Alto please

TomMapfumo's right about the size of the Yanagisawa mouthpiece, 1.83mm. Although some mouthpieces are notoriously variable (Otto Link, Meyer, Berg Larsen) Yanagisawa's are much more precisely made, and very consistent. I still think that if you find a 1 1/2 reed hard going on a 1.83mm tip opening you'd be better off examining your technique rather than throwing money at the problem.

When you're asking about whether it is a relatively narrow tip opening you're comparing it to Yamaha and Selmer, mouthpieces with pretty small tip openings. I'd place the average alto opening at about 2mm/0.8 inches. The Yanagisawa is a good bit smaller than that and should be easily playable by a beginner with a 1 1/2 or 2 strength reed. I'm not one of these macho nutcases who thinks you have to blow a massive mouthpiece, on alto I play a mouthiece with a tip opening of about 2mm, and I've been playing for 30 years. I just think that you're having trouble playing what should be an easy mouthpiece to blow, and personally I think you should try to work out why that is. Buying new kit is always enjoyable, but it's not, to my mind, the best course of action to sort out a playing issue.
 
Hi Tom,the rico standard 1./2 (softest) is the only reed I can use to get a clear singing sound, any others like rico royal 1.12 or vandoren 1 seems to hard ie breathy, which makes me think the MP is a bit too open for me? The Meyer 5m looks a good bet may be?
regards
John

Hang on a minute. A few posts ago you said it was working brilliantly. Why would you want to change it?
 
Hi Nick, I just thought if I am limited to the rico 1.1/2 (softest available) then ok, I could just stay with it untill my embouchure developes more, but looking at the Lewington MP chart
the Yani 6 sits above Yamaha 7cm, and Selmer between D and E, which made me think it was too wide a tip for me?
regards
 
I'd be inclined to stick with your current set up. However, one thing that a narrower tip and harder reed will give you is less flexibility in intonation. Which is a good thing if you're not good at keeping it in tune and a bad thing if you like to add lots of expression to your playing (providing you can control it well enough to stay in tune).
 
Hi Nick, I just thought if I am limited to the rico 1.1/2 (softest available) then ok, I could just stay with it untill my embouchure developes more, but looking at the Lewington MP chart
the Yani 6 sits above Yamaha 7cm, and Selmer between D and E, which made me think it was too wide a tip for me?
regards

Bill Lewington is wrong - it is 0.072" and the Yamaha 6C is 0.071" - nothing in it - and the 7C is 0.075" which is a bit bigger. The Yani is a much better and Hard Rubber piece.

Do you have a teacher, and have they said anything about your embouchure? How much mouthpiece do you take in when playing? It is important to find the point on the reed that sounds/feels the best. It is usually a mid point about 1cm from the mouthpiece tip. which is easier than either less or more mouthpiece.
Softest 1.5 reeds are the Alexander Superials but only available in 10. or the Marca Jazz, which are in 5's.
 
I see, the Jody jazz chart is different to the Lewington one!It does put the Yani 6 at 72 thou and not 76 thou, thats why I was questioning whether the Yani 6 was wider tip than even Yamaha 7cm or Selmer D,perhaps I should replace my chart 1st!
I do have a teacher and he uses a Selmer C** (for the last 55 years) that was another reason I questioned the Yani 6, should I be playing a MP wider than his?

http://www.bill-lewington.com/charts/altosax.htm
 
Hi Guys just to add a little pause for thought in this thread on mouthpieces. It looks like it has come down to a few .001"'s of an inch.:shocked: To be honest I would doubt that, that tight a tolerance would have been in place at point of manufacture>:). That is why you can get two identical mouthpieces that sound slightly different:thumb:. I would stand corrected on this if any of the tech's around here wish to jump in but I would have though +- .0025" would be nearer the mark if not bigger:confused:. So you can see you could have .005" between two same sized pieces if not more:thumb:. Hence the need to have many mouthpieces refinished by the experts🙂. Plus the need to play test as many as you can.:thumb:
 
Interesting question - should you be playing an MP wider than your teacher's? It is too random a question from my perspective. If your teacher has been playinga Selmer C** for 55 years then he would not have had a great desl of choice way back then. I suspect he leans more to the classical side of things. In those days it was quite common to play quite narrow tip openings, and many non classical players would play larger pieces than they did then. I do not play classical music and have never played anything smaller than 0.070", which is too small for me anyway. My sax teacher used to play a 7* on tenor (I play an 8). The important thing is to choose eventually what feels right for you, but you are likely to need to start smaller until your embouchure develops. I started on a Selmer Super Session E (0.078") with Rico Jazz Select 2H reeds. No idea what my teacher played on Alto - not relevant, but may have been of interest.

To satisfy your curiosity it would be better if you did get a smaller mouthpiece (below 0.070") and see whether it made a difference soundwise etc. Vandoren/Lomax etc.would probably be a safer bet than a Selmer - they are less consistently made these days than 55 years ago by common consent. I would always recommend having at least 2 mouthpieces and several different reed types/strenghtsso that you can make an informed choice about what you play.

Kind regards
Tom
 
Last edited by a moderator:
To add to what Tom's just said, teachers brought up on small tip sizes may tend to put you off playing a wider tip, for no good reason. Especially if they're clarinettists as well. Same goes for different embouchure styles.

But you need to make your own way, all we can do is comment.

With all of these discussions (and teachers) you need to listen, evaluate and then make an educated guess before evaluating for yourself.
 
My teacher (uncle) played and still plays big band/small band style,he paid £50.00 for his Selmer mk 6 back then in the 50.s,recently he gave me a plastic bag full of vintage mouthpices mainly alto,there were Selmer C*,C**, D, soloist,Roc britone,etc, they made best part of £700.00, 2 weeks later I bought my alto Ahrggggg!!! Anyway,I did try a friends alto yam 4C, but it did close up fairly easily,I fancy a Meyer 5m, it has good reports and is a bit narrower than the Yani I have at the moment,what do you think?
btw when I ask my teacher have you tried any other MPs or ligatures? He says 'what for?' I then keep quiet!
 
If you are looking for the sort of sound you describe in your original post then a Meyer will be too bright. The Yani is more likely to produce the type of sound that you are looking for than a Meyer would. There are many Meyer type mouthpieces out there which are better made, to be honest.

A Runyon 22 #4 tip opening would cost about £30 and be 0.066" - Charlie Parker used to play one (Santy Runyon was his first teacher). You may need to decide exactly what type of sound you want before buying a mouthpiece, and then get something which has a reputation for being well made. If you are looking to buy without testing first this would be very important. As Jonf says above some mouthpiece brands are not made consistently, and hence any measurement may be variable.

Going slightly smaller sounds a good idea, but do make sure that you choose a mouthpiece that is capable of the sort of sound that you want. A bit of online research would be useful, but it does come across that you are rather unsure about making the right decision, especially as most commentators doubt whether the mouthpiece should be a problem, and the reeds that you have (I do not know how many you have of the various ones you have tried - but they all sound like they should be almost too soft for the mouthpiece. Reeds do vary in hardness within a pack and you may have rather hard reeds. I would try some other reeds in your position, rather than shelling out over £100 on a new mouthpiece, which may not necessarily resolve the problem. At the same time it may still be an embouchure/technique problem ultimately.

Good luck
Tom
 
It looks like it has come down to a few .001"'s of an inch.:shocked: To be honest I would doubt that, that tight a tolerance would have been in place at point of manufacture:

In manufacturing a tolerances of a thousands of a mm are not that unusual. My Dad once worked on a project producing pipes for the artificial insemination of bees (!) where tolerances were measured in fractions of a micron, not mm. If there is the desire to have tolerances down to 1/00th of a mm it's perfectly feasible. I think the companies which stick to fine tolerances, in all dimensions, not just tip opening (Vandoren and Yanagisawa spring to mind) are the ones which have the most consistent mouthpieces.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,675
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom