Theory & Impro Melody Notes Dont Match Chords

so the piece we're looking at could be scored in g or d and both could be correct.
No. ky signatures ar thee to show th key, ie the tonic centre. There may be exceptions when in regard to modal tunes, but this isn't that.

A blues whose tonic is D should not be written in G just because there are some blue notes (e.g. b7 or b3)
However given the earlier comment on diatonic chords, though it might be possible to score the notes "correctly" in the wrong key, the implied diatonic chords would be wrong.
Am I close/distant/miles off?
I'd say miles off but I don't quite understand what you are saying.
 
Well I think that's more or less what I was trying to say .... but for the wrong reason! So you have to respect the key signature, even if some other key signature "looks" better in that it has fewer accidentals in the melody
Yes. The key signature gives you information about your likely journey through the piece of music both melodically and harmonically. You'll be "pre-armed" as to what notes are likely to crop up, which chords/harmony is likely and where you might modulate to, if it does.

Examples like this, and lots of jazz, step beyond "rules" of key when music theory was drawn up. For example, G7 - a dominant 7th chord was never used as a key-chord - a chord 1. Its use (more than a hundred years ago now) was as a chord 5. Hence, jazz/blues/rock n roll etc usage of dominant chords as 1 chords makes the key signature seem wrong - but if you look further into the piece (including harmonic movement) then it becomes more logical.

As for melody, it doesn't have to follow the chordal structure everywhere, and if there are deviations it might make more sense if you look at the line itself rather than just a "vertical" snapshot over the harmony at that point. It could be that you have tension that is resolved a little further on. Often, it might just be that the melody is an extension of a chord - the b9, #4 - whatever really. Much of the time these will be heard as tension and be released - the b9 resolving downward to the 1/root and the #4 resolving upward to the 5th. They might just be passing notes, maybe ones that hang around a little longer in order to have an impact. The more complex/quirkey the tune, the less they will "resolve" in a traditional/classical way, like an "oops, sorry about that".

As has been said before, the chords might also have been simplified, or even be wrong. Don't forget that they are only a guideline too - a soloist might start to outline different changes, and the rhythm section may or may not go with them. And vice versa.
 
Thanks Pete E, thats really helpful. I get the idea of the flexibility that all this implies, but from a practical standpoint it makes it difficult to know where to start when getting to grips with it all as a rookie.

I know that some excellent musicians just play by feel, and dont know any theory and cant read a note. I suspect I will never be one of them! So I'm trying to go for the "rules based" approach, even if only in a very simple form. It's just that the rules seem a bit complicated, and can often be tweaked or even broken to good effect!
 
Thanks Pete E, thats really helpful. I get the idea of the flexibility that all this implies, but from a practical standpoint it makes it difficult to know where to start when getting to grips with it all as a rookie.

I know that some excellent musicians just play by feel, and dont know any theory and cant read a note. I suspect I will never be one of them! So I'm trying to go for the "rules based" approach, even if only in a very simple form. It's just that the rules seem a bit complicated, and can often be tweaked or even broken to good effect!
Yes, the rules are vast but in most instances they do make sense and work quite well.

The old “Joe Bloggs is amazing and can’t read a note and knows nothing “ is not a truism. They know loads - but just in a different “non-labelled” way. If you quoted traditional theory to Chet Baker he might not recognise the words but he’d sure as hell recognise the sound if you played an example. And for him, that was his only concern.

Had he wanted to be in a reading band, like a show band - backing names etc he’d not have the right skills.

For “ear musicians “ it might be the only way they found that they were comfortable learning, or it was the only possible thing on offer at the time. It doesn’t make any difference, as Chet Baker stands right at the forefront of jazz trumpet playing as does Miles Davis, who could read. Many ways, many ways…
 
Yes, the rules are vast but in most instances they do make sense and work quite well.

The old “Joe Bloggs is amazing and can’t read a note and knows nothing “ is not a truism. They know loads - but just in a different “non-labelled” way. If you quoted traditional theory to Chet Baker he might not recognise the words but he’d sure as hell recognise the sound if you played an example. And for him, that was his only concern.

Had he wanted to be in a reading band, like a show band - backing names etc he’d not have the right skills.

For “ear musicians “ it might be the only way they found that they were comfortable learning, or it was the only possible thing on offer at the time. It doesn’t make any difference, as Chet Baker stands right at the forefront of jazz trumpet playing as does Miles Davis, who could read. Many ways, many ways…

I went to a really interesting talk by Alyn Shipton that tied in with his new book about the Gerry Mulligan 1950s quartets. His research into Chet's musical background showed that in his early years he played trumpet in various US Army bands before leaving the military in 1951. His conclusion is that Chet's reading and understanding of musical theory must have been better than most people have assumed, because those Army bands would all have required reading.

I bought the book and had a nice chat with Alyn while he autographed it for me.

Rhys
 
I went to a really interesting talk by Alyn Shipton that tied in with his new book about the Gerry Mulligan 1950s quartets. His research into Chet's musical background showed that in his early years he played trumpet in various US Army bands before leaving the military in 1951. His conclusion is that Chet's reading and understanding of musical theory must have been better than most people have assumed, because those Army bands would all have required reading.

I bought the book and had a nice chat with Alyn while he autographed it for me.

Rhys
Thanks Rhys, not unusual to have “myths” busted.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,427
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom