Tech/maintenance Maintenance & Cleaning Stuff

Another way of looking at it: how much oil is your average saxophone player going to get through?

I don't have an automotive workshop with every grade and type of lubricant on hand. Therefore it makes sense for me to buy a small bottle of Ultimax for my saxophones. It comes in a handy little applicator bottle and that one bottle will probably last me years.

Sure in terms of price per volume it's super expensive. But buying a large volume that I wouldn't use in several lifetime's of playing (even if it was just a litre or so) and then finding something to apply it with like hypodermic needles etc just doesn't make sense practically or financially to me.
My point wasn't so much that it's more economical to buy in small quantities, it's that this supposed "designed for woodwind instruments" oil is just one of many standard oils a big company makes, and you're paying not only for it coming in a small quantity but also for it being labeled "for woodwind instruments" instead of "for sewing machines" or "for automobiles" or "for general hardware store use". Pretty much any kind of light mineral oil (not vegetable based!) will do just fine on a saxophone.
 
I realize that a lot of what I am paying for using the Music Medic lubricants is convenience. The small needle tip oil applicators, and the syringe containing the pivot and roller lubricant are ideal when working on as many saxophones as I do. This is what has worked for me for several years. If others wish to "go out to the garage, get a quart of motor oil, dip a wire in it, use the wire as applicator" that's their choice. 😉
 
My point wasn't so much that it's more economical to buy in small quantities, it's that this supposed "designed for woodwind instruments" oil is just one of many standard oils a big company makes, and you're paying not only for it coming in a small quantity but also for it being labeled "for woodwind instruments" instead of "for sewing machines" or "for automobiles" or "for general hardware store use". Pretty much any kind of light mineral oil (not vegetable based!) will do just fine on a saxophone.

I fully get the point that saxophones don't have anywhere near the mechanical demands of even a sewing machine. Let alone an internal combustion engine with water vapour, fuel and particulate contaminants, operating at a high degree of temperature variation and mechanical shear etc.

It does take the guesswork out of finding a suitable lubricant that doesn't have additives that will damage finish and won't run out everywhere or poison the player or cause skin irritations. Perhaps instead of "designed for", it should read "specially selected for" woodwind instruments.
 
The are advantages to using grease - and disadvantages too. Same with oil.
According to lubrication engineers it is better to use grease for equipment with a lot of downtime and/or for equipment without an oil circulation system, when two other conditions are met:

1 the resistance of the grease doesn't slow down the equipment significantly.
2 When the diameter of the lubricated axis (in meter) multiplied with the RPM of the movement is smaller than 6000.

As the resistance of the grease is much smaller than the resistance of the springs it doesn't slow down the speed of movement of the keys. The second condition is a protection against overheating, which is safe when moving slower than 18000000 RPM.

I know than generally people prefer oil for saxophones, but I have no problems with using grease.

The advantages are:

longer protection, better protection against water and less problems with dust and particles entering the lubricated areas.
 
I feel drawn to oil for its advantage of capillary action drawing it along the inside of long rods.
Wouldn’t you just remove the rod then apply grease, if it is appropriate on rods (which I’m not sure about as opposed to point screws)

I would have thought you’d want to clean the rod anyway whether you were greasing it or oiling it
 
After cleaning the rod and the keywork, I inject some grease in the keywork with a syringe and slowly rotate the rod back in. If there is enough grease some is extruded at the other end. If the extrudate is not clean repeat cleaning. No extrudate, more grease. Also remove the extrudate after greasing.
 
On saxophones I like to use Music Medic's high viscocity Ultimax key oil. It is thicker and doesn't flow as easily as the low viscocity (thinner) oil. It stays in place when applied to the inside of the hinge tube before inserting the rod and doesn't make the key feel sluggish. I like to use the Ultimax pivot screw grease for rollers, and it does noticeably cause them to "roll" slower, which in that application is just fine. I would not use that grease for regular keys with hinge tubes because of the "sluggish" movement it creates.
 
There is a huge range of viscosity in different types of grease. I just test if it slows my fast trill speed.
I understand where you are coming from. Like many professional techs I spend a lot of time on overhauls "chasing down" key friction either inside the hinge tube (key barrel) or where the rod or tube contacts the post. Part of the test is not only how fast the key opens and closes, but also how it feels to the touch. Some go so far as to put a bit of oil or grease where the spring fits in its "cradle". A simple experiment might be to put oil inside one key and grease inside the one next to it on the lower stack, unhook the spring, and then compare how fast each key closes using just gravity.
 
A simple experiment might be to put oil inside one key and grease inside the one next to it on the lower stack, unhook the spring, and then compare how fast each key closes using just gravity.
In such an experiment, when both keys are equal, the greased one closes slower. But if you hook the springs again there is no real difference in how fast your fingers can open and close the keys. The spring tension has more influence than the resistance of the lubricant.

So it comes back to how it feels to the touch. I do not underestimate the capacity to feel a differences in touch but I also do not underestimate the possibility to get used to such small differences.
 
According to lubrication engineers it is better to use grease for equipment with a lot of downtime and/or for equipment without an oil circulation system, when two other conditions are met:

1 the resistance of the grease doesn't slow down the equipment significantly.
2 When the diameter of the lubricated axis (in meter) multiplied with the RPM of the movement is smaller than 6000.
...
The advantages are:

longer protection, better protection against water and less problems with dust and particles entering the lubricated areas.
As I'm sure any lubrication expert would attest, it's not quite that simple.
The keywork on a horn is, in engineering terms, quite crude. The necessity for a relatively large amount of clearance between the barrel of the keys and their associated rod screws couple with the inherent flex in the system (not to mention wear and tear) leads to a situation whereby lubricants get pushed away from the point of most friction. This is the big drawback of using grease - the same mechanism that pushes lubricant away from such points will also suck it back in...if it's able to. The action of pressing a key creates much more force than releasing it...so a grease will be displaced and will not be sucked back into place. This is where oil has a very clear advantage.

Another advantage is that although oil can drag particles into the barrel, it can also flush them out. If anything gets into the grease - it's there until it's manually cleaned out.
I'd been looking into these issues for quite some time when I came up with a novel way of combining oil and grease to get the best of both worlds - namely using two lubricants which aren't miscible. Silicone grease provides the long-term general lubrication and quietening, synthetic gear oil provides the flow properties and allows the action to operate without stiction.

 
Last edited:
Well, I'm glad the engineering of sax lubrication is well understood. I'd hate it if the bearings on a sax failed halfway through a gig, causing wide spread damage and injury.
Strangely enough - it happens.
It's mostly the palm keys that are affected. The lube dries up, water gets in, rust builds up - and sometimes the keys quite literally grind to a halt.

The worst cases are when it happens to the stack keys - and it's usually the lower stack that cops it. I did a job on a Selmer tenor where the low E key just locked down solid. The player tried to fix it by raising the key and made it a whole lot worse. I ended up having to cut the key out. Had to ream out the entire stack and make an oversized rod to fit.
A reasonable amount of damage - and a certain amount of injury when it came to paying the bill.
 
As I'm sure any lubrication expert would attest, it's not quite that simple.
True, luckily I have a job which requires me to make choices in complex systems. Sometimes there are too much variables to make a clear choice and you have to weigh conflicting influences in majors and minors. In this case I beg to differ in some choices of majors and minors.

In bearings grease often doesn't fill the bearing completely. This makes it possible to use grease in bearings at higher velocities. In such a case your analysis is correct. Now a saxophone, even in bebop, is a low velocity application for grease and you can fill it up until there is no air. When the grease is pushed away on a long rod the grease comes back when the geometry is restored in order to avoid a vacuum.

Now grease doesn't evaporate as fast as oil. So there is less need to fill up a greased system as frequent as an oiled system.
Every time you oil a system without cleaning the surrounding area, you can bring particles into the system which are not removed when the oil evaporates. When grease is kept in an open jar it will accumulate particles. So you have to keep it in a closed jar and inject it with a syringe in order to avoid the introduction of particles.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,588
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom