Tech/maintenance Maintenance & Cleaning Stuff

In bearings grease often doesn't fill the bearing completely. This makes it possible to use grease in bearings at higher velocities. In such a case your analysis is correct. Now a saxophone, even in bebop, is a low velocity application for grease and you can fill it up until there is no air. When the grease is pushed away on a long rod the grease comes back when the geometry is restored in order to avoid a vacuum.

Now grease doesn't evaporate as fast as oil. So there is less need to fill up a greased system as frequent as an oiled system.
Every time you oil a system without cleaning the surrounding area, you can bring particles into the system which are not removed when the oil evaporates. When grease is kept in an open jar it will accumulate particles. So you have to keep it in a closed jar and inject it with a syringe in order to avoid the introduction of particles.
If you're relying on a vacuum to replace displaced grease when a key is pressed, you're going to be disappointed.
It's a nice theory, but that's why I tested the proposition - to see what actually happens vs. what folks think happens.

I wouldn't be at all concerned about the potential for oil to evaporate; it would take a very long time and the losses would pale beside those incurred through migration.
It's certainly good practice to clean the pillars/keywork before applying oil to prevent ingress of particles - but it's worth remembering that the process of wear creates its own particles, and without any flushing mechanism to remove these it becomes even more important to strip the action and re-grease on a regular basis.
 
If you unscrew a pivot screw to remove a key, and then remove the screw to clean its thread, what's the best way of cleaning the thread in the post? It will have tiny particles in there, waiting to be pushed back into the key end when the pivot screw in reinserted, and then sloshed around by the fresh oil to make a nice grinding paste.
Other than a correctly sized thread tap, screwed through and then cleaned before removing, I can't think how?
 
If you unscrew a pivot screw to remove a key, and then remove the screw to clean its thread, what's the best way of cleaning the thread in the post? It will have tiny particles in there, waiting to be pushed back into the key end when the pivot screw in reinserted, and then sloshed around by the fresh oil to make a nice grinding paste.
Other than a correctly sized thread tap, screwed through and then cleaned before removing, I can't think how?

Couple of options.
A pipe cleaner, generously moistened with cigarette lighter fluid. Use one end for the 'first run', the other for the second - then snip the dirty end off. Repeat for as many pillars you wish to clean.

Interdental brushes - again, moistened with CLF. These can be cleaned.
I like to do two passes, then blow the pillar out with an air duster.
 
Ah yes! Good thinking. I have these already.
Would isopropyl alcohol be a suitable alternative to lighter fluid? I have both but others may not.
It's OK. I don't find it quite as effective as CLF - and as CLF cleans more things (pads) it tends to be my go-to solution.
 
Cigarette lighter fluid is "Naphtha (/ˈnæpθə/ or /ˈnæfθə/) is a flammable liquid hydrocarbon mixture.

Mixtures labelled naphtha have been produced from natural gas condensates, petroleum distillates, and the distillation of coal tar and peat"

Isopropyl alcohol (IPA, correctly styled isopropanol) is an alcohol; meaning it's got an -OH group on one end.

Lighter fluid, being a mixture of long(ish) chain molecules, is going to be what's called a "non polar" solvent and will act more readily on non-polar compounds, like oils and oil-related materials; alcohol, being a small molecule and asymmetric (the OH hanging off one side) is a polar solvent and will act more readily on polar compounds.

Since what you're trying to clean out of an internal thread on a machine that's been well oiled through the years is a mixture of oil, oil sludge, and assorted schmutz, an oil-based solvent will be the most effective at loosening this stuff so some kind of a swab can mechanically carry it away.

And that's why lighter fluid (naphtha) is more effective at removing the sludge from that threaded part.

If you pay attention to the type of solvent you're using and the type of material you're trying to remove, you'll have a lot better results. For example, gummy labels that leave a residue; that's an oil-based adhesive; use something derived from oil. Yes, you can struggle away with rubbing alcohol, but plain old OLIVE OIL will generally take that stuff off, and not damage the surface.
 
@Stephen Howard do you think that's because lighter fluid evaporates more slowly than IPA or is there more to it?
CFL evaporates much faster than IPA...at least when compared to the 70% stuff I have here - but I don't think it's a factor.
I think it's just that CFL is a better solvent for oil.

You can test it for yourself. Pop a drop of each solvent on a white plate then put one drop of oil in each...and see what happens.
 
I've shared this before, but I have excellent results cleaning hinge tubes and post holes with cotton pipe cleaners with a few drops of inexpensive brass valve oil. It is an excellent solvent for old grease and oil, it is easily removed with a dry pipe cleaner, and it leaves no residue. This is what I use in a needle tip applicator.

619XRHJ0UEL._AC_UL320_.jpg
 
In industry I'd use a commercial degreaser. We used to use Isopar -L in the print trade as it is essentially the same as the carrier medium for the inks we were using in our Indigo printing presses and minor contamination of the ink was not an issue. Having a degreaser / washup station is a bit overkill for home saxophone repair, you may be able to buy small bottles of petroleum based degreaser - bicycle maintenance comes to mind but beware of additives and avoid citrus at all costs!

From my point of view, I'm mindful that some of the principles that apply to industry simply aren't as relevant to saxophone maintenance and the parts of a sax are not subject to the same stress and demands and you don't need to worry about carbonisation or effects of high temperature etc.

I'd expect user habits have more of an impact: Leaving an instrument out on a stand attracting dust, spilt drinks in a pub, spit and sweat etc.

The reason I like IPA or isopropyl alcohol (if you prefer) for day to day maintenance use is it's quite mild and evaporates more or less completely. Lighter fluid may do the job better in this case, but it does stink and seems to linger for a while!

Bottom line though: I'm not a sax repair technician and what works practically may differ somewhat from theory and Wikipedia!
 
I find the 'aroma' of CFL varies depending on the brand.
For example, I tend to get mine at Poundland. It's cheap (a quid) and it does the job...but it doesn't have a very nice niff. Ronsonol, on the other hand, is pricier and smells much nicer. But IPA just smells like IPA - and it's not an aroma I'm particularly fond of. Back in the day I used to use carbontetrachloride - and even the memory of how it niffed makes me shudder (especially when you burnt it).

...But it all might be down to all that vintage Evostik I've been inhaling down the years....
 
I get the feeling with lighter fluid most are a pretty rough distillation with plenty of impurities - so long as it burns.

Not all degreasers have much of a smell if you stick to oil based - Isopar L certainly doesn't - it's some sort of modified paraffin

I see you can still buy MEK Methyl Ethyl Ketone on Amazon - this stuff is legendry in the print trade and is now widely outlawed for commercial use in the UK - I hear it'll take Hammarite paint off metal - smells terrible and can kill you though so I couldn't recommend it as you can also develop a sensitivity which means you can go in to shock if you catch a whiff (oh and people use it for making illegal substances).
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,588
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom