Stephen Howard
Well-Known Member
If you're relying on a vacuum to replace displaced grease when a key is pressed, you're going to be disappointed.In bearings grease often doesn't fill the bearing completely. This makes it possible to use grease in bearings at higher velocities. In such a case your analysis is correct. Now a saxophone, even in bebop, is a low velocity application for grease and you can fill it up until there is no air. When the grease is pushed away on a long rod the grease comes back when the geometry is restored in order to avoid a vacuum.
Now grease doesn't evaporate as fast as oil. So there is less need to fill up a greased system as frequent as an oiled system.
Every time you oil a system without cleaning the surrounding area, you can bring particles into the system which are not removed when the oil evaporates. When grease is kept in an open jar it will accumulate particles. So you have to keep it in a closed jar and inject it with a syringe in order to avoid the introduction of particles.
It's a nice theory, but that's why I tested the proposition - to see what actually happens vs. what folks think happens.
I wouldn't be at all concerned about the potential for oil to evaporate; it would take a very long time and the losses would pale beside those incurred through migration.
It's certainly good practice to clean the pillars/keywork before applying oil to prevent ingress of particles - but it's worth remembering that the process of wear creates its own particles, and without any flushing mechanism to remove these it becomes even more important to strip the action and re-grease on a regular basis.
