Tech/maintenance Maintenance & Cleaning Stuff

Once it's been used it's even worse. I drained some from a motorcycle bevel drive where it had been mashed around for 20,000 miles, and it was absolutely revolting.
Yeah, I used it in a limited slip differential in an old sports car of mine. I have no desire to drizzle it all over my saxes.
 
That's nowt... when I were a lad it'd get drained out o' me grandad's Riley after 500,000 miles and a teaspoon of it served up f'supper, still warm mind, wi'a six year ol' crust o'cardboard I'd slept under in middle of lane t'night before.
Now we all know that's not true, purely because a Riley wouldn't do 50,000 miles, let alone 500,000 😀
 
Out of interest, why do you recommend 75w140? That's normally used in very high power or load applications. Is there a particular advantage over mor normal (cheaper) oil specs?
It's purely down to a combination of viscosity and staying power - and the fact that it's relatively cheap and widely available.
 
Well, you don't need multiviscosity oil for a saxophone, since it doesn't operate over a wide temperature range. If what's available is multivis, it won't hurt anything.

I use a light non-smelly oil for mechanisms in general (currently working down a 40 year old bottle of sewing machine oil). I use grease for rollers (since I am a cyclist I have a tube of Phil Wood Waterproof Grease - the "waterproof" isn't needed but it's what's there).

Nothing in a saxophone operates under high contact pressure, nor at high speeds. Frankly a light grease would probably be the right lube for most all of the mechanisms on a saxophone. But with the long hinge tubes there's the opportunity to get enough viscous friction to make the action sluggish.

The honest truth is that as long as you stay away from weird stuff and vegetable oils and animal fats, you'll pretty much be fine. All the various high priced specialty lubricants marketed for saxophones are BS, they've just taken something from the hardware store and repackaged it. Do you really think DuPont, or Dow, or Royal Dutch Shell, are formulating special oils for the 3 or 10 liters a year a saxophone specialty shop might sell? They wouldn't be charging $10 for that little bottle of oil, they'd be charging $10,000.
 
I have had very good results using Music Medic Ultimax Synthetic medium viscoscity key oil. The 5ml needle oiler is the perfect size. I also purchased the 16 oz bottle to refill the needle oiler as needed. As a professional repair tech who specializes in complete overhauls, this amount of oil is more than a lifetime supply. A do-it-yourselfer could get by with the 5ml needle oiler for several years applying the correct amount. For an individual to buy a liter of any oil to use on woodwinds unrealistic regardless of the price.

As I wrote earlier, most of the techs in the US that I have spoken with at conferences, clinics, and on the internet have gone to the synthetic oils made specifically for musical instruments. Most brass players/technicians prefer either the Hetman or the Alisyn Synthetics. Most of the woodwind techs use the Ultimax from Music Medic.
Do you REALLY think oil companies are "specifically" making oil for musical instruments?

Do you have any idea of the volumes it would take to have a bespoke oil formulation? Or the volumes a "musical instrument oil company" would be selling? I'll give you a hint: the first one's going to be measured in hundreds of drums, the second in quarts.
 
Well, you don't need multiviscosity oil for a saxophone, since it doesn't operate over a wide temperature range. If what's available is multivis, it won't hurt anything.
You don't need multi-viscosity, you don't need additives, you don't need NASA's stamp of approval.

What you DO need is an oil that stays put, that doesn't degrade/solidify over time, that 'plays well' with existing lubricants and that won't damage either the metal or the horn's finish.
But most importantly of all - you have to be able to get your hands on a bottle of the stuff at a moment's notice.
I've found that if you put even the slightest complication in front of a player who's minded to have a go at oiling the action, it simply won't get done. And that could be one of the biggest mistakes a player ever makes.
 
Do you REALLY think oil companies are "specifically" making oil for musical instruments?

Do you have any idea of the volumes it would take to have a bespoke oil formulation? Or the volumes a "musical instrument oil company" would be selling? I'll give you a hint: the first one's going to be measured in hundreds of drums, the second in quarts.
As a general rule you call up a oil producer, explain what it is you need a lubricant for and they'll go check their existing range to see if anything fits the spec. If they haven't got anything suitable they might be prepared to formulate it...at a suitable cost.

I had such a conversation with the boffins at Castrol many, many years ago. They were extremely helpful, even knowing up front that I wasn't going to order anything.
 
...
But most importantly of all - you have to be able to get your hands on a bottle of the stuff at a moment's notice.
I've found that if you put even the slightest complication in front of a player who's minded to have a go at oiling the action, it simply won't get done. And that could be one of the biggest mistakes a player ever makes.
Hence my advice:

Go out to the garage, get a quart of motor oil, dip a wire in it, use the wire as applicator.
 
Do you REALLY think oil companies are "specifically" making oil for musical instruments?

Do you have any idea of the volumes it would take to have a bespoke oil formulation? Or the volumes a "musical instrument oil company" would be selling? I'll give you a hint: the first one's going to be measured in hundreds of drums, the second in quarts.
Some unknown company makes the oils and lubricants that Music Medic markets and sells under the name "Ultimax". Whether or not each particular viscosity is manufactured for woodwind instruments specifically, they are excellent lubricants and IMO a step up from the petroleum key oils that were sold in the past.
 
OK, let's run that pop fly out.

Ultimax oil $9.89/10 ml = $0.99/cc
Ultimax oil $56.01/16 oz = $0.12/cc
Ultimax "sticky oil" $9.78/0.5 oz = $0.65/cc, $84.76/16 oz = $0.17/cc
Mobil 1 motor oil (available in a variety of viscosities) $8.78/qt = $0.009/cc
Mobil 1 gear oil (75-105 or 90-140) $28.29/qt = $0.029/cc
Mobil 1 grease $15.00/12.5 oz = $0.04/cc

There's really little evidence that "synthetic" means anything for a saxophone with very low velocities of motion, very low contact pressures, room temperature operation, and no products of combustion trying to attack the oil or make it cross-link, but there you are. If you're willing to use white lithium grease, automotive gear oil, and motor oil the costs are even lower.
 
Another way of looking at it: how much oil is your average saxophone player going to get through?

I don't have an automotive workshop with every grade and type of lubricant on hand. Therefore it makes sense for me to buy a small bottle of Ultimax for my saxophones. It comes in a handy little applicator bottle and that one bottle will probably last me years.

Sure in terms of price per volume it's super expensive. But buying a large volume that I wouldn't use in several lifetime's of playing (even if it was just a litre or so) and then finding something to apply it with like hypodermic needles etc just doesn't make sense practically or financially to me.
 
Sure in terms of price per volume it's super expensive. But buying a large volume that I wouldn't use in several lifetime's of playing (even if it was just a litre or so) and then finding something to apply it with like hypodermic needles etc just doesn't make sense practically or financially to me.
Yep, the convenience factor is what you pay for. Nothing wrong with that.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,588
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom