My argument is why not use an oil that is made specifically for that application with the proper viscoscity? It is not that expensive. Maybe using a "gear oil" or "motor oil" won't hurt, but is that the best possible choice? I do not know even one professional tech who uses "gear oil" or "motor oil" on woodwind keys in the U.S.
And my argument is that the action on woodwind instruments is so crude (in engineering terms) that virtually 'any old oil' will do - providing it stays put.
I mean, c'mon...£173 for a litre of oil, for a saxophone? The engine in my BMW is a masterpiece of modern engineering, and has to cope with extraordinary operating conditions - yet even a high spec oil for it barely hits £15 a litre. Even a litre of oil for your jet will only cost around £30 a litre.
Am I being asked to believe that the lubrication requirements for a horn exceeds that of a car, or a jet turbine?
Did the 'research' for developing a specialised musical instrument oil really cost that much??
It's complete bollox.
And what's the point of recommending a super-duper mega-priced lubricant if it's going to be put on top of whatever's already in the action? It's like pouring a finger of Islay malt into a glass that's still got the dregs of last night's Special Brew sloshing around the bottom. Utterly, utterly pointless.
If you can strip, clean and degrease the entire action (pillars too) and replace it with whizz-bang oil - fine, you'll get the benefit (assuming there is one)...otherwise it's like nipping out in the dead of night and sticking a 'Turbo' sticker on the back of your Lada in the hope of impressing anyone who comes up behind you.
If you examine what happens to the oil in an action, how it moves, where it ends up, it soon becomes abundantly clear that the whole system has a major built-in flaw - oil is pumped in and out of the key barrels and in so doing picks up any contaminents that have come to rest on the pillar faces.
It's the ultimate leveller.
Here's a little Stevie project anyone can do at home (ask your parents first though).
Take a sheet of clear polythene...one of those little resealable bags is ideal. Make sure it's nice and clean.
Pop a drop of oil onto the outside of the sheet/bag - then leave it somewhere convenient in the room where you usually practice. For best effect leave it somewhere chest height.
When you're next playing, be mindful of where you place your sax. Do you put in on the floor, or on a stand maybe? On the sofa? Place the oiled sheet/bag in the same area for a while.
Try placing the sheet inside your horn case and close/open the lid a few times.
Give it a week, maybe two..maybe a month or more if you like - and then hold the sheet over a piece of white paper (shine a light on the paper for best effect) and see what's in the oil.
Most of what you'll see isn't going to be of much concern - it'll either be too big to find its way inside the keywork, or too soft to be of much consequence. If you have a microscope handy (and who doesn't?) you might notice smaller, darker dots. Some of this is going to be grit - tiny particles of sand/stone that are light enough to be carried in the air. Handfulls of this stuff gets lifted off the floor and propelled into the air every time you open a door, or sit on your sofa...or jig about while blowing changes over 'Mustang Sally'.
If anyone wants to report back with their results (pics too, if you like), it'll be interesting.
So - provided the oil meets a few basic criteria (stays in place, doesn't dry out, doesn't eat through the action, doesn't kill you), it's all you need - and until someone finds a way to stop the oil being contaminated in use, it'll remain all you need.
As for 'no other tech uses it' - I've had two tenors in this week, both having been 'repaired' recently by other techs. One cost £150, one cost £37 - and neither of them work. The £150 job won't go below A without a struggle (and even if it did, it wouldn't get much further), and the other one falls on its arse at F.
So, I'm probably rather grouchy and even less inclined to give credence to what other techs do than I was before.