Playing the saxophone Legere reed

Perhaps consider paying attention to what other folk are suggesting, then?

So far we've established that you place your reeds on in a manner most would consider incorrect; somehow are destroying your cane reeds in your caravan (for context, I've had my saxes in pretty much any climate, and neverhad the issues you're describing); probably have general issues at the bottom end of the horn.

So the first thing for me would be to place the reed correctly, then start to work on your bottom end. The 2.5 legere seems to work for you, so stick with it whilst placing it correctly on your mouthpiece. If after a while it's still playing too soft, try moving up. Alternatively do the same with the 2.75, but given you've said you're having a harder time with it, that seems the incorrect approach. Perhaps also consult with your teacher and see what they suggest....

Or just carry on doing whatever it is you've already decided you want to do.....
I would say if thats where the reed plays best..keep it there tbf..I do listen to what people say and take notice accordingly..however sometimes queston how it's said..TBF the threads gone way of track..It's not about cane the caravan or my placement of the reed, which is fine according to my teacher or whether a 2.5 is ok: it was about whether working harder for a better tone is worth it..btw if you can stand in a pool of sweat dripping wet in over 100 degrees heat with no aircon because thats all youve got to practice in, and not damage a couple of no 2 cane reeds i take my hat of to

Without meaning to be rude, you've said enough on this thread that makes me think that perhaps you aren't qualified enough to day where a reed plays best. 😉

I disagree the thread has gone off track, the only thing is nobody is saying what you want to hear.

But as I say, if you've decided you know best and want to ignore the other folk suggesting what to do (of which there are several and people way more qualified than I), then be my guest.
TBF after 7 years I humbly disagree..my teacher says it's fine..Granted im no pro but you assessing my reed placement telepathically is wonderful maybe you could give me telepathic lessons while im sweating my nuts of.. ;-) could you answer what it is you think I want to hear..
 
Well 6 years in but thats pretty new .

TBF after 7 years I humbly disagree..my teacher says it's fine..Granted im no pro but you assessing my reed placement telepathically is wonderful maybe you could give me telepathic lessons while im sweating my nuts of.. ;-) could you answer what it is you think I want to hear..
6.... 7....

As I say, you do you. I just don't get the point in coming asking questions when you don't want to hear the answers....
 
Im sorry but I don't understand what i don't want to hear..
I think what it may be is that you gave four specific options to solve a problem. However many people, including myself, think there should be a different solution, ie just play a softer reed (e.g. 2.5 or IMO 2.25). It was further complicated by saying you didn't have the reed in what is generally recognised as the correct placement for proper articulation among other things.

But the impression is that isn't the answer you want to hear, because you didn't ask if just playing a softer reed would help. Yes, there was something about a softer reed on a different mouthpiece, which just seemed to complicate the issue.

Also I still don't know why/where you got advice about Theo Wanne mouthpieces working best with hard reeds.
 
Last edited:
I think what it may be is that you gave four specific options to solve a problem. However many people, including myself, think there should be a different solution, ie just play a soft reed. It was further complicated by saying you didn't have the reed in what is generally recognised as the correct placement for proper articulation among other things.

But the impression is that isn't the answer you want to hear, because you didn't ask if just playing a softer reed would help. Yes, there was something about a softer reed on a different mouthpiece, which just seemed to complicate the issue.
TBF @Pete Thomas I have tried a 2 hence having the spare reeds from the exchange programme..on my Lebayle jazz it sounds lovely but re another post the only way i can get a patch to stay on is contact glue..it then lasts a week..so I have stuck with the TW on which the 2.5 sounds better and the 2.75 even nicer..I think theres mixed consensus re placement with legere yesrerdays article suggested starting flush and moving forwardbor back in small increments..my teacher feels placement is fine..Why would i ask for advice only to ignore it..butbi am not that daft that after nearly 8 years i can't put a reed on..
 
on my Lebayle jazz it sounds lovely
What lebayle?- this is a new one added to the thread to just confuse things further??? What have patches got to do with it?
TW on which the 2.5 sounds better and the 2.75 even nicer.
Different again!!!!. The 2.5 sounds better than what? if the 2.75 sounds better than the 2.5 then use that one. But in your first post you said it was not very good articulation to which I'd say don't use it.:doh:
.I think theres mixed consensus re placement with legere yesrerdays article
I don't. (what is yesterdays article?)

If the reed is the wrong strength then adjust placement could be a temporary bodge - but it is very likely to be bad for articulation
 
If you are going to play Legere it is always best to have about 2,3 or 4 of the same size to rotate around, maybe getting another 2.5 might just be the answer, I have never come across a Legere of strong strength playing better.
I use 2's on alto and have four of them to rotate around, I personally think you should stick with 2.5, better your tone with that strength and make sure you can voice your 2 1/2 octaves well, you obviously can't do that on the 2.75.
 
What lebayle?- this is a new one added to the thread to just confuse things further??? What have patches got to do with it?

Different again!!!!. The 2.5 sounds better than what? if the 2.75 sounds better than the 2.5 then use that one. But in your first post you said it was not very good articulation to which I'd say don't use it.:doh:

I don't. (what is yesterdays article?)

If the reed is the wrong strength then adjust placement could be a temporary bodge - but it is very likely to be bad for articulation
Trouble is @Pete Thomas by selecting sections from the whole thing complicate things by taking them out of context..

Why would i want to confuse a thread, im not a troll.. I mentioned the lebayle as i used a legere 2 on it with good results..Also in context i explain why i dont use it now..missing..

Point 2 in context..the 2.5 sounds better than the 2 on the TW, missing.. you are correct the 2.75 sounds better, but slightly harder to blow, not really surprising.

Point 3 you discussed the article from the clarinet board..re positioning..

I said articulation was a bit more difficult hence the original questions..

Point 4 i don't adjust the reed its in its best place as stated several times and confirmed by a teacher.. again I have no issues with the 2.5 the 2.75 just sounds better

Tbf this is starting to feel like a wind up in the words of dragons den...im out
 
Trouble is @Pete Thomas by selecting sections from the whole thing complicate things by taking them out of context..
Please explain what that means and why you mention it.

Why would i want to confuse a thread, im not a troll

I think we have a real communication problem here and sincerely I would love to sort it out. I don't think you are a troll but there are very obviously some misunderstandings here and it does seem what you say subsequently doesn't fit with original post.

in the words of dragons den...im out

But if you are out that is sad because I think you have a lot of experienced players here trying very hard to help and I'm sure your questions could be very useful also
 
Please explain what that means and why you mention it.



I think we have a real communication problem here and sincerely I would love to sort it out. I don't think you are a troll but there are very obviously some misunderstandings here and it does seem what you say subsequently doesn't fit with original post.



But if you are out that is sad because I think you have a lot of experienced players here trying very hard to help and I'm sure your questions could be very useful also
Thete were some basic questions asked in the beginning..From my last post i feel you have selected snippets that dont make sence without the rest of it..i.e. the lebayle in context it makes sense..the legere 2 worked lovely on it but i dobt use that piece because a patch wont stay on it.. From thete you ask the 2.5 sounds better than what ..my post tells you the answer..Pete..the original post wasnt about why i play legere not cane, why i ruined 1 or 2 reeds in excessive heat..none in all my time in the church hall, how after nearly i years yep that surprised me i cant place a reed on a mouthpiece, even tho my teacher thinks its fine..it just starts to get a bit, or sound a bit patronising..People saying i don't want to hear things without saying what..its just getting a bit daft...tbf..i appreciate the advice but its drifted..
 
I really think we need to bear in mind that @eb424 is asking genuine questions.

Our experienced members are very obviously desperately trying to help but points are being missed. In my opinion because @eb424 posts as though he was speaking to you if you were there with him.

Unfortunately this doesn't always work well on a forum as people lose track of the "conversation" and a post in between means more than one thing ends up being discussed at once.

I have lost track of the original question despite following the thread. 🙂 And suspect others have too.

Jx
 
Last edited:
I really think we need to bear in mind that @eb424 is asking genuine questions.

Our experienced members are very obviously desperately trying to help but points are being missed. In my opinion because @eb424 posts as though he was speaking to you if you were there with him.

Unfortunately this doesn't always work well on a forum as people lose track of the "conversation" and a post in between means more than one thing ends up being discussed at once.

I have lost track of the original question despite following the thread. 🙂 And suspect others have too.

Jx
Not to surprised after 6 pages. Lol
I don't want to offend anyone or anyone to think i don"t appreciate or take notice of the advice.
Tbf my heads s very strange place.
 
Last edited:
At the risk of stirring up Hornets:

The TW and the 2.75 strength reed you say sounds best - is this because you prefer an airy/fluffy sound? If this sound is solely because of the reed (being a bit too hard) then articulation, not to mention low notes, will be problematic.
 
On the subject of splitting reeds - like others, I can’t even remember the last time I had a reed split - clarinet (Bb and Eb and bass), soprano, alto or tenor sax. And this includes practising 10 hours per day (a looong time ago), a hard-playing tour (60 date, 3-hour set that included lots of playing in the altissimo and a loud band), and the more recent years of my new L’aissaiz Faire style where I play once every few months.
Are you keeping the reed on the mouthpiece after use?
 
On the subject of splitting reeds - like others, I can’t even remember the last time I had a reed split - clarinet (Bb and Eb and bass), soprano, alto or tenor sax. And this includes practising 10 hours per day (a looong time ago), a hard-playing tour (60 date, 3-hour set that included lots of playing in the altissimo and a loud band), and the more recent years of my new L’aissaiz Faire style where I play once every few months.
Are you keeping the reed on the mouthpiece after use?
Hi..No I always took the reeds of at the end of the night and put them in my case..I think the issue was that I should have taken them off when I stopped for a ciggie etc..It was mainly the summer few weeks when it was over 100 degrees in the van.. I think the constant wetting and quick drying of the cane reeds didn't help..Tho TBF life seems much simpler with the legeres..
 
At the risk of stirring up Hornets:

The TW and the 2.75 strength reed you say sounds best - is this because you prefer an airy/fluffy sound? If this sound is solely because of the reed (being a bit too hard) then articulation, not to mention low notes, will be problematic.
Hi..I'm not really looking for that airy sound on most songs..that seems easier for me with a lower strength reed where articulation is more controllable...I think the benefit of cane vs legeres is the amount of variety and sounds availlable matching reeds to mouthpieces..With the legere i suposse I could try the American cut..It's hard to define but the 2 sig on the TW sounds tinnier the 2.75 seems to have more depth, if that makes sence..
 
Hi..I'm not really looking for that airy sound on most songs..that seems easier for me with a lower strength reed where articulation is more controllable...I think the benefit of cane vs legeres is the amount of variety and sounds availlable matching reeds to mouthpieces..With the legere i suposse I could try the American cut..It's hard to define but the 2 sig on the TW sounds tinnier the 2.75 seems to have more depth, if that makes sence..
Perfect sense. And if you go even softer it will produce a quacking-like sound no doubt.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,563
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom