- Messages
- 4,216
- Location
- london
I would say if thats where the reed plays best..keep it there tbf..I do listen to what people say and take notice accordingly..however sometimes queston how it's said..TBF the threads gone way of track..It's not about cane the caravan or my placement of the reed, which is fine according to my teacher or whether a 2.5 is ok: it was about whether working harder for a better tone is worth it..btw if you can stand in a pool of sweat dripping wet in over 100 degrees heat with no aircon because thats all youve got to practice in, and not damage a couple of no 2 cane reeds i take my hat of toPerhaps consider paying attention to what other folk are suggesting, then?
So far we've established that you place your reeds on in a manner most would consider incorrect; somehow are destroying your cane reeds in your caravan (for context, I've had my saxes in pretty much any climate, and neverhad the issues you're describing); probably have general issues at the bottom end of the horn.
So the first thing for me would be to place the reed correctly, then start to work on your bottom end. The 2.5 legere seems to work for you, so stick with it whilst placing it correctly on your mouthpiece. If after a while it's still playing too soft, try moving up. Alternatively do the same with the 2.75, but given you've said you're having a harder time with it, that seems the incorrect approach. Perhaps also consult with your teacher and see what they suggest....
Or just carry on doing whatever it is you've already decided you want to do.....
TBF after 7 years I humbly disagree..my teacher says it's fine..Granted im no pro but you assessing my reed placement telepathically is wonderful maybe you could give me telepathic lessons while im sweating my nuts of.. ;-) could you answer what it is you think I want to hear..Without meaning to be rude, you've said enough on this thread that makes me think that perhaps you aren't qualified enough to day where a reed plays best. 😉
I disagree the thread has gone off track, the only thing is nobody is saying what you want to hear.
But as I say, if you've decided you know best and want to ignore the other folk suggesting what to do (of which there are several and people way more qualified than I), then be my guest.

