Reeds Legere and other synthetic reeds

For synthetic reeds, I used to be a Legere American Cut all the way guy (at least on tenor), but then the 2nd generation Venn reed from D’Addario came out, and I haven’t picked up a Legere since. I wish that they had a 2.33 strength😛, as the 2.5 can be a bit stiff and the 2.0 is much too soft for me.

FYI, D’Addario now offers an exchange of strength program just like Legere, which reduces the financial “risk” a bit (or at least softens the mental blow when spending $30/reed).
 
Last edited:
I use American Cut and rotate between 5 of them but don't find them pricey, the 5 I have were bought between October 2019 until now and they are all still playing strong so that makes it less than 2 per year, around £54 per year that relates to 2 boxes of 10 cane reeds per year, so not that pricey for me.
Cane typically lasts me 6 weeks at least, so 8 per year. Synthetic about 4 months, so 3 per year. A box of 10 cane reeds costs me $30, a synthetic $25. That works out to synthetic costing triple what I pay for cane. I consider the convenience of synthetic worth the extra cost on my doubles (clarinet, soprano, bari, bass). But I just can't tolerate the synthetic sound on my main voices (tenor and alto).

However, someone like @skeller047 who only gets 2 days out of a cane reed, would save a lot of money on synthetic. That's about 18 boxes per year for a total of nearly $600 versus $75 per year for synthetic.

Considering the material cost of synthetic is just pennies, they still seem obscenely over priced to me.
 
Last edited:
Cane typically lasts me 6 weeks at least, so 8 per year. Synthetic about 4 months, so 3 per year. A box of 10 cane reeds costs me $30, a synthetic $25. That works out to synthetic costing triple what I pay for cane. I consider the convenience of synthetic worth the extra cost on my doubles (clarinet, soprano, bari, bass). But I just can't tolerate the synthetic sound on my main voices (tenor and alto).

However, someone like @skeller047 who only gets 1 day out of a cane reed, would save a lot of money on synthetic. That's about 36 boxes per year for a total of nearly $1100 versus $75 per year for synthetic.

Considering the material cost of synthetic is just pennies, they still seem obscenely over priced to me.
I suppose everyone is different, I could never get a cane reed to last me 6 weeks so for me synthetic works just fine but like I just said we are all different.
 
It's time to replace my Legere reed which I have been using on and off for a couple of years, are the signature line still the best for general play, I think that is the model I have at the moment, difficult to tell as the logo's have worn off. Are there any other synthetic contenders on the market with recommendations. Thanks in advance.
I started out with the Signature, which was fine, but later tried the American Cut which I found to be more responsive with a tone that really satisfied my ear. Have therefore stayed with the American Cut for almost 2 years - it's now my "go-to" reed.
(PS: tried the Studio Cut as well, but did not like the tone one bit!)
 
Depending on which horn I'm playing, I use either Legere Signature, or the Fiberreed Onyx, or Copper Onyx. For bari and bass I don't like the sound & response I get with Legere reeds, so that's where I use Harry's Onyx or Copper Onyx reeds.

Just like cane reeds, I use 4 synthetics in rotation on all my horns. 4 rotated regularly last me more than a year. That is far cheaper than cane, and the consistency is worth it. Unless people see what reed I put on my MP, no one can tell I'm using a synthetic.

As for Fiberreeds sounding like duck calls. That has certainly not been my experience. That said, YMMVALW 😉 :sax:
 
Hey, whatever works. I have a string of outdoor gigs coming up on bass sax, so will switch from my usual Rico to Legere to mitigate any drying out between sets. Not my ideal sound, but like you said, the audience won’t know or care.
 
Cane typically lasts me 6 weeks at least, so 8 per year. Synthetic about 4 months, so 3 per year. A box of 10 cane reeds costs me $30, a synthetic $25. That works out to synthetic costing triple what I pay for cane. I consider the convenience of synthetic worth the extra cost on my doubles (clarinet, soprano, bari, bass). But I just can't tolerate the synthetic sound on my main voices (tenor and alto).

However, someone like @skeller047 who only gets 2 days out of a cane reed, would save a lot of money on synthetic. That's about 18 boxes per year for a total of nearly $600 versus $75 per year for synthetic.

Considering the material cost of synthetic is just pennies, they still seem obscenely over priced to me.
Given the way synthetics behave for me, I would be happy to pay more for cane. But my math is much like yours. I certainly get more than 2 days out of a reed.

When I was playing shows for a,living, I once had an alto reed that I played every day for 6 weeks; I was just playing one reed at that time instead of rotating. Actually that experience led me to return to rotating, because it was painful breaking in a new one when it finally died. Most of my reeds lasted a week or two. Nowadays, being retired and lazy, who knows…
 
...there was a long period of my life where three reeds a week is about right...

...I expect 20 or so hours per reed, so 2-3 reeds a week is not out of line...
I was floored by this, so it stuck with me. Never in million years could I wear out a reed in just 2 days when 6 weeks of hard playing on a very open mouthpiece is normal for me. But you were apparently doing just that for years. Of the hundreds of other sax players I've known in my life, none come anywhere close to 2 days per reed. Whenever I need an example of extreme reed wear, you're always the first who comes to mind.
 
Last edited:
I was floored by this, so it stuck with me. Never in million years could I wear out a reed in just 2 days when 6 weeks of hard playing on a very open mouthpiece is normal for me. But you were apparently doing just that for years. Of the hundreds of other sax players I've known in my life, none come anywhere close to 2 days per reed. Whenever I need an example of extreme reed wear, you're always the first who comes to mind.
I think this depends on the player and how much playing he/she does.
I can remember a post from the other forum a few years ago by "Woody Reed" Euge Groove who said that he got through a massive amount on reeds, I can't remember the exact figures but it was a scary amount.
 
I think this depends on the player and how much playing he/she does.
I can remember a post from the other forum a few years ago by "Woody Reed" Euge Groove who said that he got through a massive amount on reeds, I can't remember the exact figures but it was a scary amount.
Of course. Playing hours is better for comparison than days or weeks. I probably get around 40 hours out of a reed, which is about 6 weeks for me. Most of my peers are similar. I'd have to play 20 hours/day to wear one out at @skeller047 's rate, 24 hours/day at Euge's rate.

But with Euge, could it be that he was not necessarily wearing them out, but just rejecting lots of them, i.e., finding only one in a box of 25 that he found acceptable? I'd never heard him before, so I took a listen. He sounds pretty chill. I just don't hear the energy required to shred a reed in a day. Maybe as a session player, he just prefers a fresh reed for every session. That's totally understandable for a pro with really high standards. But at the end of the day, the reed is still perfectly fine after a couple of hours of playing time, not actually worn out.

I suspect that in both cases, there are some bad estimates and exaggerations. It just seems impossible for anyone to wear out reeds at such an accelerated rate.

Regardless, I'm rethinking my original point that you may actually save money using synthetics if your cane reeds tend to wear out prematurely. It seems like the massive forces wearing out your cane reeds would also wear out the synthetics at a proportional rate. So if I get 40 hours from a typical cane reed, and 120 from a typical synthetic, someone who only got 8 hours from the same cane reed would only get 24 hours from a synthetic. That would mean if @skeller047 got 2 days from cane, he'd only get 6 days from synthetic.
 
I was floored by this, so it stuck with me. Never in million years could I wear out a reed in just 2 days when 6 weeks of hard playing on a very open mouthpiece is normal for me. But you were apparently doing just that for years. Of the hundreds of other sax players I've known in my life, none come anywhere close to 2 days per reed. Whenever I need an example of extreme reed wear, you're always the first who comes to mind.
Sorry for confusing you @lydian. I think it’s more like a reed a week - per horn. 20 hours or so. I worked in show bands, did the casual/club date thing, played jazz gigs - playing alto, tenor, clarinet, flute, piccolo, occasionally soprano sax, alto flute (and a foolish 2 year foray into oboe and English horn).

So.. 4 single reed horns, rotating 8 reeds per horn. 20 hours per reed, 3 reeds a week implies a 60 hour work week. I suppose with practice, reharsals, gigs and jams I did play that much some weeks - most weeks, probably closer to 50.

For a single horn, 1 reed out of 8, being rotated, means that it was in my case for at least 8 weeks. And got used on average for one of those weeks. And usually only alto and/or tenor would get replaced; soprano and clarinet less often. So yeah, 2-3 reeds a week makes sense in that way.

Rather than hours, let’s look at services. I would expect 8 - 12 services (1 rehaearsal, 1 gig, 1 practice session, etc.) out of a reed. I don’t think that’s extreme at all.

For real extremes you have to look at those folks I call the “chuckers”. Try a reed, if it doesn’t work, chuck it. I’ve seen guys go throug an entire box in an hour that way…

[EDIT] You get 40 hours of playing out of a reed. I’m not really out of line with that. I’ve posted elsewhere about the 6 week alto reed I had once - played the same reed every night for 6 weeks. It was a great reed, but the pain of finding a new one led me back to rotation as a general rule.

In those days I was playing a lot - every day practice, rehearsal for a new show once or twice a week, 6 nights a week on stage for two shows, big band after hours gig. off night jazz gig, jam with the show rhythm sections, jam with the local cats, weekend afternoon cocktail parties, occasional recordings - you get the picture. I was busy. Lotta hours, lotta reeds.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for clarifying. So you’re saying rotating cuts your reed life in half, but gives you a more consistent experience over time. I would have expected rotating to increase reed life somewhat. I guess I may as well keep doing my play it til it dies method. Only takes me a few minutes to adjust to a new reed.

These days as an amateur, I only average about 8 hours playing time per week across 4 reed instruments, only one of which is primarily synthetic. With this schedule my reeds last quite a long time. I always carry 4 good reeds per instrument in case one dies.
 
Some reeds last longer, others die on the 3rd play. 20 hours average seems about right. Really just a guess. The 6 week reed was 15-20 hours a week, on alto, so an outlier. Darn good reed…. Dick Oatts uses your approach, he plays them until they “turn green”.
 
Of course. Playing hours is better for comparison than days or weeks. I probably get around 40 hours out of a reed, which is about 6 weeks for me. Most of my peers are similar. I'd have to play 20 hours/day to wear one out at @skeller047 's rate, 24 hours/day at Euge's rate.

But with Euge, could it be that he was not necessarily wearing them out, but just rejecting lots of them, i.e., finding only one in a box of 25 that he found acceptable? I'd never heard him before, so I took a listen. He sounds pretty chill. I just don't hear the energy required to shred a reed in a day. Maybe as a session player, he just prefers a fresh reed for every session. That's totally understandable for a pro with really high standards. But at the end of the day, the reed is still perfectly fine after a couple of hours of playing time, not actually worn out.

I suspect that in both cases, there are some bad estimates and exaggerations. It just seems impossible for anyone to wear out reeds at such an accelerated rate.

Regardless, I'm rethinking my original point that you may actually save money using synthetics if your cane reeds tend to wear out prematurely. It seems like the massive forces wearing out your cane reeds would also wear out the synthetics at a proportional rate. So if I get 40 hours from a typical cane reed, and 120 from a typical synthetic, someone who only got 8 hours from the same cane reed would only get 24 hours from a synthetic. That would mean if @skeller047 got 2 days from cane, he'd only get 6 days from synthetic.
You could be right about that, Euge might just have been ultra selective, as with me I found that I was getting 2/3 great reeds out of a box of 10 then 5/6 that were ok and 1/2 that were rubbish but this was may years ago, maybe I need to revisit cane to see if this has changed.
 
You could be right about that, Euge might just have been ultra selective, as with me I found that I was getting 2/3 great reeds out of a box of 10 then 5/6 that were ok and 1/2 that were rubbish but this was may years ago, maybe I need to revisit cane to see if this has changed.
I’ve found the same proportions the entire 50-ish years I’ve been playing. No change recently. But synthetics have improved a lot, with the exception of Bari brand. They’re just as terrible as they were 50 years ago.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,541
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom