Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

I've never played by ear and never played any other instrument before (I played a little bit of piano as I was learning the theory, but not fond of it).

If you want to play jazz playing by ear is essential, reading music isn't. I was just listening to Erroll Garner (because Dave Liebman says at the start of this video
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zvA4ztA7nzs
that the 13 year-old pianist is "the next Erroll"), Erroll never learned to read music. He wrote "Misty", but someone else had to write it down for him. I've also been listening to Chet Baker, another life-long ear player. That's just to illustrate that reading music isn't necessary.

Since it is so important and you have never done it, I would suggest you spend at least half your time playing by ear from now on. Pick a tune that you could sing, and try to play it.
 
@Bernie makes a good point that listening and playing by ear is important, but there is no reason to sacrifice musical literacy while adding that to your skill set.

I would define musical literacy as the ability to hear music and produce music, rather than the ability to read written notes. I play at jam sessions with people who can read written notes, but can't produce real music as a result. The other day a group including one of these guys played All Of Me. They started three times, each time the note reader was playing in a different time to the rest of the band, but he just ploughed on, unaware of what was happening because he was reading and not listening.

I think that guy is musically illiterate. I think Erroll Garner (for example) was musically literate, even though he couldn't read or write musical notation.
 
I try to write carefully Jazzaferri, so I'd appreciate it if you would read what I say with equal care. I've never said reading music stops you improvising well, that would be a stupid thing to say, what I said is that it is not necessary to read music to play jazz.
 
Once musical experience is expanded beyond playing in jam sessions, such as playing in a concert band, big band, sax quartet, or small combo then the ability to read music---especially sightread music is essential to be able to participate.

It certainly isn't essential to be able to play in a small combo. Chet Baker, who I mentioned earlier, played with small combos all his working life and made many records, he never learned to read music. He didn't know the name of the key he was playing in. Erroll Garner too. A film biography of Garner was called Nobody Can Hear You Read, his habitual response when he was asked why he never learned to read music. He made records with orchestras by the way. These were professional musicians, there must be many many more amateur ear players around. I've been happily playing with a small combo myself recently, and I never look at the written music. The leader never looks at the music either, and he is the finest jazz musician I have played with.

It is nice to be able to tell a good story, but that is a far cry from being able to read a book.

That's a rather muddled metaphor. Let's try to get a bit of clarity:

Reading is to literature as listening is to music.

Writing is to literature as playing or singing is to music.

It's the sound of music that is its essence, not the written notation.

So someone who can play or sing well can do the equivalent of telling a good story, and someone who can listen to and understand music can do the equivalent of reading a book.

Music is understood by listening to the sound. You don't need to know what a major 7th is to understand that a major 7th chord can have a "happy" sound, to take a practical example.
 
Last edited:
The combos I play in have written charts and arrangements which are much different than "lead sheets" with just the melody and chord changes. Being able to play parts accurately from written music notation is called "reading music", and its parallel in spoken language is being able to read words printed on a page. Literacy in any language includes being able to read and write words, sentences, and paragraphs in that language---including the language of music. I have no more to say on this topic.
 
I would define musical literacy as the ability to hear music and produce music, rather than the ability to read written notes. I play at jam sessions with people who can read written notes, but can't produce real music as a result. The other day a group including one of these guys played All Of Me. They started three times, each time the note reader was playing in a different time to the rest of the band, but he just ploughed on, unaware of what was happening because he was reading and not listening.

I think that guy is musically illiterate. I think Erroll Garner (for example) was musically literate, even though he couldn't read or write musical notation.
Sorry , that isn't a problem with reading music, that's a musicianship problem - and that type of thing happens to readers and non-readers.
 
I play in bands where we are performing specific arrangements, not lead sheets, playing by ear is not relevant in that context. I accept it would be feasible, but difficult, to learn the parts by rote and play from memory, but that is not the same thing. It would also be ridiculously time-consuming, which is precisely why notation was developed: to make it easier to pass music on to others without having to serve the apprenticeship of a medieval bard or minstrel who learnt an entire repertoire from memory whislt serving a 'master'.
 
A few years ago I was in a sax quartet and someone brought a piece that was so note dense in spots and so fast all I could do was completely fake it in the 16th sections. Fortunately it was a tune I knew and no one said anything nasty.

I still struggle to sight read a few bars of 16ths at speeds in excess of highway speeds
 
You will not pay your dues and you will not be taken seriously if you can't read music amongst the Jazz musicians. You cannot walk into a jazz Jam which is what jazz is all about anyway. In the open the real book to a page in a song that you have never heard before. Most likely you're going to look pretty stupid. I have Jam with cats who are like in their eighties who knew every tune in that book. But still you're not going to be respected as a jazz musician if you cannot read music. At least not respected by the people that you want to be respected by... they will be nice to you and they will respect you as a human being and as a musician in general but they will not consider you a jazz musician. And in some circles you're not even respected unless you paid your dues. So you can talk about this cat never learn to read music or this guy wrote this song never learned to read but it's all book knowledge. I have lived it and lived with these guys and still jam with these guys. And you have to have the total package like the man said when the notes are coming so fast or the cords are coming really fast. Or someone wants to play free jazz you gotta have the ear going on. It took a long time before I was considered a jazz musician and even now I still have to win a cutting match before I'm taken serious. Part of paying your dues is playing in a jazz big band you can't do that if you can't read music I don't care how good your ears. It can even be difficult if you are good at playing by ear and reading music and know the song. Highway speeds man will test you.
 
Last edited:
The combos I play in have written charts and arrangements which are much different than "lead sheets" with just the melody and chord changes.

Ok, but that doesn't mean reading charts is "essential" for anybody else, does it?

Being able to play parts accurately from written music notation is called "reading music", and its parallel in spoken language is being able to read words printed on a page.

That's mistaken reasoning, as I tried to explain to you.

Literacy in any language includes being able to read and write words, sentences, and paragraphs in that language---including the language of music. I have no more to say on this topic.

It's always a tactical error to say that in a discussion JBT.
 
You will not pay your dues and you will not be taken seriously if you can't read music amongst the Jazz musicians.

So you think Chet Baker and Erroll Garner didn't pay their dues and weren't taken seriously?

But still you're not going to be respected as a jazz musician if you cannot read music. At least not respected by the people that you want to be respected by... they will be nice to you and they will respect you as a human being and as a musician in general but they will not consider you a jazz musician.

Is that what it's all about for you then, getting people's respect? That's a bit pathetic really. I'm not so needy.

Nevertheless, I find that the people I play with are quite impressed by the way I play without reading, an experienced musician last week said "wow, you have a fantastic ear" and a less experienced musician said "you are doing what we all want to do".

So you can talk about this cat never learn to read music or this guy wrote this song never learned to read but it's all book knowledge.

No, it's a fact. Many fine jazz musicians don't read music.

I still have to win a cutting match before I'm taken serious.

What a horrible way to think about music.
 
...Chet Baker, who I mentioned earlier, played with small combos all his working life and made many records, he never learned to read music. He didn't know the name of the key he was playing in...

That's just not true of Chet. He played in the Army band and studied harmony formally at college. You can't do that without some reading ability. He wasn't very good at sight reading by all accounts but I'm sure he knew the name of the key he was playing in.

Erroll Garner on the other hand probably was an ear player but he was from an earlier, less harmonically sophisticated, era. Personally I'm not as talented as Erroll or Chet so I have to use whatever means available, including reading music. You may be different.

There have been quite a few musicians who have falsely claimed not to be able to read music. It's all about image. There's a video, which I can't find at the moment, where Gerry Mulligan says exactly that about Chet.

I did find this which also confirms what I said above.

 
from here THE FOLK WHO FEEL JAZZ: CHET BAKER


"Russ Freeman talked about Chet's ability to read music in this 1990 interview.

Also, the because Chet Baker was not a composer, it has lead people to believe he was musically illiterate. I think that it was Baker's ability to play what was in his head, rather than what was written down, that made him such a great musician."

Please note the use of the word "illiterate".
 
That's just not true of Chet. He played in the Army band and studied harmony formally at college. You can't do that without some reading ability. He wasn't very good at sight reading by all accounts but I'm sure he knew the name of the key he was playing in.

Erroll Garner on the other hand probably was an ear player but he was from an earlier, less harmonically sophisticated, era. Personally I'm not as talented as Erroll or Chet so I have to use whatever means available, including reading music. You may be different.

There have been quite a few musicians who have falsely claimed not to be able to read music. It's all about image. There's a video, which I can't find at the moment, where Gerry Mulligan says exactly that about Chet.

I did find this which also confirms what I said above.


I get the impression that when the "greats" say they don't read music, they are really talking about sight reading off the page at break neck speeds, such as would be needed playing complex pieces in a large orchestra. I find it hard to believe any of them are totally ignorant after playing all those years. One would have to learn a lot, even if by accident. Scott Hamilton has stated before that he doesn't read music. He said once that he could never play in a big band setting where he would have to sight read the page. But I don't for a minute think he couldn't lay some music theory on you if he wanted to.
 
Last edited:
what I said is that it is not necessary to read music to play jazz.

No but it really helps,what if you are called on to play a tune out of the Real Book that you have never heard before as Eoe has already said,reading and playing by ear go hand in hand,they compliment each other.
Starting to read music is not difficult,mastering it is but its just practise.
 
That's just not true of Chet. He played in the Army band and studied harmony formally at college.

He got through the army band audition by faking playing while listening to the other trumpet players playing the first time though, the second time through he played the tune. He was later thrown out of the band by a newly appointed and more officious senior officer who thought (quite rightly) that the band members were a lot of druggy slackers. He was required to sight read a test piece, and couldn't do it.

He wasn't very good at sight reading by all accounts but I'm sure he knew the name of the key he was playing in.

Not according to musicians he played with.

Erroll Garner on the other hand probably was an ear player but he was from an earlier, less harmonically sophisticated, era.

He was known for employing novel chord voicings.

Personally I'm not as talented as Erroll or Chet so I have to use whatever means available, including reading music. You may be different.

Hmm. Well I don't suppose I am as talented as them either, but I don't think you necessarily have to be specially talented to play by ear. After all, most of us are able to sing pop songs or hymns without needing to look at written music. It's a natural ability, which you can transfer to a musical instrument.
 
No but it really helps,what if you are called on to play a tune out of the Real Book that you have never heard before.

That happens to me quite frequently. If the tune is reasonably predictable I can sometimes get it the second time through. If the tune is more complex it probably isn't a good idea to try and play it if you haven't heard it before, whether you read or not. So in that case I don't play. Instead I sit out and listen to the people who rely on the written music, and note that they don't make a great job of soloing on pieces they can't play by ear.

Starting to read music is not difficult, mastering it is but its just practise.

I can read music, but I don't need to.
 
There have been quite a few musicians who have falsely claimed not to be able to read music. It's all about image.

But we've just heard how other jazz musicians won't give you that all-important respect if they think you can't read!
 
Please note the use of the word "illiterate".

I was trying to make a rather subtle point about "illiteracy" Dibbs. JBT missed the point, I think you have too. Aldevis got it though it seems. Go back and read what was said, carefully.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,565
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom