trimmy
One day i will...
- Messages
- 9,674
- Location
- Liverpool ( Pool of Life )
Homework for the 6th !!Try another nursery rhyme of have a go at St. James' Infirmary.
Homework for the 6th !!Try another nursery rhyme of have a go at St. James' Infirmary.
I've never played by ear and never played any other instrument before (I played a little bit of piano as I was learning the theory, but not fond of it).
@Bernie makes a good point that listening and playing by ear is important, but there is no reason to sacrifice musical literacy while adding that to your skill set.
Once musical experience is expanded beyond playing in jam sessions, such as playing in a concert band, big band, sax quartet, or small combo then the ability to read music---especially sightread music is essential to be able to participate.
It is nice to be able to tell a good story, but that is a far cry from being able to read a book.
Sorry , that isn't a problem with reading music, that's a musicianship problem - and that type of thing happens to readers and non-readers.I would define musical literacy as the ability to hear music and produce music, rather than the ability to read written notes. I play at jam sessions with people who can read written notes, but can't produce real music as a result. The other day a group including one of these guys played All Of Me. They started three times, each time the note reader was playing in a different time to the rest of the band, but he just ploughed on, unaware of what was happening because he was reading and not listening.
I think that guy is musically illiterate. I think Erroll Garner (for example) was musically literate, even though he couldn't read or write musical notation.
The combos I play in have written charts and arrangements which are much different than "lead sheets" with just the melody and chord changes.
Being able to play parts accurately from written music notation is called "reading music", and its parallel in spoken language is being able to read words printed on a page.
Literacy in any language includes being able to read and write words, sentences, and paragraphs in that language---including the language of music. I have no more to say on this topic.
You will not pay your dues and you will not be taken seriously if you can't read music amongst the Jazz musicians.
But still you're not going to be respected as a jazz musician if you cannot read music. At least not respected by the people that you want to be respected by... they will be nice to you and they will respect you as a human being and as a musician in general but they will not consider you a jazz musician.
So you can talk about this cat never learn to read music or this guy wrote this song never learned to read but it's all book knowledge.
I still have to win a cutting match before I'm taken serious.
...Chet Baker, who I mentioned earlier, played with small combos all his working life and made many records, he never learned to read music. He didn't know the name of the key he was playing in...
That's just not true of Chet. He played in the Army band and studied harmony formally at college. You can't do that without some reading ability. He wasn't very good at sight reading by all accounts but I'm sure he knew the name of the key he was playing in.
Erroll Garner on the other hand probably was an ear player but he was from an earlier, less harmonically sophisticated, era. Personally I'm not as talented as Erroll or Chet so I have to use whatever means available, including reading music. You may be different.
There have been quite a few musicians who have falsely claimed not to be able to read music. It's all about image. There's a video, which I can't find at the moment, where Gerry Mulligan says exactly that about Chet.
I did find this which also confirms what I said above.
what I said is that it is not necessary to read music to play jazz.
That's just not true of Chet. He played in the Army band and studied harmony formally at college.
He wasn't very good at sight reading by all accounts but I'm sure he knew the name of the key he was playing in.
Erroll Garner on the other hand probably was an ear player but he was from an earlier, less harmonically sophisticated, era.
Personally I'm not as talented as Erroll or Chet so I have to use whatever means available, including reading music. You may be different.
No but it really helps,what if you are called on to play a tune out of the Real Book that you have never heard before.
Starting to read music is not difficult, mastering it is but its just practise.
There have been quite a few musicians who have falsely claimed not to be able to read music. It's all about image.
Please note the use of the word "illiterate".
