Playing the saxophone Learning to Read v Playing by ear

After thinking about this for a while I don't think Georgia is a good tune for a sit in at this stage. It's a lovely old song that the band do play but it's not typical of the New Orleans genre. Tenor isn't a mainstay of the band so fitting in is difficult, especially with a four piece front line. You're there to fatten the sound imo so look for holes in the harmony and spaces in the rhythm/phrasing

When starting out it's important to get the phrasing and feel right as well as the tune and harmony. New Orleans has a bounce and swing. Long tones and little rhythmic phrases. Tonic is your friend. Most of this genre stick to I IV V with a middle eight that goes up a tone or a fourth/fifth or wanders off minor.

Long tones and little rhythmic phrases. Tonic is your friend. Most of this genre stick to I IV V with a middle eight that goes up a tone or a fifth or wanders off minor.

They usually play the song through twice ensemble, to make sure everybody has got it, and then watch the trumpet for the solos. If it's two out, first one is usually simpler and quieter then go for the big finish

I'd recommend Bill Bailey (F) which might seem a little passe, but it's surprising how many tunes from this genre use the chord sequence with a different melody, in different keys and tempos. You learn one sequence and get half a dozen songs under your belt at the same time. You'll often hear the band saying it's a Bill Bailey sequence and even joke about it when Bill Bailey crops up. Bill Bailey is a Bill Bailey sequence to the tune of Bill Bailey.😀

Simple songs with a verse chorus format ABAB or AABA or such like are easy to follow and more importantly, easy to pick up when you drop them.
 
I don't think Georgia is a good tune for a sit in at this stage.
Having tried to work out what I'm going to do with it, I agree. However, that's the one it's going to be and I'll have to do my best. I think that will amount to playing as little as possible with the band and my solo will be the melody. I agree, Bill Bailey would be easier but I don't know it and whether I've got time to learn it for Tuesday, what with seasonal interruptions, I doubt. Do you know in what key they play it? Even better, please will you tell me the start note (in concert, to avoid doubt). If I know where to start I can work the rest out from there.

Thanks for the advice.
 
At Colin the Bear's suggestion I'm learning "Bill Bailey". There's nothing special about that except that it's taking me a step further in playing by ear. This is the first time I've needed to learn anything properly by ear - on previous occasions either I've had no need to get it right so I've tootled away to suit myself or I've had sheet music available to make sure. This time I've got to get it right without sheet music. Please don't bother sending me any because that will spoil the exercise. It's a tune that I didn't know previously so I've had to refer to You Tube to find how it goes and I've settled on Ella Fitzgerald's version to copy. That brings up another issue: I've got to learn it in F but Ella sings it in Eb. Solution: follow Ella in Eb - that teaches me the melody - then play it in F. It's working well.

This may all seem simple stuff but it's part of my learning curve. It may be of interest to others who are deliberately learning to play by ear, a subject that few teachers seem to teach.
 
I had another go at sitting in with a local jazz band last night. I flatter myself in thinking that my efforts weren't quite so dreadful as my first try the week before. I don't propose to post week-by-week accounts of my progress but there are three things that are worth saying:
First of all, thanks to the Forest New Orleans Jazz Band for giving me this wonderful opportunity to learn to play. Coming to music as an old-age-pensioner, I've missed the opportunity of youth that most good musicians took to learn their trade. When you're young you learn more rapidly and, more important, people of your own age are at the same level as you so you grow together in skill. It's much more difficult for older people because most musicians of their own age already know how to play and a learner like me has nothing to contribute to their music. There are "beginners' bands" but, so far as I know, these all depend on reading sheet music and playing prearranged parts. The Forest New Orleans Jazz band have agreed among themselves to give me the opportunity to learn on the job, which is the best, if not the only, way of learning to play their kind of music. That's why I'm so grateful to them. I suspect that many other such bands would have the same attitude to learner musicians and I'd encourage people like me to take such opportunities if they're offered.
Secondly, thanks to Colin the Bear for his advice and encouragement. You've seen some in this forum but he's done much more for me on the spot.
Thirdly, I've learned that when you're playing with a jazz band, the really important aspect of improvisation isn't your solo. I had a brief try at soloing last night and simply played the basic melody, so far as I could remember it. Where you must improvise is when the band's playing together. The trumpet takes the melody and the others in the front row play around it. I had a go at this last night and some bits of what I played seemed (at least to me) to fit - hey, maybe I'm learning to improvise! The point here is that we're all familiar with backing tracks where we take the lead. More important to me now is playing with tracks which include the melody and learning to make up my part.
 
Oh Ivan.....we should meet and have a few beers! Right eye lens replaced with plastic one because of cataracts. In photos my eye comes out white and the other one red! Will get the other one done in a couple of months.

Three bottom front teeth knocked out in the same tackle that did my wrist. Right knee awaiting a "scrape" out hopefully later this year. Chiropractor booked for my back!

Actually in comparison with some of my pals i am not doing so bad!!!! It is all relative and I'm not complaining when I see other peoples' situations.
I have visions of you looking like The Terminator!
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,566
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom