Saxophone beginners Learning to read standard notation vs using the note names

Writing the names of the notes will, with enough repetition, become redundant.
As with reading music notation - ie once you have learned the song. My point above was that using conventional notation is a much quicker way to learn music because you have the immediate visual cue such as the contour of the melody and the rhythmic notation and spacing.

But I do understand that note names work if you have a mental block against the concept of learning to read music. But it is like training wheels on a bike - ideally you give them up as soon as you can in order to develop the more useful skills.
 
Last edited:
Everyone that I know can read music. I understand that not reading music is your choice, but please don’t normalize it to the world. Your path is a difficult one that makes a goal of mastery a tortuous one.
In 45 years of playing I have never come across this way of playing, everyone I have played with in bands have had some level of reading ability.
I know many players, some are very good, that are not capable of reading music. Good players but, of course, limited. I love when killer readers, well educated and good players and autodidact players that are not capable of reading and no music education can join each other in easy music styles.
 
By becoming redundant, I meant that the brain will adapt with repetition, so that the note is perceived on the staff
Only if they are written on the actual music notation.

But if they are like this, as discussed in post #18:

16956766006454584863460760254508-jpg.23997


then the notes cannot be perceived on the staff unless you can already read music.
 
Notation is like the alphabet, when you know it information can be recorded and passed to others, who get exactly what you send and do not have to rely on remembering what you said. They can then pass it on without adding misheard information. Of course errors in the original can occur but if you sent by email the only errors that occur will be those that you sent in the original message. The other advantage is that notation is mostly a world wide convention.
 
I know many players, some are very good, that are not capable of reading music. Good players but, of course, limited. I love when killer readers, well educated and good players and autodidact players that are not capable of reading and no music education can join each other in easy music styles.
Probably because they learned jazz or classical. It’s a bit like asking a bricklayer why his carpentry skills aren’t good.
 
I know many players, some are very good, that are not capable of reading music.
I have come across players that can't read and some were excellent players, quite a few of them had relative pitch and some had perfect pitch hearing, but non that followed Eddie's way of reading but whatever works is fine it's all music at the end of the day, but you have to deal with the limitations at some time in your musical journey if you want to go down the path of playing in some situations.
 
Probably because they learned jazz or classical. It’s a bit like asking a bricklayer why his carpentry skills aren’t good.

It’s a bit like asking a bricklayer why his carpentry skills aren’t good.
One of the guys I was think on started study classical sax and the other guy was a rocker before and after university. We shouldn't underestimate the social ability.
 
One of the guys I was think on started study classical sax and the other guy was a rocker before and after university. We shouldn't underestimate the social ability.
Focusing on another style of music can certainly move people away from previous fluidity in another style.
 
but you have to deal with the limitations at some time in your musical journey if you want to go down the path of playing in some situations.
Who aren't limited? For some years ago we were asked to play some blues and rock songs at a company event. We decided to do some Springsteen songs. Just for 45-60 min. The guy that were going to play the tenor sax solos became sick so we decided to ask a young professional jazz player if he could play. No problem he said, Springsteen and Clemons are easy songs to play. When he came to the rehearsal he started to play the solos. He could play as it was written but the rest was a big insult to Springsteen and Clemons and all the fans. A thin tone, no energy, no volume .... it was terrible!!!! How on earth could he say that it was easy! No self-criticism or suffering from narcissism. A bricklayer is usually not searching job as a carpenter?!?! I never play jazz and I would definitely not saying it's a piece of cake.
 
A bricklayer is usually not searching job as a carpenter?!?!
No, but I used this as an example because you seemed critical of people who were outside their area of knowledge. On the other hand, if they thought they were “nailing” it then I’m with you.
 
I'm talking about the rhythm of the melody part itself. For some songs it's rather important (eg "Fascinating Rhythm"). How is that covered by drums, strings etc?
TBF i only play pop and rock songs..i play to words first and then remove them..Ive not heard of the song..sorry just different strokes..

Everyone that I know can read music. I understand that not reading music is your choice, but please don’t normalize it to the world. Your path is a difficult one that makes a goal of mastery a tortuous one.
Im not normalizing it..i joined a thread that was discussing it thats all..I do read music i have to.. I just dont play to scores. No need for me

I have come across players that can't read and some were excellent players, quite a few of them had relative pitch and some had perfect pitch hearing, but non that followed Eddie's way of reading but whatever works is fine it's all music at the end of the day, but you have to deal with the limitations at some time in your musical journey if you want to go down the path of playing in some situations.
When the times right and if i have to i will..I read dots but will have to sort out rhythm..

@thomsax , the only reason I dredged reading back up was a recent post from another beginner who said they didn’t want to learn to read. I was just trying to convince them that they should. I realize Eddie will never need to read charts. But it would save him the trouble of writing his own. That dead horse has been thoroughly beaten.

I admit that I rely very heavily on reading due to the nature of my gigs. I have to play hundreds of different charts all the time, many of which I never see until the downbeat at the gig. And of those, most are inner harmony parts that make no logical sense which makes them more difficult to memorize. So why bother memorizing hundreds of weird parts I may never play again?

I stand by my recommendation for any beginner to learn to read.
I am learning and do read..the reason i transfer it is to condense the score and for me navigation is easier. Also trouble withbthe size ofvthe dots..for me its just easier.

Needing to read and the usefulness of being able to read are two very different things. Obviously one needs to read to do gigs that require that ability, but the other aspect is the time you can save and the added value that it gives your practicing. If you ever want to memorise a tune, then one very important tool is the ability to read music because it allows you to internally visualise, or virtually "hear" the music just by looking at the notation.

Somewhere else it was said that when music is memorised, 9 times out of 10 you play it better. Although that may not apply to those who have memorised the music but want the notation there "just in case" - so then the confidence of knowing you could have a quick glance if you forgot something may help you.

But if you rely on reading note names then it is a method that is big waste of time and can really hold you back in terms of musicality.
But tbf Pete repetition playing to the track and looking at my scores is just the same

The way Eddie plays suits him but he has said that he wants to play with other musicians in bands and also in workshops,
the problem he has is that without reading skills there is zero opportunity for him to realise his ambition.


In 45 years of playing I have never come across this way of playing, everyone I have played with in bands have had some level of reading ability.
Solo saxophonists as oppossed to groups i guess

The limitations I was thinking of were more of the non reader not being able to do big band or other situations where reading was necessary.
I do read i have to transpose and transfer onto my lyric sheet..it makes navigating easier and the fonts bigger

As with reading music notation - ie once you have learned the song. My point above was that using conventional notation is a much quicker way to learn music because you have the immediate visual cue such as the contour of the melody and the rhythmic notation and spacing.

But I do understand that note names work if you have a mental block against the concept of learning to read music. But it is like training wheels on a bike - ideally you give them up as soon as you can in order to develop the more useful skills.
It's not a mental block. The notes written are the transposed notes..point taken re visual patterns or contour of the melody. I completely understand the importance of reading and when the time is right will prioritise it..
 
When the times right and if i have to i will..I read dots but will have to sort out rhythm..
Actually, that’s no different to what you have to do with letter names. So, no time like the present Eddie..
(Please stop using the word “scores”)
 
When the times right and if i have to i will..I read dots but will have to sort out rhythm..
You have been saying this for the last 3 years, I am interested to know what do you consider the circumstances that will lead to you making that decision.
What you can't seem to grasp is that your way is harder work in the long run.
 
In my experience, for most people who actually know that reading music is more efficient or at least better than writing in note names, it is a mental block.
Hard agree with this. Learning the dots on the stave will take a fraction of the time it took to learn the fingerings on your actual saxophone. What I don't get from the voluminous threads everywhere on methods to circumvent needing the dots, is that the dots are an actual shortcut.
 
Hard agree with this. Learning the dots on the stave will take a fraction of the time it took to learn the fingerings on your actual saxophone. What I don't get from the voluminous threads everywhere on methods to circumvent needing the dots, is that the dots are an actual shortcut.
Aye, it’s a pretty good method of carrying a lot of information.
 
Aye, it’s a pretty good method of carrying a lot of information.
Defo agree, tried learning the guitar and learning the letters along the fretboard,
this was a disaster until the penny dropped and the notes became chords.
I decided to learn the fingerings on the sax which became the notes which linked the notes to the stave etc.
Anyways pick what works and have fun, but then again what do I know. 😉
Dale
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,550
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom