Saxophone beginners Learning to read standard notation vs using the note names

New thread here:


NB: as it has been split, in order to continue getting notifications you need to resubscribe, ie click on the watch link at the top.
 
Last edited:
You have been saying this for the last 3 years, I am interested to know what do you consider the circumstances that will lead to you making that decision.
What you can't seem to grasp is that your way is harder work in the long run.
Hi @jazzdoh..I think when theres a need..i.e. if i went back to sax bandits or played with otheres who play from scores. I have had lessons and know i need to work on rhythms..I know the benefits of playing from scores as @Pete Thomas said i cant play songs i don't know which is a valid point. Time is an issue too,

I have been trying to get 20 songs under my belt. I enjoy playing and want to do the care home set or at least open mike.. ( lol cant help thinking of an autopsy) really didn't enjoy the bandit experience, holding on to play a couple of bars of a song just wasnt me..
 
Only if they are written on the actual music notation.

But if they are like this, as discussed in post #18:

16956766006454584863460760254508-jpg.23997


then the notes cannot be perceived on the staff unless you can already read music.
This is not a score Eddie. (It’s not music either, but…)
 
This is not a score Eddie. (It’s not music either, but…)
A whole piece of music, with all instruments shown is called a score.
Piano parts are usually referred to as that, a piano score.
Other parts are usually called “parts” ie sax part, flute part etc.
- I’m not sure of a note in my part so can I check the score -
It’s confusing to just call everything you use a score.
 
But it isn’t that now! I came from my mum but I’m not called Pam…
No but if you were referring to mum you wouldn't say Pete..lol..thought i had only referred to the original doc as a score.anyhoo I'm sure you don't need this on a beautiful Saturday morning..do appreciate all the advice though..have a lovelly weekend.
 
I just use this with the backing track i can't read fast enough yet to play the songs i enjoy playing..i'll get there tho it's just time..
The only way you will get faster is by doing it, it won’t fall in you lap, but you already know this.
Why don’t you just pick a piece of music with backing track that is easier and learn it using reading and go from there, I hope you do get there Eddie but you have to make a start, but the longer you leave it the harder it will be.
 
How do you sightread a song you don’t already know using the letter method? You’ve spared yourself a headache but given the audience one instead.

When you write down music, whatever method you choose, you need to convey the following in order to reproduce it accurately and fully - which pitch to play (including which octave), when to play it, how long to play it, how loud to play it and how to articulate it. Traditionally written music on those annoying lines gives you all of the above information. Letters only give you the pitch, not even which octave. All the rest depends on you already knowing the song or just making up all the other details.

No matter how annoying, I encourage all musicians to learn at least the basics of reading music, even if you play primarily by ear. It will enhance your understanding of rhythm, key and form and open the door to literally millions of written charts you may have never heard. A child can learn to read music in a couple of weeks, an adult not much longer. It’s well worth the small amount of effort.
Hi for me i take it from the score and circle high notes or low notes depending on which are fewer..The backing track gives me the rest..I have learnt the basics i need too know in order to convert the original score onto my lyric sheet which i find easier. I can't read that fast so by converting I am able to play the songs I want to which are usually a fast tempo.. but can navigate round a score slowly..I can understand that most on the cafe have been playing and teaching for years and that there is a definate benefit to reading music if you are playing traditionally and with others it makes complete sence, i will learn..I think I will always just play by myself hopefully one day to an audience so I am not currently prioritising improving my reading..Theres also the issue that the songs on Karaoke version dont match the original tunes exactly...but slowly slowly
 
OP plays simple pop tunes, none of which would ever have more than a one page lead-sheet. I don’t understand where these scores are coming from.
I buy the original score with lyrics from music notes. TBF they may be simple tunes to you but Bobby Mcgee was 9 pages, Meatloafs two out of three ain't bad are complex for me. I used them all for what I saw as essential learning curves and staminner..E.G. Bobby Mcgee incorporated palm keys, had a key change from G to E major so incorporated 4#s as most of my tunes do...There also fairlyhigh tempo so theres a need to write the notes on currently.
 
Theres also the issue that the songs on Karaoke version dont match the original tunes exactly...but slowly slowly
Karaoke Version use to say what artist " made famous by" if it's not the original artist. There is also some differences if it's a live recording or a studio recording. Other things to look out for is that some songs are fading out and that can be tricky how to stop .....? Fading out or where to cut it off?
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,548
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom