Saxophone beginners Learning to read standard notation vs using the note names

You must play the horn parts as they are written. When I played in a horn section we had all horn parts written and we played/learned the horn parts as they were written. Even easy stuff like "I'm A Man", "Hoochie Coochie Man", "Hi Heels Sneakers" ..... . I could play the easy stuff from memory. In fact I played most horn parts from memory. But some good (maybe they weren't so good after all) and experienced players couldn't play without a note stand and sheet music in front of them. That's also weried? Addicted?? I don't know why a person that writes a letter on the sheet music seems to be odd while a player that can't play without sheet music must have a paper in front of them? I'm a tolerant person. Just do what you like as long as we are making good noise, friendly to each other and having fun.
 
Last edited:
@thomsax , the only reason I dredged reading back up was a recent post from another beginner who said they didn’t want to learn to read. I was just trying to convince them that they should. I realize Eddie will never need to read charts. But it would save him the trouble of writing his own. That dead horse has been thoroughly beaten.

I admit that I rely very heavily on reading due to the nature of my gigs. I have to play hundreds of different charts all the time, many of which I never see until the downbeat at the gig. And of those, most are inner harmony parts that make no logical sense which makes them more difficult to memorize. So why bother memorizing hundreds of weird parts I may never play again?

I stand by my recommendation for any beginner to learn to read.
 
Poor memory in my case.
Yes, and that's is fine. That's why we use sheet music. I'm not reading/playing so complicated arrangements so I understand that you need sheet music.

We played "Real Real Gone" for some years in different keys (different singers). A tenor player couldn't play without the horn part. We did the song in concert G and also in C. We changed the horn part once so the tenor part that was on the note stand was in D instead of A. The tenorist had the wrong sheet music but played just fine. She is a fine player. But that shows she didn't need the sheet music.
 
I realize Eddie will never need to read charts.

I admit that I rely very heavily on reading due to the nature of my gigs.
Needing to read and the usefulness of being able to read are two very different things. Obviously one needs to read to do gigs that require that ability, but the other aspect is the time you can save and the added value that it gives your practicing. If you ever want to memorise a tune, then one very important tool is the ability to read music because it allows you to internally visualise, or virtually "hear" the music just by looking at the notation.

Somewhere else it was said that when music is memorised, 9 times out of 10 you play it better. Although that may not apply to those who have memorised the music but want the notation there "just in case" - so then the confidence of knowing you could have a quick glance if you forgot something may help you.

But if you rely on reading note names then it is a method that is big waste of time and can really hold you back in terms of musicality.
 
Last edited:
@thomsax , the only reason I dredged reading back up was a recent post from another beginner who said they didn’t want to learn to read. I was just trying to convince them that they should. I realize Eddie will never need to read charts. But it would save him the trouble of writing his own. That dead horse has been thoroughly beaten.

I admit that I rely very heavily on reading due to the nature of my gigs. I have to play hundreds of different charts all the time, many of which I never see until the downbeat at the gig. And of those, most are inner harmony parts that make no logical sense which makes them more difficult to memorize. So why bother memorizing hundreds of weird parts I may never play again?

I stand by my recommendation for any beginner to learn to read.
Yes, reading music is important. Especially when you decide that music is going to pay your bills. I'm impressed by musicians that can do club gigs, play symphonic music and play a big band wedding gig within a week. From "Hoochie Coochie Man" to ABBA gold.
 
Needing to read and the usefulness of being able to read are two very different things. Obviously one needs to read to do gigs that require that ability, but the other aspect is the time you can save and the added value that it gives your practicing. If you ever want to memorise a tune, then one very important tool is the ability to read music because it allows you to internally visualise, or virtually "hear" the music just by looking at the notation.

Somewhere else it was said that when music is memorised, 9 times out of 10 you play it better. Although that may not apply to those who have memorised the music but want the notation there "just in case" - so then the confidence of knowing you could have a quick glance if you forgot something may help you.

But if you rely on reading note names then it is a method that is big waste of time and can really hold you back in terms of musicality.
I wish I had a copy of Andrew N White III's essay on "The Fallacy of the Oral Tradition", where he, as an African American musician deeply steeped in African American improvised music, described emphatically and eloquently just why and how WRITING IT DOWN saves time and prevents errors. Not the attitude you might expect from someone so deeply involved in that form of music.

And it's clear that the most efficient way to communicate music in writing is standard notation. There is room for improvement in standard notation (though little has been proposed and none adopted), but of the systems currently available (tab, standard, written note letters, etc.) standard notation always outperforms the others.
 
I’m curious how others memorize music, simple melodies, not Rachmaninoff piano concertos. For me, it’s not a collection of note names. I literally play back the tune in my head and play along without ever thinking note names, just matching sounds in my head. Such tunes I would have learned entirely by ear in the first place without ever writing anything down.

I don’t have perfect pitch. But if someone asks me to play a tune I’ve never played before but have at least heard before, I can usually play it by following along with the sounds in my head, again with no concept note names coming into play at all, but possibly thinking intervals or major/minor. I imagine this is what most people do, but I’ve never asked.
 
Everyone i know who uses backing tracks does it.. no one is saying that reading music isn't important or at least i havent..the backing track is your music, timing, rhythm, all you need are notes. Distinguishing octaves i just circle the note..issue is for me the length of the scores and how to fit 9 pages on a stand. Also the backing tracks are usually slightly different from the score re copyright. Backing track with words first notes are only syllaballs, then remove the words, and play..

Everyone that I know can read music. I understand that not reading music is your choice, but please don’t normalize it to the world. Your path is a difficult one that makes a goal of mastery a tortuous one.
 
The way Eddie plays suits him but he has said that he wants to play with other musicians in bands and also in workshops,
the problem he has is that without reading skills there is zero opportunity for him to realise his ambition.

like i said i know pub players and most do the same.
In 45 years of playing I have never come across this way of playing, everyone I have played with in bands have had some level of reading ability.
 
Everyone i know who uses backing tracks does it.. no one is saying that reading music isn't important or at least i havent..the backing track is your music, timing, rhythm, all you need are notes. Distinguishing octaves i just circle the note..issue is for me the length of the scores and how to fit 9 pages on a stand. Also the backing tracks are usually slightly different from the score re copyright. Backing track with words first notes are only syllaballs, then remove the words, and play..
Since this was just quoted, I'll point out again that you do "know" at least in the internet sense, someone who has used backing tracks extensively, both for personal practice and professional performance, and who never writes note letter names in but simply reads the standard notation as needed.

I did work with a keyboard player/songwriter whose music-reading skills appeared to be rudimentary at best and he wrote out melodies as a string of letters. Of course, to get the rhythms correct took considerable practice. He was a hell of a player and composer of songs, and he's gone on to be a full time professional musician, but I don't know if he ever got his reading together.

I too have been playing improvised music for about 45 years and I've come across a huge range of capabilities from zero music reading to 100% reading. The vast majority of professional musicians I"ve worked with had a range of modalities they used, from pure ear playing to pure reading. The fact that you can read music and play something exactly as written does NOT mean you can't play purely by ear. And of course anyone who's ever come across an error in printed music knows very well that even playing in an orchestra is "playing by ear" - when you run across that error, you don't play the wrong note (at least not after the first time), you play the right note, because your EAR just told you it's the wrong note.
 
Since this was just quoted, I'll point out again that you do "know" at least in the internet sense, someone who has used backing tracks extensively, both for personal practice and professional performance, and who never writes note letter names in but simply reads the standard notation as needed.

I did work with a keyboard player/songwriter whose music-reading skills appeared to be rudimentary at best and he wrote out melodies as a string of letters. Of course, to get the rhythms correct took considerable practice. He was a hell of a player and composer of songs, and he's gone on to be a full time professional musician, but I don't know if he ever got his reading together.

I too have been playing improvised music for about 45 years and I've come across a huge range of capabilities from zero music reading to 100% reading. The vast majority of professional musicians I"ve worked with had a range of modalities they used, from pure ear playing to pure reading. The fact that you can read music and play something exactly as written does NOT mean you can't play purely by ear. And of course anyone who's ever come across an error in printed music knows very well that even playing in an orchestra is "playing by ear" - when you run across that error, you don't play the wrong note (at least not after the first time), you play the right note, because your EAR just told you it's the wrong note.
I think there has to be a use of both when using improvised music, I too have come across various levels of reading ability from poor to super readers but you do need some level of reading ability if you want to play big band but playing by ear and reading is the best approach overall but I have not come across any other players that just write the letters above the lyrics but if Eddie is ok with this and it works for him that's great.
 
In rock and pop, it’s usual to play the music by heart, rather than reading from a page. I commented in another thread that I think it’s a Bad Idea (TM) to write down the names of the notes. In the example here, it’s also kind of useless, as there is no indication of the rhythm. So in order to play the tune, you kind of have to already know it, in which case I think your time would be better spent just playing the tune, instead of writing the note names on the page.

I understand you are just doing this for yourself, and you are probably just going to play along with backing tracks, no other musicians involved. So it’s really your thing, and you can do exactly what you want. But my advice, and apparently I’m not alone, is to either not bother with this intermediate step (you will learn the tune better) - OR - go the next step and learn to read and write music in the traditional way. That will take longer, but trust me, it will pay dividends.
 
So in order to play the tune, you kind of have to already know it, in which case I think your time would be better spent just playing the tune, instead of writing the note names on the page.
Time will also be better spent doing ear training and learning some very basic theory, which will also make learning tunes easier and quicker.
 
Writing the names of the notes will, with enough repetition, become redundant.

I can remember doing it when starting out, untill it wasn't needed.

Sitting with an album cover and a recorder, playing the lyrics, was a pastime too.

Some have a natural rhythm and play what they've heard.

We're all on the same road. Some have a destination and want to get there asap. Some are picking flowers on the verge.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,550
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom