Playing the saxophone Learning to improvise in all the keys

AlonW

Member
Account closed
Messages
435
Location
Somewhere in space
Level
Jedi Master
I've been trying to learn to improvise in all the keys, and found a feature of IReal Pro that helps with this. You can modulate up a half step each time the song repeats, so I just set the song to Rhythm Changes and 30 repeats and then let it go through all the keys as I play along and improvise.

Screenshot 2025-01-23 at 4.37.06 PM.webp
 
It might be what you “should “ do in the name of being well-rounded or ultimately prepared. But, depending upon what type of music you tend to find yourself playing, it will rarely happen. Rhythm Changes is only a jazz phenomenon too.
 
It might be what you “should “ do in the name of being well-rounded or ultimately prepared.
Agreed, or rather it's a great exercise to do, not that I've ever done it. When I was ever in a situation of having to play a standard in a non-standard key (e.g. a singer suddenly asks for Misty in Ab, then I tended to struggle - but then I never called myself a jazz musician anyway even though I was sometimes in those situations. I was possibly one step ahead by the fact that I knew those sorts of tune in with alto and tenor keys (as well as concert pitch because my mind automatically thinks in concert pitch along with transposed keys) That may seem an advantage but I remember one specific incident where I ended up with egg on my face.
But, depending upon what type of music you tend to find yourself playing, it will rarely happen. Rhythm Changes is only a jazz phenomenon too.

Very true. The only other example where it's probably something you should know is the tune Mac the Knife, where it is (or was) common to modulate up a semitone for each chorus. Again only what we might call a jazz phenomenon.
 
Last edited:
Agree completely. If you set your stall out to be a “jazzer” then I think you have to be prepared for someone to call a tune at 300+ bpm and in any key. It’s definitely a lot of work to get there, but if you’re a player who finds yourself doing this, that AND the other, then unless you’re a freak (some are) and have the energy and application to work on everything, all day long, then you have to pick what is going to be most useful and useable on whatever bandstand you step onto.

If you’re just delving into stuff, maybe it’s more important to work in a few keys but work more on how, what and where you play rather than just being able to do something in every key.

I admire the application though, and many of us have dabbled with Rhythm Changes in all keys, until you realise that the few “challenging “ keys always remain “safe” in your playing rather than fluent and interesting. Then you have the choice of whether to work properly on improving those keys or not.

Most tunes are called in the key of the Real Book. That doesn’t suit every instrument so changing key to one that sits nicer on your particular horn is a fantastic thing to do. Getz always did this. Getz also picked tunes in random keys just to be awkward to the rest of the band too, and because he could.

I’m not an out and out jazzer but I’ve done a fair few gigs with a Rhythm Changes tune, and can say that it was probably called in one of just two or three keys I suspect.

It’s a bit like the old adage: pick your fights…
 
Well, the exercise isn't just about being able to play Rhythm in all keys. Both the A part and the bridge of Rhythm are standard chord progressions in all of popular music, and being able to negotiate through those patterns in all keys is a huge leg up in being able to cope with whatever one encounters on the bandstand. Sure, most RB tunes are in flat keys, but then most rock and roll tunes are in sharp keys.

Again, it depends on what kind of a tool box you want to have. There have been many artistic musicians with very limited tool boxes, who played in a very limited number of keys and a very limited number of forms. Personally, knowing my own limitations as an artist, I have ended up focusing on being a competent player in whatever genre and whatever key is needed. For people just starting out (or just starting out on a later-life restart) I'd advise against deciding to limit your acquisition of skills before you've even started. For those of us that have been at this a long time, well, by this time it is what it is, largely, and we work on doing the best we can with the material on hand.
 
I'd advise against deciding to limit your acquisition of skills before you've even started.
So you advise spreading yourself thinly right from the off? Bandwidth. Concentrate on becoming good at a few things (basic stuff) then branching out, if that so floats your boat.
 
This isn’t really a true statement is it. Rock n Roll tunes that go around the houses?
The I VIm7 IIm7 V7 aspect became endemic in pop (noticeable doo wop and "bubble gum") music of the 50s / 60s though often I VIm IV V7 so I would say it's maybe kind of standard back then and pops up occasionally since. It's also standard in that even if you have very little harmony knowledge you'll hopefully recognise it by ear, e.g. Blue Moon.

But I agree I wouldn't call it standard in all of pop music. I V VI I may be more standard.

Also the IGR bridge I don't think is standard in all pop music.
 
So you advise spreading yourself thinly right from the off? Bandwidth. Concentrate on becoming good at a few things (basic stuff) then branching out, if that so floats your boat.
I guess there are two different approaches. By getting accustomed to playing in any key from the get-go, you have no "difficult" keys - at least that's the theory. For example, in Suzuki bass teaching, one school of thought has the little kids starting out in thumb position (where the notes are close together and easier to finger for little hands) and when they get more advanced, there's no difficulty perceived in thumb position, because that's where they started.
 
I guess there are two different approaches.
I agree. Maybe even three (but I haven't thought of the third one yet).

In some respects any approach can be good - or maybe (hopefully) someone can disagree and/or disprove that.
 
I hesitate - as a complete amateur - to reply.

I've been playing tenor sax with an (old school) amateur rock/pop band for the past 6 months. In that time, I've had to learn to play in (for me, new) 'transposed' keys to common 'concert keys' used by the band. I can transpose concert keys 'on the fly'.

IMHO. learning to play in all keys depends on your ambition - especially the range of bands, artists and arrangements that you (want to be able to) work with. IHMO, it also depends on the sax roles that you (want to) fill. 'Fills' (in any concert/transposed key ) are relatively easy to learn or improvise. Solos (in any 'unfamiliar' key) are more challenging. M humble advice (as an amateur) is to look up some representative video's.
 
The I VIm7 IIm7 V7 aspect became endemic in pop (noticeable doo wop and "bubble gum") music of the 50s / 60s though often I VIm IV V7 so I would say it's maybe kind of standard back then and pops up occasionally since. It's also standard in that even if you have very little harmony knowledge you'll hopefully recognise it by ear, e.g. Blue Moon.

But I agree I wouldn't call it standard in all of pop music. I V VI I may be more standard.

Also the IGR bridge I don't think is standard in all pop music.
Eg C - Am - Dm7 etc is quite different to E7 - A7 - D7 - G7
 
Eg C - Am - Dm7 etc is quite different to E7 - A7 - D7 - G7
Yes very different indeed. I should actually have said that E7 - A7 - D7 - G7 is not standard in any pop music. I can only recall one pop song with it now I come to think about it.
 
Yes very different indeed. I should actually have said that E7 - A7 - D7 - G7 is not standard in any pop music. I can only recall one pop song with it now I come to think about it.
Which is what I meant, though I didn’t say it. Granted, the R Changes that Gershwin wrote were not all dominants, but isn’t that what everyone has come to use since Bebop?
 
@AlonW, what you are doing is good stuff, good for your ears and good for your fingers. Who cares what keys you get thrown at you or what type of music you end up playing, doing this helps your ears to show the way and is worth the effort. Eventually we all get a bit blase about this seemingly basic rote work but opening your ears is always valuable and then it gives you freedom.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,420
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom