Agreed, or rather it's a great exercise to do, not that I've ever done it. When I was ever in a situation of having to play a standard in a non-standard key (e.g. a singer suddenly asks for Misty in Ab, then I tended to struggle - but then I never called myself a jazz musician anyway even though I was sometimes in those situations. I was possibly one step ahead by the fact that I knew those sorts of tune in with alto and tenor keys (as well as concert pitch because my mind automatically thinks in concert pitch along with transposed keys) That may seem an advantage but I remember one specific incident where I ended up with egg on my face.It might be what you “should “ do in the name of being well-rounded or ultimately prepared.
But, depending upon what type of music you tend to find yourself playing, it will rarely happen. Rhythm Changes is only a jazz phenomenon too.
So you advise spreading yourself thinly right from the off? Bandwidth. Concentrate on becoming good at a few things (basic stuff) then branching out, if that so floats your boat.I'd advise against deciding to limit your acquisition of skills before you've even started.
This isn’t really a true statement is it. Rock n Roll tunes that go around the houses?Both the A part and the bridge of Rhythm are standard chord progressions in all of popular music
The I VIm7 IIm7 V7 aspect became endemic in pop (noticeable doo wop and "bubble gum") music of the 50s / 60s though often I VIm IV V7 so I would say it's maybe kind of standard back then and pops up occasionally since. It's also standard in that even if you have very little harmony knowledge you'll hopefully recognise it by ear, e.g. Blue Moon.This isn’t really a true statement is it. Rock n Roll tunes that go around the houses?
I guess there are two different approaches. By getting accustomed to playing in any key from the get-go, you have no "difficult" keys - at least that's the theory. For example, in Suzuki bass teaching, one school of thought has the little kids starting out in thumb position (where the notes are close together and easier to finger for little hands) and when they get more advanced, there's no difficulty perceived in thumb position, because that's where they started.So you advise spreading yourself thinly right from the off? Bandwidth. Concentrate on becoming good at a few things (basic stuff) then branching out, if that so floats your boat.
I agree. Maybe even three (but I haven't thought of the third one yet).I guess there are two different approaches.
Eg C - Am - Dm7 etc is quite different to E7 - A7 - D7 - G7The I VIm7 IIm7 V7 aspect became endemic in pop (noticeable doo wop and "bubble gum") music of the 50s / 60s though often I VIm IV V7 so I would say it's maybe kind of standard back then and pops up occasionally since. It's also standard in that even if you have very little harmony knowledge you'll hopefully recognise it by ear, e.g. Blue Moon.
But I agree I wouldn't call it standard in all of pop music. I V VI I may be more standard.
Also the IGR bridge I don't think is standard in all pop music.
Yes very different indeed. I should actually have said that E7 - A7 - D7 - G7 is not standard in any pop music. I can only recall one pop song with it now I come to think about it.Eg C - Am - Dm7 etc is quite different to E7 - A7 - D7 - G7
Which is what I meant, though I didn’t say it. Granted, the R Changes that Gershwin wrote were not all dominants, but isn’t that what everyone has come to use since Bebop?Yes very different indeed. I should actually have said that E7 - A7 - D7 - G7 is not standard in any pop music. I can only recall one pop song with it now I come to think about it.
