I'm just wondering whether we should talk about education or scales...
They are highly related without a doubt. Most people who see no value in learning scales probably feel that way because of how scale study had been presented to them. If someone just hands you a book of scales and says, "Here learn these scales and you'll be a good musician", that's total baloney.
Just as like as I described with mathematics, there's a whole context of application that is missing from that approach.
In fact, if I may I would like to make comparison between learning math and learning scales using the following two examples:
The Wrong Approach to Teaching (IMHO)
In Mathematics
1. Teach someone a whole bunch of boring rules of math.
2. Then give them a bunch of problems to apply them to.
3. Then say, "See? Do you understand now?"
No, that doesn't work very well, at least not for me.
In Music Theory
1. Teach someone a whole bunch of boring scales and modes.
2. Then give them a bunch of chord progression to play over.
3. Then say, "See? Do you understand now?"
No, again, that doesn't work for me at all.
There's a whole big GAP in that type of teaching process, IMHO
Here's the correct way to teach each either one (IMHO).
In Music
1. Give the student a concrete example of a piece of music where several different scales are being played over a chord progression.
2. Explain to them why the different melodies in different places sound different (i.e. are based on different scales and modes)
3. Then give them actual chord progressions to play over using each type of scale and mode to create the different moods.
Suddenly they don't even think of it as being "Scales Studies", instead they simply see it as studying MUSIC.
Same thing with mathematics.
In Mathematics
1. Give the student a concrete example of related quantities in nature (Concrete Applied Mathematics)
2. Explain to them how the qualitative interactions can be
quantified and
conserved, thus producing "rules of relational behavior".
3. Then give them concrete examples that are similar to the example just give, and see if they can begin to see how to model that behavior in terms of the
quantified conserved qualities.
(It's actually the
conservation of energy and matter that gives our universe the property of being mathematically consistent. Our mathematics would not even work or apply to a universe where energy and matter are not
conserved) , 2+2 wouldn't necessarily equal 4 in such a universe.
Ok, I confess that the mathematics "
sounds" more complicated, but truly it's not, especially if the introductory examples are chosen to be easy to work with. Then expand from there.
For example when I taught electronics I started with Ohm's law E = IR etc. (different people use different letters). But I made clear what these letters represented in terms of
conserved physical quantities.
Then I taught why I = E/R and R = E/I
must also be true in a very intuitive way, not just using abstract symbols and rules of algebra, but simply because physical properties in our universe
obey conservation laws. That's what makes mathematics WORK.
Then from there I start to give other ways of discovering the values for these three basic quantities of electronic, thus each E, I, and R can slowly be replaced with more complex descriptions until the student is working with very complex equations that still appear to them to simply be E=IR in a just more detailed form. But they can still see why everything must remain balanced. They begin to recognize what is "E" and what is "I" and what is "R" even when those things are being described in very complex ways.
Old students leaving my classes tell the new students coming in, "It's all E, I, R. That's all it is!"
Of course there's a lot more to maths than this, but still, the point I'm making is that people can actually get an intuitive grasp of algebra without having ever heard the word "Axiom" or "Rule". When I'm done with them they understand algebra
intuitively.
Then the axioms and rules start to make sense because they understand what's actually going on that causes these rules to
come into being.
It's the same way with music theory. Music theory
comes into being because of what music is. Music doesn't
come into being because of what music theory is. That's backward thinking. Understand the music and the theory falls out of that understanding. Understand the behavior of nature and the mathematics will fall out of that understanding.
Axioms, scales, and rules, fall out of understanding. Understanding does not fall out of axioms, scales, and rules.
Just my perspective on things. ;}