Surely scales and all that implies, were invented so that theorists, mathematicians and those not realising that if it sounds right, it is right, had something to teach and thus earn money?
Reading this caused a few thoughts to bounce around in my empty brain. (ha ha)
One thing to realize is that many western instruments were actually themselves invented and designed around the 12-note well-tempered system. So suggesting that scales were invented by theorists doesn't quite hold cork grease. Of course, I realize that you were posting this with tongue in cheek, but still, it's causes one to ponder.
I'll be the first to agree that theorists, mathematicians, and some music teachers, are over-zealous predators when it comes to finding music theory students to prey upon.
Just the same, there is some value in analyzing the musical system that all of our instruments are based on.
I would also be the very first to agree that no music "theory" is required to make good music. Good music is nothing more than pleasing or interesting sound and if a person can accomplish that without any 'theory' then clearly they do not need 'theory'.
Theory is really nothing more than an analytical explanation of why something sounds good. Once an analysis has been made, further theory (i.e. further analysis) suggests that if we take our understanding of why something sounds good and work backwards from there, we could use that knowledge and process to then create new music that also "sounds good". (that's the "Theory")
I certainly feel that "music theory" (i.e. an understanding of why some things sound better than other things) is useful information to have. Like I say, it's certainly not required. But surely it can't hurt.
UNLESS someone gets so bogged down in music theory that they totally ignore the natural artistic spontaneity that truly brings music to
LIFE. Once they lose site of that, then they have lost an appreciation for music altogether and have become totally lost in a barren dry desert of "music theory".
So there needs to be a combination of the two: Artistry and Analysis if music is to have any life.
And, of course, the analysis itself is totally unnecessary if a person can artistically produce music without bothering to analyze what they are doing.
I think those kind of "innately spontaneous musical artists" are probably the exception rather than the rule. So this leave "music theory" as a valuable tool for the rest of us to try to play 'catch-up'.
Fortunately for me, having been involved in physics and mathematics, I actually view music theory as somewhat
FUN.
And I also confess to
not being an "innately spontaneous musical artist".
But hopefully, I'm
ALIVE enough to make half-way decent music with the help of a little bit of music theory.
🙂))
Although on some days even that comes into question. ;}