Saxophone beginners Learn to play melodies or scales?

That's cute! 🙂))

You should go to an assistance office and apply for disability. When they ask you what the problem is just say, "I'm dyscalculic and I have my mathematics flunking papers right here to prove it"

See, you ARE a mathematician in the most natural innate way.

For real mathematicians mathematics is all about patterns. Numbers are nothing other than tools they use to quantify patterns.

But you see beyond the numbers and just comprehend the patterns directly.

This reminds of something some famous mathematician once said. Sorry I can't remember who he was, but here's what he said:

"A mathematician needs to calculate the differential and integral calculus using abstract symbols and numbers, but God,... well ...., She just does it intuitively, no calculations required."

See ArtLady, you're a Goddess of musical note patterns and didn't even know it. No calculations required, just play the music intuitively. ;}

Ah!!.... so I could have passed CSE (yes I'm that old) maths instead of getting ungraded if they'd just played me tunes instead!! 🙂))

Well I'm an ear player for sure rather than a reader (although I can do both) and I must admit it took me years to get my head around the fact that a #4 is also a b5 ;}

I like that...."Goddess of Musical Note Patterns" :mrcool :thumb:
 
I didn't know you were a Mathematician did I miss something? :confused:

Well, kind of. I've been involved in some mathematical banter with OG and SD in another thread. I was assuming you'd seen that. Sorry for any confusion.

Nope never ever got told that
It sounds like maybe you did - see below

.....just could never and still cant do it - how the heck can x+y=b anyway!!? and as for square roots :confused:
A fair question. You do need to be quite clear about the rules of the game with something like x+y=b before you can get anywhere. But let's not go into that now.

I even had to bail out of the OU Tech of Music course at the first assignment, even after having a very nice OU tutor come to my house who spent 2 hours going through the "basic maths" needed for the course with me (wasn't very basic to me at all - basic to me is 1+ 1 = 2 and 2 x 2 = 4 🙂)) )
This is just the kind of thing I'm talking about. It doesn't sound very tactful of your "very nice" OU tutor to describe something as "basic maths" when you were obviously having problems with it. Far too many teachers boost their own egos in this way at the expense of their students. And maths teachers are some of the worst, in my experience.

I sort of got it while he was there explaining it but by the time I tried to do the assignment that evening....it had all gone again 🙁 Im pretty certain I'm dyscalculic.
I think that's very unlikely. I wasn't there, I know, but it sounds like you sort of got it but were too intimidated by the situation to grill the guy about the bits you didn't get. And you can't expect to pick this stuff up in a single 2-hour session, any more than you could learn to play the sax that way. There are skills to be learned and that takes practice. Sticking a negative label like "dyscalculic" on yourself (or on asomeone else) is just cruel (OK, maybe there are a handful of people around with some kind of brain disorder which means they can't do that kind of reasoning, but I don't think that's what we're talking about here.) Doesn't it frustrate you when someone whistles a tune and then describes themself as tone-deaf?

I don't quite understand what you mean about knowing a few note patterns, I don't have a problem with that - don't need maths for that :confused: thank goodness! :thumb:
I just meant that when Brian (jazzdoh) was talking about "relying on the maths of music" I was interpreting that as "knowing a few note patterns and chord sequences", rather than anything deeply mathematical. I wouldn't dream of suggesting that you don't know any, especially after hearing the clip you posted recently, which was well above my level of playing.
 
Isn't pure maths a bit like philosophy,
In a word, no. In three words, NO, NO, NO!!!! Philosophies are a product of the time and culture in which they were written. And to me, that's the only thing that makes them interesting. The theorems of pure maths are just plain true, and always will be (and some of them are even useful!). The problem with pure maths is that, without studying it thoroughly, you can't really understand what the words mean. So you get popular presentations which water it down to the point where it's meaningless. Marcus de Sautoy's TV programs are a particularly bad example of this. He seems to be going out of his way to be obscure. Pure maths has got to be the most rigorous intellectual discipline there is, definitely no bull**** allowed.

more thought than actual output? However we have various abilities, some better than others especially if encouraged by the right teacher, we can be well above average.
My take on the natural abilities issue is that most of us never get anywhere near the limits of them. And neither should we, as we have other things to do with our lives. But there's an attitude which is quite strong in our culture which says "you've either got it or you haven't". I think that attitude is very destructive. It discourages people from taking up music, for example, because "I've never had any talent for that kind of thing." It even deprives the people at the top of their fields of the proper credit for achieving their mastery, by dismissing them as "geniuses".

The right coupling between coach and client achieves results. Moral:-Find the right person and techniques, then you'll become as good as you are able, whether it's playing a saxophone, speed reading, speed dating or running the CaSLM. Guess that lets me out then.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So why did I find Maths, Physics, Chemistry a breeze, but struggled with French and Latin, despite putting more work into each of them than the other three combined? I had no problem memorising formulae and equations, but an incredible amount of problems memorising declensions, conjugations and simple vocabulary!

Same problem with sequences (such as tunes). I try hard, but they don't stick. When we had to learn our multiplication tables, I really struggled. But with the help of a few that stuck (like 6x8) and the 5/10 times table I was able to calculate the answers before the teacher realised I hadn't memorised anything.

Same goes for learning poetry, or quotes from books for English. Didn't work.

I work in IT. A few years ago a new guy was recruited. Good mathematician (at least he had a degree in it), but no idea whatsoever about programming. He just couldn't handle the logical sequences/constructs required for programming - which is strange for a mathematician.
 
Ah!!.... so I could have passed CSE (yes I'm that old) maths instead of getting ungraded if they'd just played me tunes instead!! 🙂))

Well I'm an ear player for sure rather than a reader (although I can do both) and I must admit it took me years to get my head around the fact that a #4 is also a b5 ;}

I like that...."Goddess of Musical Note Patterns" :mrcool :thumb:
At least in equal temperament...>:)🙂))

ahem.. got a bit carried away there - couldn't resist it 🙂

EDIT: There was a nice 'muahaha' maniacal laughter emoticon there which isn't showing, which rather detracts. Never mind.

EDIT II - sussed it!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Don't want to get embroiled in the argument, as i don't think there is an argument regarding weather you learn scales or not, put simply, how can you build chords if you cant play scales? of course you have to learn them if you are going to go anywere, how on earth are you going to know what key you are in or be able to change key etc without them? i guess it's a no brainer really, just knuckle down and learn them, adds so much more to what you will find you are able to play
 
So why did I find Maths, Physics, Chemistry a breeze, but struggled with French and Latin, despite putting more work into each of them than the other three combined? I had no problem memorising formulae and equations, but an incredible amount of problems memorising declensions, conjugations and simple vocabulary!

Same problem with sequences (such as tunes). I try hard, but they don't stick. When we had to learn our multiplication tables, I really struggled. But with the help of a few that stuck (like 6x8) and the 5/10 times table I was able to calculate the answers before the teacher realised I hadn't memorised anything.

Same goes for learning poetry, or quotes from books for English. Didn't work.

I work in IT. A few years ago a new guy was recruited. Good mathematician (at least he had a degree in it), but no idea whatsoever about programming. He just couldn't handle the logical sequences/constructs required for programming - which is strange for a mathematician.


That's very interesting and not a million miles from my experience. I started work in an office job (A levels in maths, physics and chemistry) but moved into IT after a few years and started writing assembler programs (IBM mainframe). The intersting thing was the WORST programmers were the ones with the computer science degree - illogical thought processes and an inability to keep things simple! The best ones were often language graduates.

My boss for many years was a mathematician (masters from Bristol) - he was very good.
 
So why did I find Maths, Physics, Chemistry a breeze, but struggled with French and Latin, despite putting more work into each of them than the other three combined? I had no problem memorising formulae and equations, but an incredible amount of problems memorising declensions, conjugations and simple vocabulary!
Perhaps because you weren't being taught effective methods of learning. Ugh! Rote memorisation like you're describing is the best way to put yourself off any subject. Maybe you were more interested in sciences, so that stuck a bit more.

Generally speaking we remember what we understand. Learning vocab should come from reading books and holding conversations, not from staring at a list of unrelated words for hours because we've got a test next Friday.

Same problem with sequences (such as tunes). I try hard, but they don't stick.
I find that hard, too. It helps me a lot to learn the chord sequence at the same time, and when I've learned how the melody fits with that, I'm begiinning to understand how the whole thing is put together. Then I can remember it, because it makes sense to me.

When we had to learn our multiplication tables, I really struggled. But with the help of a few that stuck (like 6x8) and the 5/10 times table I was able to calculate the answers before the teacher realised I hadn't memorised anything.
Good for you. Just how a real mathematician *would* handle such a situation.

Same goes for learning poetry, or quotes from books for English. Didn't work.
What on earth is the point of memorising poetry, or quotes from books? To make life easy for examiners, that's what. I don't have any kids myself, so I'm out of touch with school education, but I do hope today's youngsters aren't still being tortured with this nonsense, in a time when you can carry hundreds of books around on your Kindle or whatever.
I work in IT. A few years ago a new guy was recruited. Good mathematician (at least he had a degree in it), but no idea whatsoever about programming. He just couldn't handle the logical sequences/constructs required for programming - which is strange for a mathematician.
That does sound odd, but you can get through a maths degree by memorising enough stuff without really understanding it. Many of my fellow Uni students did just that, and so did many (most?) of the students I taught, despite me begging them to master a few basic principles which would be both easier and far more useful to them in the long run.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Likewise I don't want to get embroiled, but I can't remember actually having to memorise poems or text for exams even when I was at school, and that was half a century ago. Nevertheless it is useful (I find anyway) to be able to quote a line from a poem or a quote from a book at apposite times in conversation or writing, especially if it expresses the point better than I can.

In the same way it's useful to have multiplication tables and oft-used formulae in your mind (and that was hard for me as I am mildly dyslexic/dyslcalculic too); and for me it's the same thing to have knowledge of scales to build chords and melodies on and to have melodies in memory - to play and to use in solos: OG already mentioned Bird's Koko solo quote which is one of scores that he used.
 
Perhaps because you weren't being taught effective methods of learning. Ugh! Rote memorisation like you're describing is the best way to put yourself off any subject.

Unfortunately the greatest disaster for mathematics is often the way it is taught. Often times it is indeed taught from a vantage point that things simply need to be memorized.

For example, in high school I did great in early mathematics (when things were presented as concrete numbers - basically I did good in the arithmetic). However, when it became algebra, I lost it. Why? Because of the way that it was being presented to me. It was being presented to me as nothing more than a bunch of rules that must basically be memorized (at least in the way it was being taught to me). I was having trouble even accepting the rules, much less memorizing them. I didn't understand why they were they way they were.

Unfortunately, whenever I would asked for an explanation, for a better understanding of why the rules were the way they are, I would basically be scolded, and told that it's not important to understand the rules, all that's important is to learn them and know that they always hold. That simply didn't work for me and I ultimately FLUNKED out of algebra.

In fact, I actually dropped-out of high school altogether at that time. I had enough of that kind of incompetent teaching.

But my interest in learning did not stop and I went on to take an course in electronics, to my utter shock and amazement I could absolutely SEE why the rules of algebra are they way they are, because now I was manipulating variables where I understood precisely what physical quantities they represented, and how those quantities affect each other. Thanks to Ohm's Law, and all the other quantitative relationships of electrons I became an almost "Algebraic genius". All simply due to a totally different way of looking at it.

Instead of trying to just memorize a bunch of meaningless axioms and rules in a totally abstract way, I saw the actual quantitative relationships of nature.

After that, I got my G.E.D. and went on to college. I majored in physics and chemistry (not mathematics), but I took a lot of math courses in the physics and chemistry program. I breezed through calculus which is a billion time simpler than algebra (ha ha). Of course it was my deep understanding of algebra that allowed me to breeze through calculus. But that deep understanding of algebra came from having leaned electronics, NOT from having taken courses on algebra as taught in math classes, those courses were totally ineffective for me.

Anyone who has trouble with mathematics should just dump the math classes and take up something like electronics or physics. They then will learn mathematics naturally and see what it's truly all about and basically where it CAME from. Maybe then, armed with that better understanding of what mathematics is actually describing, they could then go back to the math classes with a far better understanding of what's actually going on.

Just my thoughts.

By the way, in the later years of my career I became a college instructor. I taught computer science, and electronics. My students in those classes were constantly commenting on how I taught them more about mathematics than they ever learned from their math classes. And I made it a point to do that specifically. I made mathematics EASY for them, by showing them how it actually works in nature.

It's a shame I'm retired now. Teaching was fantastic and I really miss it.
 
Likewise I don't want to get embroiled, but I can't remember actually having to memorise poems or text for exams even when I was at school, and that was half a century ago. Nevertheless it is useful (I find anyway) to be able to quote a line from a poem or a quote from a book at apposite times in conversation or writing, especially if it expresses the point better than I can.

In the same way it's useful to have multiplication tables and oft-used formulae in your mind (and that was hard for me as I am mildly dyslexic/dyslcalculic too); and for me it's the same thing to have knowledge of scales to build chords and melodies on and to have melodies in memory - to play and to use in solos: OG already mentioned Bird's Koko solo quote which is one of scores that he used.
Ah - you needed to go to my grammar school in the 70s :w00t: - Latin and French vocab, things to decline and conjugate :shocked:, big chunks of Shakespeare and poems to learn ;} - in other words, the full set!
 
I'm just wondering whether we should talk about education or scales... This has drifted into something more interesting than scales....

TV, same experiences as you.

Martin, many of my experiences with Maths were like SDs - abstract rules. Taught out of context to be memorised and filed away for later use in whatever subject used maths as a language. And it was no different when I did a maths module through the OU a few years back. But.... difference with Maths was somehow it stuck. I had little interest in in it, but I could do it. But I'm doing my best, alnog the lines SD mentioned, to teach the kids maths properly, because the understanding isn't really there.

As for rote learning, they're still making the kids do it here.

I agree we need to learn how to learn.... And it's something that generally isn't taught, and certainly wasn't when I was at school.
 
Oh dear! I had just written a long reply on how adults learn differently to children and in different ways, partly as they can use context and experience, and drawing on my own experience as an adult learner and as an management trainer. However it timed out and I lost it all. Must be a learning point there about learning to stop it timing out!

Anyway, it's interesting as it all bears very much on how people learn music as adults and this thread has shown how different people learn in different ways.
YC
 
I'm just wondering whether we should talk about education or scales...

They are highly related without a doubt. Most people who see no value in learning scales probably feel that way because of how scale study had been presented to them. If someone just hands you a book of scales and says, "Here learn these scales and you'll be a good musician", that's total baloney.

Just as like as I described with mathematics, there's a whole context of application that is missing from that approach.

In fact, if I may I would like to make comparison between learning math and learning scales using the following two examples:

The Wrong Approach to Teaching (IMHO)

In Mathematics

1. Teach someone a whole bunch of boring rules of math.
2. Then give them a bunch of problems to apply them to.
3. Then say, "See? Do you understand now?"

No, that doesn't work very well, at least not for me.

In Music Theory

1. Teach someone a whole bunch of boring scales and modes.
2. Then give them a bunch of chord progression to play over.
3. Then say, "See? Do you understand now?"

No, again, that doesn't work for me at all.

There's a whole big GAP in that type of teaching process, IMHO

Here's the correct way to teach each either one (IMHO).

In Music

1. Give the student a concrete example of a piece of music where several different scales are being played over a chord progression.
2. Explain to them why the different melodies in different places sound different (i.e. are based on different scales and modes)
3. Then give them actual chord progressions to play over using each type of scale and mode to create the different moods.

Suddenly they don't even think of it as being "Scales Studies", instead they simply see it as studying MUSIC.

Same thing with mathematics.

In Mathematics

1. Give the student a concrete example of related quantities in nature (Concrete Applied Mathematics)
2. Explain to them how the qualitative interactions can be quantified and conserved, thus producing "rules of relational behavior".
3. Then give them concrete examples that are similar to the example just give, and see if they can begin to see how to model that behavior in terms of the quantified conserved qualities.

(It's actually the conservation of energy and matter that gives our universe the property of being mathematically consistent. Our mathematics would not even work or apply to a universe where energy and matter are not conserved) , 2+2 wouldn't necessarily equal 4 in such a universe.

Ok, I confess that the mathematics "sounds" more complicated, but truly it's not, especially if the introductory examples are chosen to be easy to work with. Then expand from there.

For example when I taught electronics I started with Ohm's law E = IR etc. (different people use different letters). But I made clear what these letters represented in terms of conserved physical quantities.

Then I taught why I = E/R and R = E/I must also be true in a very intuitive way, not just using abstract symbols and rules of algebra, but simply because physical properties in our universe obey conservation laws. That's what makes mathematics WORK.

Then from there I start to give other ways of discovering the values for these three basic quantities of electronic, thus each E, I, and R can slowly be replaced with more complex descriptions until the student is working with very complex equations that still appear to them to simply be E=IR in a just more detailed form. But they can still see why everything must remain balanced. They begin to recognize what is "E" and what is "I" and what is "R" even when those things are being described in very complex ways.

Old students leaving my classes tell the new students coming in, "It's all E, I, R. That's all it is!"

Of course there's a lot more to maths than this, but still, the point I'm making is that people can actually get an intuitive grasp of algebra without having ever heard the word "Axiom" or "Rule". When I'm done with them they understand algebra intuitively.

Then the axioms and rules start to make sense because they understand what's actually going on that causes these rules to come into being.

It's the same way with music theory. Music theory comes into being because of what music is. Music doesn't come into being because of what music theory is. That's backward thinking. Understand the music and the theory falls out of that understanding. Understand the behavior of nature and the mathematics will fall out of that understanding.

Axioms, scales, and rules, fall out of understanding. Understanding does not fall out of axioms, scales, and rules.

Just my perspective on things. ;}
 
Oh dear! I had just written a long reply on how adults learn differently to children and in different ways, partly as they can use context and experience, and drawing on my own experience as an adult learner and as an management trainer. However it timed out and I lost it all. Must be a learning point there about learning to stop it timing out!

Anyway, it's interesting as it all bears very much on how people learn music as adults and this thread has shown how different people learn in different ways.
YC

I'm in total agreement with you. Adults do indeed learn different from young people. And that isn't necessarily dependent upon chronological age either.

Another way to say it is that a mature mind learns differently from an immature mind. And the maturity of a mind is not necessarily dependent upon age.

As you've also pointed out different people also learn differently from each other even without considering age or maturity of mind.

They have actually invented a word for teaching mature minds, it's called "Andragogy", as opposed to Pedagogy (the teaching of children).

I personally feel that college students should be taught as adults. Yet are colleges still continue to use standard forms of Pedagogy and are highly resistant to considering methods of Andragogy.

I was prepared for Andragogy when I was still in grade school. Well, I say that because one of the man concepts between these two styles of teaching is that Adults need to know why something is important, and they need to understand why is works. Kids are more willing to just accept axioms and rules without a need to understand them. Kids are willing to just believe whatever a teacher says without thinking about it too deeply. Thus Pedagogical methods of teachings tend to treat students in that way.

The methods of Andragogy tend to address the more mature student's needs to understand why something is important and exactly how it applies to something before they are prepared to merely learn it rote.

And this is true whether the subject is algebra, or learning scales.

The adult needs to understand why that's important before they will waste their time with it.

And they won't settle for "Because I said so".

They want a clear understanding of precisely how this is going to benefit them. They want to see how they are going to get positive results from this before they are willing to put any effort into it.

Can we blame them?

I sure want to have an understanding of how I can use something before I waste my time and effort fiddling around with it.

Adults want to see progress now. Not tomorrow.

If it isn't going to help me today, then it's probably not going to help me tomorrow either.

That's the thinking of the adult mind.

Show me some musical results today from learning scales, and I might think about studying them.

So that's what the teacher of an adult needs to do. That's what Andragogy is all about.
 
Do you need the support of a theory system that alters, to decide whether it is good or are you willing to make your own, possibly wrong judgement?

No. I don't need it for that. I need it to help me find something which is good. To attune my ears and fingers to various tonalities and the functions (sounds if you prefer) of various notes within those tonalities.

To take a random example, what does a B natural sound like in the context of D7#11? If you can hear that in your head (which is what you need to do when improvising---too late to decide you don't like it once it's played) without having practised it, good for you. I can't.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've removed a few posts, there seems to have developed an argument which went slightly beyond a "healthy" debate.

Please everyone be civil and remember it's not just name calling that causes problems, but also sarcasm and innuendo.

A very interesting thread though, and a couple of the posts I had to remove did reference myself, so I will respond to that.

Yes, I have studied a lot of scales and theory, but I also believe in the other side of the argument that if your ear is good enough, then all that study may not be very important to you.

But that's a big if.

My ears are not that good, or rather they weren't: I was practically tone deaf when young and was thrown out of the school choir. So I worked a lot on scales.

But I know many musicians who don't read, don't know chords, don't know a harmonic minor form a dorian and yet play fantastic music and improvise.

So I agree with both Fraser and Old Git.

Now let's get on with the discussion.
 
My ears are not that good, or rather they weren't: I was practically tone deaf when young and was thrown out of the school choir. So I worked a lot on scales.

Taken alongside your recordings, that's one the most encouraging statements I've ever read. I may have to frame it and clip it into a lyre on my sax when I'm practising (well, OK, maybe that's an exaggeration). Thanks
 
I'm a late bloomer also. And a guitar player. It seems to me that practicing scales is a good idea just for practice sake. But to play jazz or improvise? One needs a vocabulary of licks with the ultimate goal of being able to instantly play whats in your head on your horn. I find most sax players or musicians in general only have so many licks and repeat themselves after a while. So i'm focusing on expanding the phrases I know how to play in all keys. So, many times i'll sing the phrase then try to play it. Or copy a phrase i've heard from someone else. It has started to build from there. Even the greats like Bird and Coltrane although masters still only had a limited repertoire of things to say. I'm need to know what to play, when to play it and how to play it, given the tune.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,677
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom