Playing the saxophone Lakshmi or phil tone tribute

@eb424 What would you like to sound like? The mouthpiece, reed, ligature and sax is just helping up a little bit. You must work with your sound. You can have a dark sound on a bright mouthpiece with baffle and small chamber.

For the last 45 years I've been on three types of mouthpieces. All of them are with high baffle . The tip opening and reed (types and strengths) have been different over the years depend on how much I played. Maybe I would have a better sound if it was possible to ask guys at Café Saxophone back then? Or still searching?

You can never be sure if the mouthpiece and the set-up is right for you. You must make a decision and follow your own ideas and ears. Time is tight these days. You want to play, not searching for the right piece? At least that's what I want to do.

What kind of music are you playing? Blues, Rock & Roll, smooth jazz .....
How are you playing? In a group with less amplification .....
Where are you playing? At home, local pub, care home .....

Even an easy mouthpiece solution can be right? I was searching for the right baritone mouthpiece for several years. Larsen, Dukoff, Low Rider ...... having mouthpiece gurus to work on them .... . One day my friend suggested to try Metalite bari mouthpiece. Bingo!! That was what I needed. A standard mouthpiece for around 500.00 s e k.
 
So - with all respect - it's complete nonsense for a beginner to buy and buy and buy.
I agree 100%.
What I meant is that you can't judge how a mouthpiece sounds and/or feels without trying it yourself and stay with it for some time.

For example I have two tenors. A Conn 10M and a Beaugnier. Different schools of saxophones.
I've settled on a totally different mouthpiece on each one. And stayed for years. What plays great on one is "meh" on the other. It takes time to evaluate a mouthpiece.
And it's the best way to hinder your progress by not settling on one setup.
 
Maybe I would have a better sound if it was possible to ask guys at Café Saxophone back then? Or still searching?
Maybe I would. Back in the old days I would just get a mouthpiece that felt right when I played it - the tone was not a real issue, ie the amount of brightness. I heard saxophone players with all different kinds of tones and IO found it useful to just play the mouthpiece that felt right so I could get my sound across.

You do like to blow your own trumpet mouthpiece

Well, it helps to pay the bills for running the Cafe..
 
I sound completely different on a mouthpiece depending on which mouthpiece I'm coming from.
Yes, this is very interesting.

For me, if I'm going to go and try a few mouthpieces on a certain instrument, I want to know that I'm "the best me" - or I'll likely change my view of a mouthpiece several days in.

So that means putting in a decent week of practice on that horn and not others particularly. It also depends what you're aiming for too - old school, tenor big band, lead alto, Sanborn, Coltrane, Smooooth, Rock n Roll - the list is endless, but significant, certainly for me.

Granted, our sound will converge with all mouthpieces/setups, but not entirely. That final percentage is what I'm always aiming at and drives me nuts.
 
found it useful to just play the mouthpiece that felt right so I could get my sound across.
Sound - do you mean using a mouthpiece that gave the same output as you feel matched your input? (regarding inflections etc - sound - style? Or do you mean sound/tone/everything).
 
IMHO it's still more complex.
I sound completely different on a mouthpiece depending on which mouthpiece I'm coming from.
So I think it takes a lot longer to judge.
I'm saying this as a player who spends about 8 hours every day behind the horn.
So - with all respect - it's complete nonsense for a beginner to buy and buy and buy.
Tbf im 8 years in and would love to play for 8 hours.. I aim for 1 -2 hours weekdays and four sat and sunday..For clarity its not buying and buying i give a piece at least a month...
 
Hello all I've tried Lakshmi 7* at a local store. I found it kinda muffled.
If you're into large chamber sound on tenor , don't forget to try a NY STM. There are thousands out there, a lot cheaper. With a good ligature ( i personally hate otto link stock ligatures ) they can sound as lush as you want, and if you blow harder they are more interesting than the power-focused-laserbeam sound that everyone loves floridas for.
A NY STM can have that roaring Dexter sound. Those florida link inspired pieces have that projected link sound which is used everywhere.
Lakshmi or a STM NY are pieces for folks that aim for that old school sound.
Florida based - Tribute for example are go to mouthpieces for people that want flexibility
Pieces like Phil Tone's Mosaic are pieces that are in the middle. Fatness yet Projection.

All great pieces. You will never understand unless you try them. On you own horn. For quite a few days. One each time 🙂

This is how I see it.
I find the Lakshmi anything but muffled..I have a bag with over 100 reeds in different brands ive used. The piece seems to prefer thicker tipped french cut vandoren green no 3 sounds great but i play rsj 2hs as they are a lot more consistent.
 
I agree 100%.
What I meant is that you can't judge how a mouthpiece sounds and/or feels without trying it yourself and stay with it for some time.

For example I have two tenors. A Conn 10M and a Beaugnier. Different schools of saxophones.
I've settled on a totally different mouthpiece on each one. And stayed for years. What plays great on one is "meh" on the other. It takes time to evaluate a mouthpiece.
And it's the best way to hinder your progress by not settling on one setup.
I'm trying to settle on 1 set up..The lakshmi is as close to a piece that i can play accross the board as i have found. I think if i were playing jazz it might not be so difficult.my issue is finding a piece to play pop ( god i hate that term) and ballads..When i got the lakshmi i played nothing but " true love ways" and "buttercup" both ends of the spectrum..it plsys the highs so well and i can get aeay with true love ways...it just misses a bit of warmth..
 
@eb424 What would you like to sound like? The mouthpiece, reed, ligature and sax is just helping up a little bit. You must work with your sound. You can have a dark sound on a bright mouthpiece with baffle and small chamber.

For the last 45 years I've been on three types of mouthpieces. All of them are with high baffle . The tip opening and reed (types and strengths) have been different over the years depend on how much I played. Maybe I would have a better sound if it was possible to ask guys at Café Saxophone back then? Or still searching?

You can never be sure if the mouthpiece and the set-up is right for you. You must make a decision and follow your own ideas and ears. Time is tight these days. You want to play, not searching for the right piece? At least that's what I want to do.

What kind of music are you playing? Blues, Rock & Roll, smooth jazz .....
How are you playing? In a group with less amplification .....
Where are you playing? At home, local pub, care home .....

Even an easy mouthpiece solution can be right? I was searching for the right baritone mouthpiece for several years. Larsen, Dukoff, Low Rider ...... having mouthpiece gurus to work on them .... . One day my friend suggested to try Metalite bari mouthpiece. Bingo!! That was what I needed. A standard mouthpiece for around 500.00 s e k.
Hi @thomsax..mainly pop and various ballads..I think its harder in this genre as a piece needs to be able to do the lot..or rather i need to do the lot on a piece...e.g. I think it may be easier in jazz.. i tried the 10mfan classic great piece depth and warmth but to my ears there was a line in "everybody hurts" rem and it just sounded to dark..played true love ways luverly tho..😤
 
Tbf im 8 years in and would love to play for 8 hours.. I aim for 1 -2 hours weekdays and four sat and sunday..For clarity its not buying and buying i give a piece at least a month...
Ok, sorry.
Anyway, my impression is that MPCs seem to change if I put them in the locker for a time 🙂

people mean by the word projection.

Sorry, it's a bit OT.
I don't care about "projection", but one definition could be that "it projects more" and "it's more spread" the difference the difference between these two MPCs, an Aaron Drake NY Metal I'm playing until the guitar solo and a Gottsu Doublering after the solo. The Drake is more solid in the middle, more a "constant" beam, like a laser. The Gottsu is more like a watering can, spreading frequencies more across.
The Gottsu wants to be a Florida Link, the Drake a NY link.
But what do I know...

Listening to Samba De Orfeu with #HearThisAt
Samba De Orfeu
https://soundcloud.com/guenne-1/sam...d&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=social_sharing

I've recorded this some minutes ago, same settings, Rigotti Wild 3 on both.


If it's too OT, please ignore.
 
Last edited:
I'm trying to settle on 1 set up..The lakshmi is as close to a piece that i can play accross the board as i have found. I think if i were playing jazz it might not be so difficult.my issue is finding a piece to play pop ( god i hate that term) and ballads..When i got the lakshmi i played nothing but " true love ways" and "buttercup" both ends of the spectrum..it plsys the highs so well and i can get aeay with true love ways...it just misses a bit of warmth..
Why not get two mouthpieces: a high baffle for the pop and a low baffle for the ballads. Use the tool that’s designed for the job.

I had a Lakshmi metal - I found it great for jazz and ballads, but I like grit. If it’s too bright for you an HR Link clone might suit you better. Or I found an HR Lakshmi more muted than the metal one, maybe something to do with the different embouchure shapes needed for each. An Aizen LS is nice and dark, the Aizen Zero is darker still. Dawkes Music sell these and allow home trials. Then add something like a PPT or wedge-baffled piece for the more raucous stuff.
 
Ok, sorry.
Anyway, my impression is that MPCs seem to change if I put them in the locker for a time 🙂



Sorry, it's a bit OT.
I don't care about "projection", but one definition could be that "it projects more" and "it's more spread" the difference the difference between these two MPCs, an Aaron Drake NY Metal I'm playing until the guitar solo and a Gottsu Doublering after the solo. The Drake is more solid in the middle, more a "constant" beam, like a laser. The Gottsu is more like a watering can, spreading frequencies more across.
The Gottsu wants to be a Florida Link, the Drake a NY link.
But what do I know...

View: https://soundcloud.com/guenne-1/samba-de-orfeu?si=f3f0c4df2b94447e878909e76dbbbfdb&utm_source=clipboard&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=social_sharing

I've recorded this some minutes ago, same settings, Rigotti Wild 3 on both.


If it's too OT, please ignore.
Just on the iMac speakers, not loud, that comes across. Personally I prefer the Gottsu for your playing on this style - do you always play with some air in your sound, a hint of Getz? Or just on this because it's Latin Jazz?

What do they tend to do if you put more air thru them - should you want to - do they still retain the same characteristics?
 
Sound - do you mean using a mouthpiece that gave the same output as you feel matched your input?
I'm not totally sure what you mean. I'd prefer to use a mouthpiece that allows me to easily change the sound I make.

But by sound I mean the sound I get which includes whatever tonal changes I might inflict. To me tone means high/low frequencies etc (what people may refer to as bright or dark or warm). Sound means the tone that I make (whatever mouthpiece) along with any pitch nuances such as vibrato, bending, growl breathiness etc.
 
Last edited:
For clarity its not buying and buying i give a piece at least a month...
A month isn't anywhere near longer enough to get the best out of a piece, yes if you try before you buy you can get mouthpieces that you know in a few mins whether or not a mouthpiece is worth pursuing but it can take a few months to get the best out of new mouthpiece.

With due respect you must of nearly tried most of the mouthpieces available, projection is something you as a player should be working on developing along with lots of other things.
Find one and then commit to it and work on getting the most out of that piece.
 
I'm not totally sure what you mean. I'd prefer to use a mouthpiece that allows me to easily change the sound I make.

But by sound I mean the sound I get which includes whatever tonal changes I might inflict. To me tone means high/low frequencies etc (what people may refer to as bright or dark or warm). Sound means the tone that I make (whatever mouthpiece) along with any pitch nuances such as vibrato, bending, growl breathiness etc.
- because you take care not to interchange the words sound and tone, so I wasn’t quite sure what you were specifically saying
 
Mouthpiece makers rely on the fact that most people don't like that kind of useful advice.
Hmm not really fair...ive had a few pieces but on different saxes. Unlike some i only have 1 tenor and an alto...you cant include the pieces tried to enable me to get on with the raw it's a different beast to the "z"...therefore needs a different piece..ive given each piece on the z long enough to know it isnt quite what im looking for..
 
Just on the iMac speakers, not loud, that comes across. Personally I prefer the Gottsu for your playing on this style - do you always play with some air in your sound, a hint of Getz? Or just on this because it's Latin Jazz?

What do they tend to do if you put more air thru them - should you want to - do they still retain the same characteristics?
I think I'm more or less automatically switching into that mode. On the other hand, if I need a more "dry" sound, I'd play my Yani with a Phil-Tone Intrepid.
Yes, that's one of the advantages of the Gottsu. It doesn't change too much with volume. It's not as loud as the Drake though. I think there's something to the facing curve you don't find on many other new pieces. As I said, it's a 7*, but it's only .98 and it has much more resistance compared to other "Links".
 
you cant include the pieces tried to enable me to get on with the raw it's a different beast to the "z"...therefore needs a different piece..
I was talking about people in general. The conversation has got around to the topic more generally. If you construe it to be about you then I can't help that of course 🙂

But then I'd argue that just because a saxophone is a different brand you "need" a different mouthpiece. It's far better to develop control with your embouchure - but that was my point. Mouthpiece manufacturers are quite happy about people thinking they need different mouthpieces for different brands of instrument instead of working on their tone or sound and being able to do themselves (like we did in the old days).
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,512
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom