Beginner impro Just started playing with a music group.

Listen to the original version of "Let' Stick Together" with Wilbert Harrison (Kansas City, Let's Work Together ...)as well. No sax on Harrison's original version. I've played "Let's Stick Together" (Ferry/Roxy) but I prefer a more "grounded way" to play this R&B song. Tenor + baritone, and harmonica and maybe add a trumpet as well. A 12 bar blues in A. It was not easy for me to play/learn the intro. I had to really nail it. I think it's too "clean and jazzy". Here is my own notes. Maybe you can use it? I was playing tenor so I played in B but alto/bari were in F#.
View attachment 20343

View: https://youtu.be/-NSQI51dppg
Thanks thomsax I shall try yours out,
 
Listen to the original version of "Let' Stick Together" with Wilbert Harrison (Kansas City, Let's Work Together ...)as well. No sax on Harrison's original version. I've played "Let's Stick Together" (Ferry/Roxy) but I prefer a more "grounded way" to play this R&B song. Tenor + baritone, and harmonica and maybe add a trumpet as well. A 12 bar blues in A. It was not easy for me to play/learn the intro. I had to really nail it. I think it's too "clean and jazzy". Here is my own notes. Maybe you can use it? I was playing tenor so I played in B but alto/bari were in F#.
View attachment 20343

View: https://youtu.be/-NSQI51dppg
Despite the omniscience of cats as gods that original had not been brought to my attention before so Canned Heat's was a version of that.
 
...and lets stick together Brian Ferry.
THERE YA GO !!!

Right there.... a 12-bar blues ! Ask them what key. Or if they want Bryan's key.

12-bar blues. Just learn the blues scale for the key it is in....literally write the scale down on a piece of staff paper. You will then have all the 'right notes to play' right in front of you
 
I always try to listen the a original version of a song.
Good to do, but in a situation where a group has specified what version they are going off of, be prepared with the version they specify.

This has happened to me twice in the past two weeks...I have for years wanted to do Karen Souza's version of Creep...finally we are using two singers who LIKE it.
I sent the YT vid of the studio version out to EVERYONE, along with the chart we sussed out of the recording.

First gig, singer #1 pulled up the lyrics on her pad and I immediately saw she was using to original Radiohead lyrics (which the Souza version alters, particularly at the end)...so right there on stage I told everyone we had to trash the entire out-verse, so just play half of the form 😡

Second gig, when we called the tune the drummer (different drummer from previous) reacted with a "the Radiohead tune, right ?" 😳 to which I tried to calmly reply "well, yyyyyyesssssss....butttttt....it's the version I TEXTED to you four days ago, you listened to it, right ?"...to which he replied, he hadn't.
It's a 3 minute YT vid. He was getting paid for this gig....

(As Mandy Patinkin once sang..."not much to ASK for")

So, bandly advice, familiarize yourself with the version specified...😉
 
Good to do, but in a situation where a group has specified what version they are going off of, be prepared with the version they specify.
The person(s) that wrote the lyrics and the music should always be remembered. If think it's easier to sing a song if I understand the meaning of the words. Or to play a sax solo. There is sample of a fine player that is playing the solo of "Lets' Stick Together". To play/cover a bad (stylistic) sax solo better doesn't help so much. No sweat, no soul, no dedication ...... But a good player. Now you shouldn't think that I'm a pro. I just like to know as much as possible about what I'm singing and playing.

I often hear bands play a song (cover) and the miss the minor chord in the song or other characistertics of the song. That's is alright if you do your own version. "Don't play it like Chuck Berry did. Hold the first chord so we built up more tension". That was ok because we/he (the leader of seance) knew what we were doing.

We used to play "Burning Love" (most guys thinks this is a Elvis Presley song) but it's written by Dennis Linde. We did Arthur Alexander version. The first recording of this song that climbed the charts. Recorded in Muscle Shoals, AL and it had horns. It's not produced as a "Vegas" song.

I think to play "Brown Sugar", "Live With Me", "Finger Poppin'" . "Dust My Broom" ..... can be hard at a family event. Today we know better. But behind closed doors ..... . And I'm more or less just playing behind closed doors. Put on the red armless sweater, some Springsteen songs ..... the problem is that my biceps are smaller and belly is bigger these days. But that doesn't bother me so much. Keep on dreamin' ! Just play and have fun.

Arthur Alexader's version of Dennis LIndes's "Burning Love". The punchy Muscle Shoals horns.
View: https://youtu.be/8VTa_9s6wgk


We also wanted to sound like Muscle shoals horns so I had a guy to write a 3-horn arrangment and a lead sheat.

burning love.JPG
 
The person(s) that wrote the lyrics and the music should always be remembered. If think it's easier to sing a song if I understand the meaning of the words. Or to play a sax solo. There is sample of a fine player that is playing the solo of "Lets' Stick Together". To play/cover a bad (stylistic) sax solo better doesn't help so much. No sweat, no soul, no dedication ...... But a good player. Now you shouldn't think that I'm a pro. I just like to know as much as possible about what I'm singing and playing.

I often hear bands play a song (cover) and the miss the minor chord in the song or other characistertics of the song. That's is alright if you do your own version. "Don't play it like Chuck Berry did. Hold the first chord so we built up more tension". That was ok because we/he (the leader of seance) knew what we were doing.

We used to play "Burning Love" (most guys thinks this is a Elvis Presley song) but it's written by Dennis Linde. We did Arthur Alexander version. The first recording of this song that climbed the charts. Recorded in Muscle Shoals, AL and it had horns. It's not produced as a "Vegas" song.

I think to play "Brown Sugar", "Live With Me", "Finger Poppin'" . "Dust My Broom" ..... can be hard at a family event. Today we know better. But behind closed doors ..... . And I'm more or less just playing behind closed doors. Put on the red armless sweater, some Springsteen songs ..... the problem is that my biceps are smaller and belly is bigger these days. But that doesn't bother me so much. Keep on dreamin' ! Just play and have fun.

Arthur Alexader's version of Dennis LIndes's "Burning Love". The punchy Muscle Shoals horns.
View: https://youtu.be/8VTa_9s6wgk


We also wanted to sound like Muscle shoals horns so I had a guy to write a 3-horn arrangment and a lead sheat.

View attachment 20345
I love this version
 
The person(s) that wrote the lyrics and the music should always be remembered. If think it's easier to sing a song if I understand the meaning of the words. Or to play a sax solo. There is sample of a fine player that is playing the solo of "Lets' Stick Together". To play/cover a bad (stylistic) sax solo better doesn't help so much. No sweat, no soul, no dedication ...... But a good player. Now you shouldn't think that I'm a pro. I just like to know as much as possible about what I'm singing and playing.

I often hear bands play a song (cover) and the miss the minor chord in the song or other characistertics of the song. That's is alright if you do your own version. "Don't play it like Chuck Berry did. Hold the first chord so we built up more tension". That was ok because we/he (the leader of seance) knew what we were doing.

We used to play "Burning Love" (most guys thinks this is a Elvis Presley song) but it's written by Dennis Linde. We did Arthur Alexander version. The first recording of this song that climbed the charts. Recorded in Muscle Shoals, AL and it had horns. It's not produced as a "Vegas" song.

I think to play "Brown Sugar", "Live With Me", "Finger Poppin'" . "Dust My Broom" ..... can be hard at a family event. Today we know better. But behind closed doors ..... . And I'm more or less just playing behind closed doors. Put on the red armless sweater, some Springsteen songs ..... the problem is that my biceps are smaller and belly is bigger these days. But that doesn't bother me so much. Keep on dreamin' ! Just play and have fun.

Arthur Alexader's version of Dennis LIndes's "Burning Love". The punchy Muscle Shoals horns.
View: https://youtu.be/8VTa_9s6wgk


We also wanted to sound like Muscle shoals horns so I had a guy to write a 3-horn arrangment and a lead sheat.

View attachment 20345
I understand your point ....yes, I too feel a nod should be given to the original version.
Sometimes (30% of time ?) when I send a version of a tune I like to someone who I want to come in to play the tune, if my version is going by a cover, I will also send the original as well.

But the reality is (at least thru my lens over time) that it's fairly common for a remake of a tune to be better than the original.
So many examples of this I wouldn't know where to start.

I am just saying Terry's jam group specified a particular artist's version/cover of the tune....so in these instances....the musician should go IN to the session familiar with that version.
It seems so obvious, to me....yet over the years, the number of times something along the lines of my Creep story above has happened, with various other bands and various other tunes...is far too many.


Just good practice to do that; again, the band specified the version for a reason, IMHO. That you may prefer a different version than what the leader picked...is a bit beside the point....or maybe something to be discussed after the next session, IMHO.
 
Last edited:
You got me. I was just thinking of Robert Johnson's and his "Dust My Broom" before I posted my "Dust My Broom" and "Dust My Blues". Listen to Robert Johnsson and Willie Dixon and you cover lots of blues songs that were made famous by other artist/bands.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,688
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom