Beginner impro Just started playing with a music group.

Just wanted to clarify that key signature for Am and C maj are the same, hence no confusion on the bandstand.
Yes you are absolutely right, but I would think there can still be confusion on the bandstand if people do think C and Am are the same thing purely because they have same key signature.

If somebody was to say play Aint No Sunshine in C (thinking no sharps or flats) I would immediately assume they mean C minor, because that tune must be in a minor key, as you mentioned above.

So I just want to emphasise to anyone (e.g. a beginner) who might read this. C major and A minor are not the same thing. Very very different. As is C and (for example) D dorian mode.

One confusing thing is when talking generally we might use just the letter on it's own to imply major, but always add the word minor to mean minor. e.g. we might say just C (fopr C major) but usually say C minor for C minor.

HOWEVER:

When it's a specific song you know to be (always) in a minor key you would necessarily have to say the minor as (in the above case of Ain't No Sunshine) that would be assumed as you would never play it in major key normally.

There are confusions with some songs, e.g. Autumn Leaves starts in a major tonality and ends in a minor tonality (the relative minor). It is technically correct to think of the ending( ie the resolution of the song) that defines it but as you can imagine there is still lots of room for confusion in this case.
 
Last edited:
It's not so much being a killer reader, but being there at the right time with the right dynamics and tempo
Yes, that's the meaning with reading music. The easy tenor part I posted is tenor part of song called "Ramrod" by Bruce Springsteen. We played that song for some years and nobody wanted to play the 24 bar tenor solo (goes over 24 bars). I played bari. So we had a tenorist that came and tried. "- That's easy" he said and played the solo as it was written. No volume, no energy, thinn tone (a small jazz piece), no sweat ... some things are not written on the sheet music ...... . I practice that solo for nearly 6 months to get the right approach. Forget the dots ... the saxophone should fill out every inch of the room. ESJohn Good Luck.

Here is "Ramrod" with Springsteen & company. A fun song to play.
View: https://youtu.be/RJVauHVQ-X0


Max Weinberg played this song as well. Now with a horn section. Mindi Abair and Tom Saviano on tenor saxes and, the one and only, Steve Madaio on trumpet. Looks like Abair and Saviano is playing the solo toghether? A baritone makes it bigger.
View: https://youtu.be/p0df2zTviqI
 
Don't some singers sometimes move the key of songs down by a semitone or more as their voices age and they struggle with the top notes ?
Indeed
Could that be an alternative explanation for it being B originally and Bb later on ?
Yes it could. I think it's unlikely in this case that Fats would struggle with the range as it's fairly low I think. He was playing this song in B♭ in the 70s while still relatively young.

I wouldn't rule out that it could have been recorded in B, just that whether it was or not, it ended up in B which is easily explainable by common practice when mastering.

He was not averse to.keys that some may think awkward, e.g. Jambalaya he played in D♭
 
Don't some singers sometimes move the key of songs down by a semitone or more as their voices age and they struggle with the top notes ? Could that be an alternative explanation for it being B originally and Bb later on ?

Rhys
Yes, age can be one reason to lower a song. Darelene Love (Christ, Please ......) sang a song i concert C in the beginning of a tour and in the end of the tour she sang it in Eb. I think the original key Phil Spector recorded it in 1963 was concert E. On Letterman show she used to sing in Eb.
 
Last edited:
Yes, age can be one reason to lower a song. Darelene Love (Christ, Please ......) sang a song i concert C in the beginning of a tour and in the end of the tour she sang it in Eb. I think the original key Phil Spector recorded it in 1963 was concert E. On Letterman show she used to sing in Eb.
it shold be concert E.
 
One of the community orchestra groups I used to play in had its 'intermediate' group made up of quite an eclectic mix which included usual orchestra instruments (flutes, oboe, clarinets, French horn, trumpets, trombone, tuba, strings) plus saxes, guitars, mandolins, accordion... Given there were 5 trumpets, a couple of trombones, a tuba, and the saxes, I am fairly sure no one heard the mandolins
 
Sounds like the music group needs some structure. Sooner or later you must ask yourself some questions.

  1. A plan. "What, How and When" and maybe also "Where". One or two persons that are "project managers"?
  2. Songlist in beforhands. Maybe sheet music as well? The rehearsals are not for us as persons to learn songs. What you are learning on rehearsals is to play together with others. We had had some guys that travelled from Copenhagen over to my place. They spent c 4 hours on train or bus and it cost them c 400 each time. And sometimes we just played two songs because the other guys were not prepared.
  3. Rehearsals or gigs. It's almost the same. Be on time. Have your gear ready. I used to make my sax ready to play after my last practicing/ rehearsal/jam. It's not charming to cure sticky pads, soak squeaky reeds, wash a stinking mouthpiece ..... while the the other guys are waiting.
  4. What to do if just a few guys shows up? Cancell or try to get something out of it?
  5. A conducter or leader. Often there are guys that take a step forward. Use to be the guitar-, bass- or keyplayer. But are they musicically capable to lead the drummer, horns, singers ...?????
  6. Goal(s) with our music. Why are we playing? We used to play on a small street festival, a local kafé and we also organized a Christmas gig/party. Three occasions !!!!!
  7. Reflections. You must often ask yourself if you "hold the plan". If not, what to do?
  8. Money? Who is paying for the rehearsal room, PA, sheet music (hornarrangments, lead/rhythm pages. backline (if the members don't bring their own drums, amps, cables) ....... . And how to get the money? A jar for bills, gigs ...? A leader/conducter often wants money for the work.
At age of 66 I'm not going to do the mistakes I did for 5-15 years ago. Be clear, otherwise I can play on my own with backing tracks.
 
Sounds like the music group needs some structure. Sooner or later you must ask yourself some questions.

  1. A plan. "What, How and When" and maybe also "Where". One or two persons that are "project managers"?
  2. Songlist in beforhands. Maybe sheet music as well? The rehearsals are not for us as persons to learn songs. What you are learning on rehearsals is to play together with others. We had had some guys that travelled from Copenhagen over to my place. They spent c 4 hours on train or bus and it cost them c 400 each time. And sometimes we just played two songs because the other guys were not prepared.
  3. Rehearsals or gigs. It's almost the same. Be on time. Have your gear ready. I used to make my sax ready to play after my last practicing/ rehearsal/jam. It's not charming to cure sticky pads, soak squeaky reeds, wash a stinking mouthpiece ..... while the the other guys are waiting.
  4. What to do if just a few guys shows up? Cancell or try to get something out of it?
  5. A conducter or leader. Often there are guys that take a step forward. Use to be the guitar-, bass- or keyplayer. But are they musicically capable to lead the drummer, horns, singers ...?????
  6. Goal(s) with our music. Why are we playing? We used to play on a small street festival, a local kafé and we also organized a Christmas gig/party. Three occasions !!!!!
  7. Reflections. You must often ask yourself if you "hold the plan". If not, what to do?
  8. Money? Who is paying for the rehearsal room, PA, sheet music (hornarrangments, lead/rhythm pages. backline (if the members don't bring their own drums, amps, cables) ....... . And how to get the money? A jar for bills, gigs ...? A leader/conducter often wants money for the work.
At age of 66 I'm not going to do the mistakes I did for 5-15 years ago. Be clear, otherwise I can play on my own with backing tracks.
Thomsax everything you have mentioned above I think is correct,There is a leader there that organise everything, from songs ,who sings ,he brings in more songs every week.i did go this Thursday and I did join in ,the guitarist I sat by helped me a lot ,told me what to play and we seemed to play together .The organiser asked me am I going to play with them on their next gig in July, im not ready for that it still feels like a shambles ,can you imagine me playing not knowing what to play I would be so embarrassed lol.im not going to put myself in that position,i need to know im comfortable playing something.Well im going to give it a few more weeks and see how it goes .
 
Your first gig will be full of nerves. Most folk mess up to a greater or lesser degree. So don't fret about it.
Rehearsal and practice are fine but you really find out if it's what you want to do, in front of an audience.
Having a deadline focuses the mind, inspires your practice and gives your playing a focus.
There'll be people in the audience who daren't do it.
Dare to do it. What's the worst that can happen? Nobody will die.
The buzz is addictive.
 
Your first gig will be full of nerves. Most folk mess up to a greater or lesser degree. So don't fret about it.
Rehearsal and practice are fine but you really find out if it's what you want to do, in front of an audience.
Having a deadline focuses the mind, inspires your practice and gives your playing a focus.
There'll be people in the audience who daren't do it.
Dare to do it. What's the worst that can happen? Nobody will die.
The buzz is addictive.
Thanks Colin again that's great advice,well its not till July so I've plenty of time to practice just see how I get on.and yes I bet its a great buzz.
 
...i did go this Thursday and I did join in ,the guitarist I sat by helped me a lot ,told me what to play and we seemed to play together .
That's GREAT...that's exactly what needed to happen...SOMEBODY in the jam group feeding you a little useful info on what notes to play over what chords or sections of the songs. That's VERY good. Hopefully you can keep that relationship/dynamic going. I would have figurd that ONE of the chordal players would step up and do that for a horn player.
 
Last edited:
...I'm not ready for that it still feels like a shambles ,can you imagine me playing not knowing what to play I would be so embarrassed lol. I'm not going to put myself in that position,i need to know im comfortable playing something.... going to give it a few more weeks and see how it goes .
Yes, probably a wise choice. No need to 'jump in' for a performance yet, you are just getting your toes wet with playing with others.

If I were you, I'd GO to their next performance to watch it, don't bring your horn - and see how it goes.

IOW, do they have their (if you'll pardon my French) sh-t together ? Does it sound like cohesive music ? Do they have intros and endings down so the songs sound like they start and end cleanly ?
Or is it just cacophony and a bit of chaos....songs muddily beginning...sorta ending with people doing different things, etc ?

If you can write down what the guitarist is suggesting to you for each song, kind of create some 'crib notes' ...maybe on staff paper with notes written, or maybe just instructions to yourself spelled out (I often do both)...then you will begin to be able to 'map' what you wanna play each tune and this will definitely firm up both your confidence and your sound.
 
Last edited:
Yes, probably a wise choice. No need to 'jump in' for a performance yet, you are just getting your toes wet with playing with others.

If I were you, I'd GO to their next performance to watch it, don't bring your horn - and see how it goes.

IOW, do they have their (if you'll pardon my French) sh-t together ? Does it sound like cohesive music ? Do they have intros and endings down so the songs sound like they start and end cleanly ?
Or is it just cacophony and a bit of chaos....songs muddily beginning...sorta ending with people doing different things, etc ?

If you can write down what the guitarist is suggesting to you for each song, kind of create some 'crib notes' ...maybe on staff paper with notes written, or maybe just instructions to yourself spelled out (I often do both)...then you will begin to be able to 'map' what you wanna play each tune and this will definitely firm up both your confidence and your sound.
Was thinking exactly that jaye,i need a note pad and write all the songs ,notes ,down for each song the guitar player is helping me with because im going to forget ,
 
After we/the group decided what to play we also decided how to play it (form). And when that was done we individually lernaed the song/parts.

I use an empty note paper and just write down your parts and learn/remember what you wrote. It can be dots, letters, numbers, symbols ...... just for your own part, But it's important that you understand what your are writing.

Next rehaersal you should learn to play the song together with your band mates.

Here is a sample. An easy R&B or R&R song called "The Wanderer." (a song we did close to the orginal by Dion). So easy that I didn't write so much on the paper. It ws just outro we changed a bit. An opera singer used to sing with us and he wondered why we were playing B'-side songs. 😉 So we decided to play more known songs.
tw.JPG
 
After we/the group decided what to play we also decided how to play it (form). And when that was done we individually lernaed the song/parts.

I use an empty note paper and just write down your parts and learn/remember what you wrote. It can be dots, letters, numbers, symbols ...... just for your own part, But it's important that you understand what your are writing.

Next rehaersal you should learn to play the song together with your band mates.

Here is a sample. An easy R&B or R&R song called "The Wanderer." (a song we did close to the orginal by Dion). So easy that I didn't write so much on the paper. It ws just outro we changed a bit. An opera singer used to sing with us and he wondered why we were playing B'-side songs. 😉 So we decided to play more known songs.
View attachment 20288
Thats exactly what I need to do ,need to be organised write down what I need to be playing so I don't forget for the next time ,which I am doing now ,every time I go I seem to be starting all over again trying to remember what I played the last time . Notebook and pen coming with me next week .
Thanks Thomsax.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,688
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom