Yes you are absolutely right, but I would think there can still be confusion on the bandstand if people do think C and Am are the same thing purely because they have same key signature.Just wanted to clarify that key signature for Am and C maj are the same, hence no confusion on the bandstand.
If somebody was to say play Aint No Sunshine in C (thinking no sharps or flats) I would immediately assume they mean C minor, because that tune must be in a minor key, as you mentioned above.
So I just want to emphasise to anyone (e.g. a beginner) who might read this. C major and A minor are not the same thing. Very very different. As is C and (for example) D dorian mode.
One confusing thing is when talking generally we might use just the letter on it's own to imply major, but always add the word minor to mean minor. e.g. we might say just C (fopr C major) but usually say C minor for C minor.
HOWEVER:
When it's a specific song you know to be (always) in a minor key you would necessarily have to say the minor as (in the above case of Ain't No Sunshine) that would be assumed as you would never play it in major key normally.
There are confusions with some songs, e.g. Autumn Leaves starts in a major tonality and ends in a minor tonality (the relative minor). It is technically correct to think of the ending( ie the resolution of the song) that defines it but as you can imagine there is still lots of room for confusion in this case.
Last edited:
