Beginner impro Just started playing with a music group.

Ok my update on Thursdays get together,Well there was only the mandolin players there ,no guitars, no bass, no keyboard just 4 mandolins and me .I was rubbish, well I think I was. I did listen to all your advice but I couldn't seem to play along with them most of the time ,it was so hard to join in ,I had to play so quiet.
We all did a piece towards the end of the night on our own, they seemed to like my playing of (All my loving ,and Stranger on the shore ,) and was nagged to play Baker Street ,so they have added that to their play list to practice
Today was contacted by the harmonica player he wants to play something with me, wants to play Aint no sunshine, well I've agreed so I sent him my recording ,not a professional one just a phone recording and he liked it .see how things go from here then .I am enjoying my journey.
 
Oh, yes. But we talk the guys into that's a minor blues. I think the knowledge and standard when it comes to "the blues" is higher USA than in Sweden. C maj start on C (root)... E (3rd) .... G (5th). Am starts on A (root), .... C ( liten ters) and E if we talk thirds. But what do I know! I can be complete wrong. I just know that "Ain't No ...." is sad and glommy. Not so gloomy as "Glommy Sunday", a must for every big band saxophonist. Charie Barnet version.

View: https://youtu.be/Tt-kIrhlvik
 
Oh, yes. But we talk the guys into that's a minor blues. I think the knowledge and standard when it comes to "the blues" is higher USA than in Sweden. C maj start on C (root)... E (3rd) .... G (5th). Am starts on A (root), .... C ( liten ters) and E if we talk thirds. But what do I know! I can be complete wrong.
Just wanted to clarify that key signature for Am and C maj are the same, hence no confusion on the bandstand. If you actually meant that some play the tune in C maj, that simply isn't true. Nobody would ever play that tune in major as that would change the melody and harmony such that it would probably be unrecognizable. So I don't know what you were trying to say there. Not sure what the other tune has to do with anything either?

In any case, I didn't mean to get too bogged down in semantics. I thought we were all on the same page until I read your reply. It simply isn't correct to say this or that minor tune is played in X major. Minor tunes are always played in minor. You can of course specify either the minor or relative major key signature, but nothing else about the tune is a major tonality.

EDIT: Here's the first page of the Real Book lead sheet. Not a blues per se, but definitely Am (key signature C maj). Can you post any versions you've heard in C major?
1652040606685.png
 
Last edited:
If you actually meant that some play the tune in C maj, that simply isn't true.
Sorry for my swenglish. We didn't play ANS in C major. We had a bluesmeeting and a guy suggested that we should play ANS. Some guys didn't knew the song and were told to play it in "C same as Am". Of course this didn't work. It's a minor blues. None of us was reading ANS. After some discuss we played it in minor.
Not a blues per se
If you sing and read the lyrics I think ANS is a bluesy song. And so is J.J. Cale's "Bring It Back". I think the blues icon Willie Dixon's up-tempo song "Bring It On Home" is less blues. But I like them all.
Not sure what the other tune has to do with anything either?
Just to show that we have "blues" songs all over the world. But we don't call them blues. Even in Sweden we have some kind of old "blues" songs. They are called "skillingtryck". Most of them were minor (moll) songs but over the years the became a little bit more cheerful.
 
I like "Baker Street" because it made the saxophone more popular. It's funny that some songs are not popular among saxophonists. I talked about that with some professional Blues, R&B, Pop, Rock, Soul .... players that use to play song like Baker Street, Mustang Sally .... songs that we learned are terrible. "Baker Street" is not easy if you're going to play it in style of Gerry Rafferty (Ralph Ravenscroft, alto saxophone). I think the original key is D. "Lots of volume and fill out every inch of the room"sax solo.
 
I like "Baker Street" because it made the saxophone more popular. It's funny that some songs are not popular among saxophonists. I talked about that with some professional Blues, R&B, Pop, Rock, Soul .... players that use to play song like Baker Street, Mustang Sally .... songs that we learned are terrible. "Baker Street" is not easy if you're going to play it in style of Gerry Rafferty (Ralph Ravenscroft, alto saxophone). I think the original key is D. "Lots of volume and fill out every inch of the room"sax solo.
I do like Baker Street and I will play it because everybody loves it,And I can blast it out because im in the back room of a pub, Im doing my own thing instead of trying to figure out how to join in with them ,
 
Yes, do your own version. I like to add horns/sax to music that don't have horns. I like Mustang Sally but I/we tried to do another version of this song. We had no keys in the band back then (drm, bass, 2 x gtr, trp, ts, bs) so added horns to a version wo horns. You don't need a backing tracks you can play over a record as well. Here is just the tenorsax played over a recording.

View: https://youtu.be/09xb8vwgxYk
 
You don't have to be a killer reader to read and play music like this.
Stars and Stripes measures.png


This is a portion of my current challenge playing with a band complete with strings, brass, woodwinds and percussion. It's not so much being a killer reader, but being there at the right time with the right dynamics and tempo (notice my notes above measure 42 and the p-f at 46) while playing in cut time. The notes are certainly easy enough and the repetition of phrases helps quite a bit. We're practicing Stars and Stripes Forever for a (US) Memorial Day concert. Wish me luck! And best wishes to you, Terry!
 
Well the original record ended up in B after mastering, that doesn’t mean it was played in B.
This seemed to be a trick the used to do. The recorded it in probably Bb, and did some voodoo with the recording tape before they sent it away to a big company (Imperial, Speciality?) This was to make it harder to copy the recording. Otherwise Pat Boone would had a mega hit with the song before Fats. "Blueberry Hill" became a multimillion-selling hit. So they probably recorded it (at Cosimo Matassas J&M Recording Studios, 838-840 North Rampard Street, New Oeleans) in Bb. Beeing woodshed honker and a sax player, that don't have to fit in or please anybody, concert B is more interesting and challenging. A better story as well that helps to keep up the interest for Rock & Roll Saxophone. They could play in all keys ....... C or C#/Db, G or G#/Ab? We can all choose .... . That's also great!😉
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,078
Messages
578,691
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom