Beginner impro Just started playing with a music group.

I would love to be able to do that Colin ,There is only maybe a few songs I know that I don't have to read and that's" And I love her" also Fever, and maybe a few others.
Your repertoire will grow. Playing along with recordings will help.
I've played with UB40, Duke Ellington Gerry Mulligan...records. 😉
 
Yes, I think lots of us have learned to play this way. For me it was the horns in a song or maybe a sax solo, that caught my attention. To play the melody or singing lines was not my thing. I tried to sing it instead of playing the singing lines on saxophone. But I'm limited to Blues and Rock&Roll.
 
You don't have to be a killer reader to read and play music like this.
View attachment 20173
This is the tenor part of a 3-horn arrangement. Med tempo rock song. And after I had read and played that song 10-15 times even I remember the song. We just played easy stuff. The challenge was to get the right sound. We were into rock and not Glenn Miller. And what to do about the famous tenor solo? Play it as XX played it, but that impossible. Or play a horn soli.

We just played easy stuff, because we weren't skilled enough. We are all differnt.
This is typical of what I play and would find difficult to memorize along with everything else in the show.
1651584811073.webp
 
I get nervous just seeing it. Yes, it's hard memorize stuff like this.
I'm not a great sight reader either, so even after a couple of hours practice, there are still parts I need to work out. Can't quite get my pinky in sync at full tempo on the line at F9, so that needs more woodshedding. Luckily, nobody in any of the big bands I've been in has ever had to memorize this stuff. I suppose if I were a pro playing the same show 5 nights a week for months on end, then it would eventually sink in. But I'm just an amateur weekend warrior trying to juggle a full time job and a half dozen bands. There's only so much my old brain can hold and only so much time I can spend practicing. I've got gigs every weekend all spring and summer long, sometimes 3 gigs in one day. Memorizing all of that would take an incredible amount of time and effort and of course would be impossible on gigs where I'm sight reading.
 
I can only sight read if I know how it goes.
Even knowing how it goes, it was tough for me to sight read something like the example above. I got most of the rhythms, but missed a lot of the notes. I wish I could play it perfectly after hearing it once, but I'll probably never get to that level. How did you get to the point where you could sight read perfectly after one hearing?
 
Sight-reading improves the more you do it... My sight-reading is reasonable. I aim to be in the right place even if there are inaccuracies with notes.

In one of my orchestras we're playing a medley from Gershwin's "Lady be Good" - there is no way you'd play that from memory. It's complex, changes key, changes tempo, changes time signature... some parts are swung, others straight quavers... (8s)
 
Sight-reading improves the more you do it... My sight-reading is reasonable. I aim to be in the right place even if there are inaccuracies with notes.

In one of my orchestras we're playing a medley from Gershwin's "Lady be Good" - there is no way you'd play that from memory. It's complex, changes key, changes tempo, changes time signature... some parts are swung, others straight quavers... (8s)
Problem is my sight reading skills plateaued in the early 80s when I was still in college. After 40 years of trying, I still can't nail something like the example I posted on the first read, much less play it from memory.
 
I can only sight read if I know how it goes.
You didn't understand my response, so I'll try to explain. You can sight read if you know how it goes. So if you hear it, then you can sight read it, which I still can't do in the example I posted. Even listening to it several times, it takes a lot of practice to finally play it correctly. So I'm jealous of your ability to sight read something as complex as what I posted upon hearing the part.
 
I would find this 32 bar section absolutely impossible to play! Way beyond my technical skills! But the more I understand the 'structure', the slightly less intimidating it becomes. Thankfully, I only need to play the occasional 4, 8 or 16 bars of this kind of stuff. And there's no way I could sight-read and play it! So (as for most Big Band pieces I play), for this kind of stuff I have to rely on 'muscle memory' developed in practice/rehearsals. The sheet music then just serves a 'reminder' of what I need to play (from muscle memory).

I soon gave up on trying to play written-out sax solos (that often included convoluted sequences of16ths). Mainly because I found them too difficult to play (comfortably). But also because - even if I could play them - they just weren't my personal style. Rather than struggle to learn how to play a written-out solo (with which I had no personal affinity), I found it much easier and more satisfying to create (and improvise) my solo's through which I could express myself more (and were much easier to play 🙂 ). @Veggie Dave made a very valid comment in a different thread that I might just be too lazy in expanding my 'boundaries' by playing 'comfortable' solo's rather than the written-out solos. I agree with him on this.



This is typical of what I play and would find difficult to memorize along with everything else in the show.
View attachment 20174
 
I would find this 32 bar section absolutely impossible to play! Way beyond my technical skills! But the more I understand the 'structure', the slightly less intimidating it becomes. Thankfully, I only need to play the occasional 4, 8 or 16 bars of this kind of stuff. And there's no way I could sight-read and play it! So (as for most Big Band pieces I play), for this kind of stuff I have to rely on 'muscle memory' developed in practice/rehearsals. The sheet music then just serves a 'reminder' of what I need to play (from muscle memory).

I soon gave up on trying to play written-out sax solos (that often included convoluted sequences of16ths). Mainly because I found them too difficult to play (comfortably). But also because - even if I could play them - they just weren't my personal style. Rather than struggle to learn how to play a written-out solo (with which I had no personal affinity), I found it much easier and more satisfying to create (and improvise) my solo's through which I could express myself more (and were much easier to play 🙂 ). @Veggie Dave made a very valid comment in a different thread that I might just be too lazy in expanding my 'boundaries' by playing 'comfortable' solo's rather than the written-out solos. I agree with him on this.
Mike was wondering if you playing a solo you've created yourself, then you were asked to play it again would it be a different solo created or would you remember what you played the last one? I've often wondered.
 
I think there's good advice here, and lots of it. I like the notion that...given you (Terry) have limited knowledge of improvisation, trying to concoct something by ear with some very basic structure/m.o. is probably your best bet.

Paring it down, at least by my interpretation:

1) Get the chord changes from either: a) the guitarist or pianist. Again....THEY ARE playing chords....they could write them out on a napkin for you certainly, if not email them to you.
or b) go online and find the chord changes on a chord tabs site

2) transpose the concert key the band is playing in into your Alto key.

3) using the chord changes you now have in front of you (btw bring the chord 'charts' of each song with you to the jams)...noodle around and figure out 2 or 3 notes which fit those chords of each bar or 2 bars or 4 bars of the song. Use those notes when you play.

4) learn the melodies of each song. write the melody out of it helps you. Practice them a bit , then start noodling around with the melodies (IOW, play some of the melody as written, then here or there stray from it and change either the phrasing or the notes or both (if changing notes try to pick notes which fit the chords, as described above).


In your position, given your current musical-knowledge toolbox, this is what I would do....

At least you will be playing more or less along with a chord progression, you will 'know' a few notes which fit each chord, and you will 'know' more or less the song's melody.
That is enough preparation/knowledge to 'sound ok' on each tune, without overloading yourself with 'omigod, I gotta learn this and this and this and this !"

It will also begin to develop

1) your ear (as to what notes sound 'right' or 'wrong' in each section of the song),

2) your understanding as to how songs are basically structured (IOW is this a 12-bar blues or is it 32-bar AABA form ?, etc),

3) your phrasing (does a long note sound better here or quarter notes ? Should I play here or lay out here ?).
 
I think there's good advice here, and lots of it. I like the notion that...given you (Terry) have limited knowledge of improvisation, trying to concoct something by ear with some very basic structure/m.o. is probably your best bet.

Paring it down, at least by my interpretation:

1) Get the chord changes from either: a) the guitarist or pianist. Again....THEY ARE playing chords....they could write them out on a napkin for you certainly, if not email them to you.
or b) go online and find the chord changes on a chord tabs site

2) transpose the concert key the band is playing in into your Alto key.

3) using the chord changes you now have in front of you (btw bring the chord 'charts' of each song with you to the jams)...noodle around and figure out 2 or 3 notes which fit those chords of each bar or 2 bars or 4 bars of the song. Use those notes when you play.

4) learn the melodies of each song. write the melody out of it helps you. Practice them a bit , then start noodling around with the melodies (IOW, play some of the melody as written, then here or there stray from it and change either the phrasing or the notes or both (if changing notes try to pick notes which fit the chords, as described above).


In your position, given your current musical-knowledge toolbox, this is what I would do....

At least you will be playing more or less along with a chord progression, you will 'know' a few notes which fit each chord, and you will 'know' more or less the song's melody.
That is enough preparation/knowledge to 'sound ok' on each tune, without overloading yourself with 'omigod, I gotta learn this and this and this and this !"

It will also begin to develop

1) your ear (as to what notes sound 'right' or 'wrong' in each section of the song),

2) your understanding as to how songs are basically structured (IOW is this a 12-bar blues or is it 32-bar AABA form ?, etc),

3) your phrasing (does a long note sound better here or quarter notes ? Should I play here or lay out here ?).
Thanks Jaye, Now with all this help im going to jump right in on Thursday and give it a good go, might even record it just to see my mistakes .or I might sound fantastic lol ummm don't think so .
 
I never said lazy. 😉
In my experience, unless the written solos are transcriptions of the originals (they usually aren’t), they’re not worth playing or learning. One of the few written solos I always play ver batim is “In The Mood”. Another is “Cotton Tail”, if I recall correctly.

But back to the topic, @Terry, have a great time at practice and just go with the flow and follow @JayeNM’s excellent advice.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,078
Messages
578,690
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom