John O'Neill's Jazz Method Book (Tenor)

The reason I ask, is that I thought of riping the tracks and then changing the pitch in audacity.
That way I'll be able to play along with the tenor.

I am not quite shure of the ethics of such an action.
I don't know, I might go and get the tenor book as well.

Anybody tried the second book? If it's as good as the first one it is worth buying.
 
The second book isn't as 'prescriptive' as the first, more focussed on gettin you to be expressive and improvise more. Includes advanced scales (modes, whole tone, diminished etc), special effects (false fingerings, growling etc) plus minor/major 2-5s and studies on the blues and rhythm changes.

Grade wise this'd put it at around Grade 5+ (UK).

So if you're new to the more 'theoretical' side of improvising and want to cover alot of ground fast, this is a great book.

Dislikes: it's written in 3 languages, so you have to 'jump around' a bit between pages. Luckily the dots are still in dot form.

Simon
 
I think 'prescriptive' is exactly the right word, Simon. Much as I love the O'Neill book, he does have that didactic, prescriptive tone, especially early on in the book, which I find a bit irksome.

In that respect I much prefer Pete's laid back "if it works for you, fine" approach on his DVD.

Peter
 
Well after some negotiation with my tutor I've finally moved on to 'country Roads' (a bit dull) and the wonderful 'Euphrates' of which there is mention in this forum. The whole subject of modes is fascinating and in this tune you can really start to feel them modes working !


Mark Whiteley wrote:
Hi Everyone

I Can't see a John O'neill Topic anywhere on the site, so though it might be useful to start one.

Everyone who's used this book will probably agree that it is excellent. Of course it has some oddities but generally speaking it is a wonderful resource.

Of course towards the middle of this book for beginners it starts to get a lot more difficult. Tunes are a lot faster too. By pages 54 & 55 ( 3 of my 'Archilles Heel' tunes 'Lucky Rhythm', 'Summer Hummer' and ' Lady Pres' things are moving at between 126 and 144.

I have previously been stuck for weeks, or was it months! on page 42 with 'The Way Of All Things'. I still can't do it to speed properly yet. All of these tunes are great for testing your ability to produce consistently strong and tuneful notes above the 'C' bridge.

I would be interested to hear how others are getting on with this book, which tunes you've found the most challenging/easy, any tips, any thoughts on the frustration side of getting to grips with this book etc!

Thanks

Mark W
 
Well this topic's had 430 hits so it seems everyone is quite interested in the O'neill book/s.

Having almost climbed over the Lady Pres mountain I'm on to Euphrates and that nice Tango that follows it, what a relief from the previous pages ! My tutor says that the way that Euphrates is set out in the book, including the omission of chords above the bars as a guide to improv, is disgraceful, but I'm just happy that it's a great tune and not too fast !!
 
I think your teacher is being a little harsh there, Mark. O'Neill does supply the modes to deploy and explore during the improvisation sections of Euphrates, and as modal improvisation is the main point of the piece, that seems fair enough to me.

Of course, the chord progressions for all the tunes are given in an appendix at the end of the books.

The bits that I find tricky in that tune are where part of the melody rises by a semi-tone when it's repeated (I've not described that very well but I think you'll know what I mean). There's some quite awkward fingering during those sections :cry:

Peter
 
Hi - I'm currently revisiting O'Neill's "Sister Caroline" having been a bad boy skipping ahead to what seem much easier and slower songs.

Is it just me or in the second line, last bar, first instrument should the second D be natural, not flat as written? It sounds better to me that way. I've tried to answer this by listening to the demo recording but don't trust my ears yet. Anyone with good ears out there who can answer this?

Dave
 
ch'boogie and I have just bought this book to have a go with and its quite a bit different to what we are used to playing 😛

I think if I go to band next term and ask if if our quavers are swing quavers I'll be stood against a wall and shot >.< :laugh: they wont like swing quavers.

Only criticism so far is the lack of a "count in" at the start of the cd tracks bit of a silence then its off and I keep missing the start.

Col.
 
Hi Col9

There is a count in on my CD (alto version) for all of the tracks. Make sure you haven't got ballance set all the way to the right (the count in and rhythm instruments are on the LEFT - only the saxophone demo on the RIGHT).

Hope this sorts out the problem - otherwise you have a different version of the CD.

Dave
 
Hi Dave

I've had some trouble with Sister caroline myself, and have tended to skip it without getting up to speed. Havn't noticed any written note faults though - I'll try it out again and get back to you.

shropshire_lad wrote:
Hi - I'm currently revisiting O'Neill's "Sister Caroline" having been a bad boy skipping ahead to what seem much easier and slower songs.

Is it just me or in the second line, last bar, first instrument should the second D be natural, not flat as written? It sounds better to me that way. I've tried to answer this by listening to the demo recording but don't trust my ears yet. Anyone with good ears out there who can answer this?

Dave
 
shropshire_lad wrote:
Hi Col9

There is a count in on my CD (alto version) for all of the tracks. Make sure you haven't got ballance set all the way to the right (the count in and rhythm instruments are on the LEFT - only the saxophone demo on the RIGHT).

Hope this sorts out the problem - otherwise you have a different version of the CD.

Dave

Well it turns out the speaker plug had come out a bit and I had sax demo in both speakers. Much better now no complaints other than it has hard to play bits :cry: After you mentioned balance I was sure I had read that somewhere either on here on in the book :whistle:

thanks for the tip
Col.
 
Hi all you O'Neill fans
Seems quite a following for this excellent tutor book. Glad to see I'm not the only one struggling with some of the tunes, especially from p.42.
Bit of nimble fingering required for the triplets introduced on p.45.
Quite an easy tune to start with "Alicante" though. This is the time when you find out just how good your sax is!
Metronome definitely good to have here, as you can start out nice and slowly then bring up to the right speed in your own time.
I enjoyed playing 'Tongue Twister' nice to have a bit of rock and roll in there, you can really let it rip. Even tried a bit of growl on that one!
Just started on 'Exercise in Rhythm'. Tripping up on the triplet in bar 10. Can manage at about 80 - 90 bpm, but have to untie my knotted fingers at the end!
Can't match the skill of the musicians on the backing track though, why can't they use less experienced saxophonists, it makes you feel a bit inadequate. I guess you just have to do the best you can, at your stage of learning, then maybe in a few years try again and you will wonder what all the fuss was about??
Sometimes I find myself playing these tunes in my own way, adding an extra note or two, and even changing some because I think they sound better! Maybe a bit presumptious on my part, but isn't that what jazz is all about?
Anyway, plodding on. Keep going back to p.39 "Playing by ear", and still can't manage it! Get a couple of bars sounding a bit like the tune in my head, then it goes off into another key, and I lose the tune altogether, it's not as easy as whistling is it?
:whistle:
 
Hi Pete



Tongue Twister and Exercise in Thythm still give me problems, especially at speed. I think the thing to do is not get too hung up on them. I give them a break for a week or two then go back, but I make sure that I do go back and try to improve them. It helps with having a tutor who won't let me get away with skipping tunes and keeps pushing me, although in another topic I was questionning the value of personal tutors (after the initial absolute beginner stage) it is this pushing you through barriers that really makes the difference with a tutor, so I've changed my mind to some extent.

Have you tried 'The Way Of All Things' yet? This was my nemesis for ages and is still tricky. !!

Nil Desperandum !


PeeDee wrote:
Hi all you O'Neill fans
Seems quite a following for this excellent tutor book. Glad to see I'm not the only one struggling with some of the tunes, especially from p.42.
Bit of nimble fingering required for the triplets introduced on p.45.
Quite an easy tune to start with "Alicante" though. This is the time when you find out just how good your sax is!
Metronome definitely good to have here, as you can start out nice and slowly then bring up to the right speed in your own time.
I enjoyed playing 'Tongue Twister' nice to have a bit of rock and roll in there, you can really let it rip. Even tried a bit of growl on that one!
Just started on 'Exercise in Rhythm'. Tripping up on the triplet in bar 10. Can manage at about 80 - 90 bpm, but have to untie my knotted fingers at the end!
Can't match the skill of the musicians on the backing track though, why can't they use less experienced saxophonists, it makes you feel a bit inadequate. I guess you just have to do the best you can, at your stage of learning, then maybe in a few years try again and you will wonder what all the fuss was about??
Sometimes I find myself playing these tunes in my own way, adding an extra note or two, and even changing some because I think they sound better! Maybe a bit presumptious on my part, but isn't that what jazz is all about?
Anyway, plodding on. Keep going back to p.39 "Playing by ear", and still can't manage it! Get a couple of bars sounding a bit like the tune in my head, then it goes off into another key, and I lose the tune altogether, it's not as easy as whistling is it?
:whistle:
[/quote]
 
PeeDee wrote:
... I guess you just have to do the best you can, at your stage of learning, then maybe in a few years try again and you will wonder what all the fuss was about??
Sometimes I find myself playing these tunes in my own way, adding an extra note or two, and even changing some because I think they sound better! Maybe a bit presumptious on my part, but isn't that what jazz is all about?

Absolutely, that's exactly what most of us are aiming at. It sounds like you're feeling your way down that track already.

All I can say is go for it, embellish around the basic melody and you're on your way.

good luck, Phil
 
Mark Whiteley wrote:
Hi Pete



Tongue Twister and Exercise in Thythm still give me problems, especially at speed. I think the thing to do is not get too hung up on them. I give them a break for a week or two then go back, but I make sure that I do go back and try to improve them. It helps with having a tutor who won't let me get away with skipping tunes and keeps pushing me, although in another topic I was questionning the value of personal tutors (after the initial absolute beginner stage) it is this pushing you through barriers that really makes the difference with a tutor, so I've changed my mind to some extent.

Have you tried 'The Way Of All Things' yet? This was my nemesis for ages and is still tricky. !!

Nil Desperandum !

Hi Mark
Yes, I found "The Way....." a little tricky, but moved on as I could be stuck on that page forever, as has been said they do get harder rather quickly, but I think iv'e done the best i can for now, and am now battling with 'Exercise in Rhythm'.
Yes I tend to do the same thing, when I get fed up with a tune and can't quite master it, I move on to the next one. I think 'well, I've done me best, maybe if I come back later, I will have improved a bit, and find it easier'.
On the subject of teachers, I have just finished with one. A lady, young, maybe late 20's, and felt she wasn't teaching me anything I didn't know! She was very good at pointing out mistakes I made, ie playing F when it should have been F#, which I was well aware of anyway! Also, she insisted that ligatures always should have the screw on the reed side. My metal ligature has two small raised lines on the side opposite to the screws, which I assume is to grip the reed, and it does play better when gripping the reed that way. I did a little research on internet and found there are 'opposed ligs'. So much for her! Anyway starting with another young lady whom I am assured is very good, we shall see. As you say, I think a teachers job is to set you targets, and point out your weak points, where you're going wrong, and give you exercises etc to iron these problems out. Anyway, will see how it goes!
Ok, good luck with it, and enjoy the weather, yuk! Or maybe it's better in your neck of the woods.
Pete

🙁
 
PeeDee wrote:
Metronome definitely good to have here, as you can start out nice and slowly then bring up to the right speed in your own time.

Can't match the skill of the musicians on the backing track though, why can't they use less experienced saxophonists, it makes you feel a bit inadequate. I guess you just have to do the best you can, at your stage of learning...

I agree a metronome is invaluable for practising at a slower speed - there is also some free software (Audacity being one example) that can reduce the tempo of mp3 files.

Regards having skilled players on the demo - I agree it is quite dispiriting to compare their playing to us beginners but think it is useful to have their example and try and emulate. I've definitely improved my phrasing by copying these demo's.

Dave
 
Phil Edwards wrote:
PeeDee wrote:
... I guess you just have to do the best you can, at your stage of learning, then maybe in a few years try again and you will wonder what all the fuss was about??
Sometimes I find myself playing these tunes in my own way, adding an extra note or two, and even changing some because I think they sound better! Maybe a bit presumptious on my part, but isn't that what jazz is all about?

Absolutely, that's exactly what most of us are aiming at. It sounds like you're feeling your way down that track already.

All I can say is go for it, embellish around the basic melody and you're on your way.

good luck, Phil

Cheers Phil, for the boost of confidence, I must be doing something right! Tell the wife will you?
🙂
Pete
 
shropshire_lad wrote:

I agree a metronome is invaluable for practising at a slower speed - there is also some free software (Audacity being one example) that can reduce the tempo of mp3 files.

Regards having skilled players on the demo - I agree it is quite dispiriting to compare their playing to us beginners but think it is useful to have their example and try and emulate. I've definitely improved my phrasing by copying these demo's.

Dave

Hi Dave
I have downloaded Audacity, all I have to do is figure out how to work it. Do you just play the CD on the computer, and it comes up on the programme?
Yes, I guess you're right about the players on the CD, it is good to
try and emulate them, and I do notice they don't play the tune exactly as written occasionaly, I guess that's phrasing.
Plodding on, as they say in Darset.
Pete
 
PeeDee wrote:

... have downloaded Audacity, all I have to do is figure out how to work it.

the software does much more but if you just want to clow down music then:
(1) in the FILE menu and find the piece of music you want
(2) go to the EDIT menu and SELECT than ALL
(3) go to EFFECT menu and choose CHANGE TEMPO (do not use change speed as this changes the pitch too).
(4) use the slider to reduce or increase the tempo, the percentage change is shown in the box above the slider (-30%) is usually enough
(5) you can the go back to FILE menu and save it as a wav file (if you download an add=on from the software's web site you can also save as an mp3 file).

good luck
 
shropshire_lad wrote:
PeeDee wrote:

... have downloaded Audacity, all I have to do is figure out how to work it.

the software does much more but if you just want to clow down music then:
(1) in the FILE menu and find the piece of music you want
(2) go to the EDIT menu and SELECT than ALL
(3) go to EFFECT menu and choose CHANGE TEMPO (do not use change speed as this changes the pitch too).
(4) use the slider to reduce or increase the tempo, the percentage change is shown in the box above the slider (-30%) is usually enough
(5) you can the go back to FILE menu and save it as a wav file (if you download an add=on from the software's web site you can also save as an mp3 file).

good luck
Cheers Dave
will give it a go.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,505
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom