every time I read criticism about the saxholder slipping off someone's shoulders or, as in this case, a report that a saxophone found a way to dislodge itself off the hook of the sax and fall........ I read it with eyes widening with surprise.
I thought I had bought a standard Saxholder while I clearly must have given a different product from the one that is described by others ! I am sure mine is NOT the XL version or any different form the average saxholder.
I am 183 cm tall and weigh 120Kg. I am , by all means large and in a far away past a rugby players (some would say that now I am only a fat old man but, hey, I have heavy bones 🙂 ) and so large that these days most XXL garments in many shops won’t always accommodate my figure. Anyway, that’s my problem.
I’ve bought this thing following a series of shoulders/neck problems (it is not yet clear what I have exactly after one year of intense sufferings), it has been my trusted and faithful companion ever since.
I use it with : Curved soprano saxophone (the only strap that doesn’t choke me in doing that) , alto, tenor and I have used it on occasion with a baritone or two. On bass clarinet I prefer a neotech harness. I relish the feeling of using this instead of any strap (and I have a few)
I can use it sitting down and standing up and a combination of the two. I have played a one hour gig last Sunday ( standing up with a change of saxophone from tenor to alto and vice versa). I wore it during that gig under a corduroy jacket, you can conceal it even better if you wear it under a shirt and you just let the cord and hook dangle out of your shirt.
I normally play it on sweaters, shirts, T-shirts, never had a problem with the saxholder messing up any of these.
I have, on occasion, left any of my saxophones hanging freely while bending , carefully, down, nothing happened or gave me the feeling that it could have happened.
If playing with the horn on the side, the abdomen support does tend to go the other direction but I don’t play like that very often because I dislike doing so.
I use the widest setting (you know you can adjust it right?) of the central adjusting screw and I have taken time to bend (by hand no need for tools) the shoulder supports a couple of times.
I play in a community band, I was the first person to buy the Saxholder there (I bought it , nobody gave it to me for free, paid 50€ ) now over 50% of the saxophone players use it we are all above the age of 50 and can use some pain relieve.
By the way, if I have one criticism is that al of my saxophones don’t get easily in or out the saxholder hook ..........let alone slipping out!
But again, sometimes I have the feeling that people are talking of a different item when I read some reports!