Playing the saxophone Jambalaya - versions and keys

The answer is it doesn't.
To play in concert G on tenor we play in A.

It just so happens that a set of dots originally ascribed for a backing track in concert C for alto happen to be written in A.
The happy coincidence is, that if these dots in A are played on tenor they will sound in concert G.

The dots are specified for a particular saxophone to match up with the backing track. You can play them on a chinese nose flute if so desired, but they won't match up with the backing track.
Simples huh...thanks @Colin the Bear basic transposition...don't know why things got out of context... answered in post 3...apilogies to anyone who has a headache...
 
I'm confused now. The question about Bb to Eb is transposing in general, not Jambalaya. Hence better in a thread about transposing in general.

The forum is most useful for people when they find thing under relvant titles 🙂

Staying relevant would certainly shorten most threads.

Regarding jambalaya: Is andouille available in Great Britain?
 
Hi does anyone know what key the original was in. I bought a copy transposed it but it didn't sound right against the carpenters version. Google is giving d major or G major music notes c major another site G major...
You can't be sure. Yes, it's recorded in (concert) C but maybe Hank played it in other keys before he recorded? When I started to learn songs by ear/heart I listened, listened ... and listened again. I didn't think about differnt keys. And I liked rock and blues songs so I often learned songs in A or E without knowing the the keys. I just wanted to play what I heard.
 
You can't be sure. Yes, it's recorded in (concert) C but maybe Hank played it in other keys before he recorded? When I started to learn songs by ear/heart I listened, listened ... and listened again. I didn't think about differnt keys. And I liked rock and blues songs so I often learned songs in A or E without knowing the the keys. I just wanted to play what I heard.
Thanks @thomsax .. it all really started because the original i had had a picture of and was advertised as the Carpenters version..it clearly isn't as when transposed to D from C it was wrong even an octave higher...A major sounds right alongsode the original track...i will use all the instrumentals in the near future for playing by ear
 
A song like this, any song really, will be played in the key that suits the vocalist, I’ve had to play in some weird keys just to suit the singer’s range that aren’t always well suited to the saxophone, you can play it but it puts you in regions that don’t sit well. This one is a good example of a song that you can take through the keys by ear, start with C as that’s what you’ve got and just go through as many keys as you can handle, singers seem to like keys with sharps so G, A, D and E are the starting point, then try F, Bb, Eb and Ab. When you’ve done that see how you feel about B, F# and C#. Just don’t rush them.
 
Methinks the good Doctor was being humorous, talking about relevance and then bringing sausages into the discussion, although I accept it’s not completely off the track, just about. And, yes I’m sure we can with a bit of effort, probably not down at the local supermarket though and we might need to settle for close enough and go for Polish sausage.
 
Last edited:
Methinks the good Doctor was being humorous, talking about relevance and then bringing sausages into the discussion, although I accept it’s not completely off the track, just about. And, yes I’m sure we can with a bit of effort, probably not down at the local supermarket though and we might need to settle for close enough and go for Polish sausage.
Ahhh had a foot long german at windsor....kinda little or kinda large....8 squid tho...flamin xmas
 
A song like this, any song really, will be played in the key that suits the vocalist, I’ve had to play in some weird keys just to suit the singer’s range that aren’t always well suited to the saxophone, you can play it but it puts you in regions that don’t sit well. This one is a good example of a song that you can take through the keys by ear, start with C as that’s what you’ve got and just go through as many keys as you can handle, singers seem to like keys with sharps so G, A, D and E are the starting point, then try F, Bb, Eb and Ab. When you’ve done that see how you feel about B, F# and C#. Just don’t rush them.
Why should we consider the vocal when we don't have any vocal on backing track? The saxplayer decide the best key for he/she. I would like to do that song in (concert) Bb (C tenor , G alto). I just read that Darlene Love had to sing in lower keys in the end of a long tour. And if she was going to record a song the same day as a tour was over she would probably sing in Eb, D .... instead of E.
 
Why should we consider the vocal when we don't have any vocal on backing track? The saxplayer decide the best key for he/she. I would like to do that song in (concert) Bb (C tenor , G alto). I just read that Darlene Love had to sing in lower keys in the end of a long tour. And if she was going to record a song the same day as a tour was over she would probably sing in Eb, D .... instead of E.

I used to ask my drummer what key he wanted to play. I didn’t care, of course, but it made him feel included.




@eb424 Humor.
 
I had a drummer once who asked what the musicians wanted to play, then immediately realising just what he’d said and going off to sulk behind his kit.
 
Last edited:
Any improvements on Dr.Gs offering, above?
Which looks quite good, to me.
You be the judge:



 
Anti-humor: After reading this thread, all my ads I am seeing everywhere today are Jambalaya recipes 🙁
A little maintenance required. Delete history and clear your cache.

Guest singer turned up at a local gig explaining her song list. This one in E, that one in A. The band leader nodded sagely and off she went to put her frock on. The trumpet player looked worried and informed the band leader he wasn't comfortable busking in sharp keys.
"Me neither" replied the band leader. "We'll play them in Eb and Bb. She'll never know."
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,074
Messages
578,636
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom