- Messages
- 7,981
- Location
- Bristol, UK
The OP now has access to tenor lead sheets for concert C and concert G.
So please can we stop? It’s making my head hurt.
So please can we stop? It’s making my head hurt.


Hey @turf3 I'm by no means saying its the best version, love fats domino and most of the ones you've shown. I'm trying to work on transposing and preferred the carpenters version to the original as it seemed a bit more challenging to play and transpose. I could get the website to transpose for me but I don't learn anything....I really appreciate all the patients and comments on here re playing by ear and do realise that the forum isn't my teacher so thanks all. I do have a cunning plan...each of the songs I transpose has an instrumental and my intention is to fill this by ear....also once I have learnt sufficient technique such as growling, and can put some more feeling into my songs I will gladly move away from the carpenters and have a go at the song in a better or more suited to me style...Thanks again...EddieWell, yeah, the cheesy mid 70s Carpenters vs. one of the pioneers and geniuses of American music, as source material.
I mean first listen to this:
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7-BQpRqmwM0
And some folks have done hip interpretations:
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lZsdvn2uJH0
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5qWnbVTqfUo
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pa2Tl5BeK-U
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a0hKzamp_R4
And then listen to this (if you can stand it):
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XonORyEo0I8
Thanks @nigeld I know you have a headache with it all but could you explain how the above works....if you can that would be great and if yo PM me your address I'll send a months worth of paracetamol as a thank you....Your opening question was about the original key (concert C), so that is what I have answered.
However, the Carpenters version is in concert G, which means that you want notes in the key of A for tenor sax.
So you can use the alto (Eb) sax notes for concert C - they are in A. When you play from these notes on tenor, you are in concert G.
It's simply that you need the dots in A to play on tenor for the concert G version (Carpenters Version).Thanks @nigeld I know you have a headache with it all but could you explain how the above works....if you can that would be great and if yo PM me your address I'll send a months worth of paracetamol as a thank you....
Thanks for that @jazzdoh, think I may as well get the headache out the way tho....i understand that there are 5 semitones difference between eb and bb but is there a formula for knowing what a key in Eb transposes to..It's simply that you need the dots in A to play on tenor for the concert G version (Carpenters Version).
The concert C version notes on alto are in A so there you have the A dots to play on tenor for concert G.
Sounds complicated but the more you do transposing the more tips like this come into play.
Have fun with the song.
BTW I know its all experience to do transposing but you could also use the play-along books that are already in the right keys, this will for now save you a headache.
Probably best to ask that in a thread about transposing so we don’t get off topic in this oneThanks for that @jazzdoh, think I may as well get the headache out the way tho....i understand that there are 5 semitones difference between eb and bb but is there a formula for knowing what a key in Eb transposes to..
ok @Pete Thomas but this thread is / was about transposing....Probably best to ask that in a thread about transposing so we don’t get off topic in this one
So why is the title Jambalaya? And the question about what key it was in originally?ok @Pete Thomas but this thread is / was about transposing....

erm...that was what I was transposing ;-) ....wrong title???So why is the title Jambalaya?
I personally wouldn't look at it that way for now, try to transpose thinking of the concert key and then moving 2 semitones up for tenor or 3 semitones down for alto.Thanks for that @jazzdoh, think I may as well get the headache out the way tho....i understand that there are 5 semitones difference between eb and bb but is there a formula for knowing what a key in Eb transposes to..
Such as?Probably best to ask that in a thread about transposing so we don’t get off topic in this one
I'm confused now. The question about Bb to Eb is transposing in general, not Jambalaya. Hence better in a thread about transposing in general.erm...that was what I was transposing ;-) ....wrong title???
sorry @jazzdoh I probably didn't get it accross right but how does the key of A on an alto become a G on tenor...can't find it on google...I personally wouldn't look at it that way for now, try to transpose thinking of the concert key and then moving 2 semitones up for tenor or 3 semitones down for alto.
sorry @mizmar does that one cover key sigs from Eb to Bb instruments......Such as?
![]()
Saxophone beginners - Transposing
Ok... so apologies to those thinking "cripes here he goes again...".... I was trying to transpose " Always a woman to me" by Billy Joel...from piano, guitar score..i.e concert pitch insstrument.The sheet music was in eb major so using my chart that goes up 2 semitones ( is a semi tone a half...cafesaxophone.com
fair point @Pete Thomas its awkward as this has come up mid thread re transposing. I don't suppose you'd have a link to a relevant thread...I'm confused now. The question about Bb to Eb is transposing in general, not Jambalaya. Hence better in a thread about transposing in general.
The forum is most useful for people when they find thing under relvant titles 🙂
Sure. Transposing from any key to any other key always follows the same procedure.. transposition in general.sorry @mizmar does that one cover key sigs from Eb to Bb instruments......
its gone on a bit....should have left it at post 3 TBF..... 😉All I can say about this thread is Me-O My-O.
The answer is it doesn't.sorry @jazzdoh I probably didn't get it accross right but how does the key of A on an alto become a G on tenor...can't find it on google...
