Ah well, after 47 years of playing the bloomin' things perhaps I've become somewhat less open to the opinions of others concerning my tone. Although, actually, I can't remember anyone sensibly commenting on it in the last 36 years (since I did a grade 8 exam and I'm not counting recordings - too many variables). So I find it difficult to regard it as an issue for anybody else.
If my tone really is an issue for somebody else then (unless they're very weird) it will pale into insignificance compared with what it means to me. If my ears tell me something's wrong tonewise then I'm not going to play as well as I could. Which is possibly bad news for everyone.
But having said all that, I certainly get your (Stephen and Jaye) points about less experienced players not necessarily being the best judges. I've certainly criticised the horrible noises my students have produced from time to time. 🙂
If my tone really is an issue for somebody else then (unless they're very weird) it will pale into insignificance compared with what it means to me. If my ears tell me something's wrong tonewise then I'm not going to play as well as I could. Which is possibly bad news for everyone.
But having said all that, I certainly get your (Stephen and Jaye) points about less experienced players not necessarily being the best judges. I've certainly criticised the horrible noises my students have produced from time to time. 🙂

