Playing the saxophone Is there a front Eb?

mizmar

Eternal early intermediat
Messages
6,147
Location
Trondheim, Norway
Level
Eternal early intermediat
I'm quite fond of the non-palm key, high E, F and F#... I was pottering with something in Bb and, obviously, palm Eb is fine but just felt an alternative would be nice; but can't find it...

(I'm on tenor just now not, i suppose, that it matters)
 
Last edited:
No there isn't. But you might be able to coax out an Eb with just the E natural side key and no palm keys. Definitely not the best practice, but could pass in a trill or awkward passage.
 
"Front F" is a harmonic of A which would normally be E but it is so sharp it sounds an F
"Front E" is a harmonic of G which would normally be D but it is so sharp it sounds an E

There just might be a finger one can add to "Front E" that would lower it a half step to Eb. 😎
 
"Front F" is a harmonic of A which would normally be E but it is so sharp it sounds an F
"Front E" is a harmonic of G which would normally be D but it is so sharp it sounds an E

There just might be a finger one can add to "Front E" that would lower it a half step to Eb. 😎
I've tried every possibility using Front E. Nothing gives an Eb. If you've found one, I'm all ears.
 
The secret to easy palm key fingerings and articulating around the saxophone, where fingers are at a minimum, is how you hang the horn and support it.
I like to have it balanced so that I can blow a C# comfortably, no hands and play it there.
Playing into a mirror and watching yourself can reveal movements you had no idea you were making.
Playing down to Bb, no thumbs, is revealing.
It all helps to position things to help your fingers dance over the keys without gripping or supporting the horn.
 
Something I found a couple decades ago that's made a big difference: practice those non-preferred fingerings just as assiduously as the preferred ones.

So, if you would normally play a pattern using front F and E, practice doing half of it with the front and half with the palm. In other words, see-sawing back and forth between front keys and palm keys. In theory, of course, one would work out fingering patterns that avoid that; but in the real world of playing "NOW" being able to do those un-recommended things is a big benefit.

Similarly, when you do your tone building and interval work, make sure to use all the alternate fingerings. For example let's say I'm practicing the C major arpeggio: I'll finger that high E as a palm key, as the traditional front E, and with the "semi-front" fingering which is like a G# but with the side high E key. When I can go from LH 2nd finger C to any of those three E fingerings and back, smoothly without fingering or airstream bobbles, that's my goal. And of course this applies to all the various finger exercises one does. Anything that has the high F# gets both fingerings, the traditional front F with something added in the RH (exactly what is added varies a bit amongst horns) as well as the 1-3-4 fingering that works on all my horns. And so on, and so on.

If your long term goal is "equal facility in all keys" (and it's hard to argue against that, not if you want to be a fully functional musician) then this kind of stuff is important.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom