Tech/maintenance Is it rust red , or red rot?..

The abrasive in it is too coarse. The finish it leaves is not high polish.
We used Brasso in the Army going back to the early 1970's. It is an older product.

Collar brass and belt buckle for the Class B and Dress Uniform (coat & tie), leadership did not like the darkened lacquer finish. We would put a half teaspoon of Brasso on a section of paper bag, use the abrasive action of the paper, work on it until all lacquer was removed. Then use Brasso with a fine clothe, could even be an old T-shirt cloth. Rub the brass to a fine shine.

Brasso will polish the sax brass, (just a thought after posting this, maybe not as shiny as a buffing wheel to a flawless mirror gloss for relacquering) but I have not needed to go to that extreme. On my 1952ish Beaugnier Vito Low-Bb Bari sax, I just used it to clean the corrosion and tarnish. I didn't want to remove the remaining lacquer. Once cleaned, it looked acceptable.

One of course can choose their poison, but I am a long time user of Brasso, and it works fine for me for my particular purposes. However, everyone has their preferences and expectations. I say use what works for you.
 
If it's been a while, I may gently apply key oil to key hinge points, use a Q-Tip / rag / felt pipe cleaner to wick up any excess.
Applying key oil to hinge key points is not sufficient. If it’s been a while, remove the rod, clean the tube, and then lube and reassemble.

See Matt Stohrer’s YouTube video on “Changing the Oil”.
 
1.webp


Before

bell-engraving.webp


After. I used Flitz on a very soft rag and tried to avoid anything that goes "across" the engraving instead of in the direction of the engraving. Some areas I used a Q-tip
 
This has been written before, perhaps by you

'Stringent' doesn't really say what the actual issue is

How exactly is Brasso bad for a brass horn? It's great for filthy brass candlesticks
There is a heavy chemical in it, quite ammoniac-smelling, and the grain of it is too large or less fine than, say, Wenol or Mass or Flitz. So, while it attacks rot pretty well, the resulting area does actually end up with 'more metal removed from it' than, the others.

And the area visually ends up looking more abraded than what Wenol, etc will do.

Since I refurb and re-sell, aesthetics of the final result are MORE important on my horns than, say, just a player who wants theirs to 'look better'. I have to spend a good 90 minutes on my offerings to get them to look nicer than what a tech might normally do for a horn owner in their 'cleaning' scope of work.

An area of microscratches and inconsistent lustre on a horn I am selling hurts the desirability. When I have been forced to use Brasso, I always have had to hit the area with a buffing wheel, lightly, afterward. With Wenol, Maas, Flitz, etc...I don' have to do that. Their results just blend better, visually.


Lastly, on lacquered horns which have the red spotting, so basically the wetness ate thru the lacq and started red rotting the brass, Noxon and BRasso can dissolve the lacquer with repeated applications (applications which would be required to get the red off, likely) whereas the others will not dissolve the lacq.....

Hope that explains it ? It is just too caustic/aggressive if what you want if for the result 'just to look like the red is gone' and have no other aesthetic side effects. If better products are available for an instrument application - and they are, I mean Wenol is available online - then IMHO use the best stuff for the job, not necessarily just the stuff at the most convenient hardware store to you. My 2 cents.
 
Why do you prefer Maas or Wenol over Simichrome?

(Just as an aside, I can't find Maas or Wenol in hardware stores here, but Simichrome is SOMEWHAT available.
I really liked Simichrome for nickelplate.....it's better on nickelplate than the others I like, almost as if it were more made for it.

Nothing against it on brass, really, I just think Wenol is better and since it isn't as if local hardware stores carry Simichrome, I have to order either online, so I usually go Wenol....If Simi were available locally, I'd probably use it more.
 
If meticulous, one can reasonably clean their sax without any disassembly or loosening key rods. Use a variety of cleaning tools such as cloths, paper towels, Q-Tips, felt pipe cleaners, a gentle cleaning agent, toothpicks and etc.
Maybe, maybe not. For areas showing verdgris or red rot in difficult to get locations, q-tips and threading and pulling cloths thru the keywork areas isn't gonna really do it.

Typical example - rot or verdgris at the base of posts. Those need significantly aggressivve treatment..a q-tip slathered with polish isn't gonna do the job.

So, yes...you can do this stuff if you really do not wanna disassemble and reassemble, or have a tech do it, but the end result is going to be compromised compared to a disassembled sax, body submerged in a sonic or chem bath, THEN followed by a hand polish where all areas are most accessible.

In situations like that, I usually just recommend to the owner:

you don't necessarily have to bring horn in solely for a cleaning - next time your horn goes in for a service (where there is a high likelihood that it is gonna have to be partially disassembled at least) have the tech include a bath, rinse and polish on top of what else it needs. It should only add around $100 then you won't have to worry about it again for several years...
 
Maybe, maybe not. For areas showing verdgris or red rot in difficult to get locations, q-tips and threading and pulling cloths thru the keywork areas isn't gonna really do it. Typical example - rot or verdgris at the base of posts. Those need significantly aggressivve treatment..a q-tip slathered with polish isn't gonna do the job.
Actually my point in cleaning was more in general, and in the cases you mention, some areas could be untouchable without a disassembly. Even a new sax gets dusty and dirty. I've found that to do a little non-disassembly detailing cleans things up quite nicely. It doesn't have to be 100% perfect to look acceptable. Removal of the dust and split splashes does wonders for appearances. Careful oiling of the keys with a quality oil continues smooth operation.

Plus, I am not afraid to do partial disassemblies if required. I am meticulous enough to get it back together without harm to adjustments. Remember the clocks and clock radios with flippy digital numbers common back in the 1970's? Mine developed problems, I had it all apart with gears, springs, rods, etc. all over the place. My roommate wondered if I'd ever get it back together again. But I did, fixed the problem and had it all back together again without left over parts. Worked fine for another couple years.
 
Actually my point in cleaning was more in general, and in the cases you mention, some areas could be untouchable without a disassembly. Even a new sax gets dusty and dirty. I've found that to do a little non-disassembly detailing cleans things up quite nicely. It doesn't have to be 100% perfect to look acceptable. Removal of the dust and split splashes does wonders for appearances. Careful oiling of the keys with a quality oil continues smooth operation.

Plus, I am not afraid to do partial disassemblies if required. I am meticulous enough to get it back together without harm to adjustments. Remember the clocks and clock radios with flippy digital numbers common back in the 1970's? Mine developed problems, I had it all apart with gears, springs, rods, etc. all over the place. My roommate wondered if I'd ever get it back together again. But I did, fixed the problem and had it all back together again without left over parts. Worked fine for another couple years.
The reason these nasties happen is lack of upkeep to begin with, so I applaud you on your efforts.

Not wiping the horn down if there's moisture on it, not swabbing, putting it in its case wet, storing it in a really bad, detrimental location....all of these things are the things that result in nasties like red rot, verdgris, etc.
 
The horror! The horror! Red ROT!!!!!!

It's all downhill from here, the horn will crumble into a pile of reddish dust before you know it (well, maybe in another 10,000 years or so...)

It's obvious that what you need to do is to pack that doomed horn up and send it to me for proper disposal, so you can get yourself a nice new Mendini.
 
Taking my beater Silversonic out after a while, I noticed it's developed a rather red-rusty line across the B/Bb key guard:

View attachment 31527

I don't know... in a certain light...

View attachment 31528

I kinda dig it.
Keep playing it. That’ll blow off !
I’ll pay for shipping if you’d like a proper cremation done here. No Feral Cats will be harmed during the process.
Buy an Opus tenor. Mendini are overrated.
 
This has been written before, perhaps by you

'Stringent' doesn't really say what the actual issue is

How exactly is Brasso bad for a brass horn? It's great for filthy brass candlesticks
Brasso and Dezincification Risk
Brasso contains ammonium hydroxide. Ammonia is a substance that can cause stress corrosion cracking and may contribute to dezincification in susceptible brasses, particularly the common CuZn30 alloy used in many applications, including musical instruments.….this from a quick AI search.

Dezincification is a common concern in treatment of brass objects in museums, visually it can result in pink coloration as the alloy surface moves to a higher relative copper content.
 
Brasso and Dezincification Risk
Brasso contains ammonium hydroxide. Ammonia is a substance that can cause stress corrosion cracking and may contribute to dezincification in susceptible brasses, particularly the common CuZn30 alloy used in many applications, including musical instruments.….this from a quick AI search.

Dezincification is a common concern in treatment of brass objects in museums, visually it can result in pink coloration as the alloy surface moves to a higher relative copper content.
That explains it, yeah for the job it needs to do on musical instruments, you don't need the ammonium in there...
 
Just for clarification, the pink appearance is not the same as red rot. You get the pink as a surface dezincification, which is very minor and typically also very short-lived. You can do the same thing on a copper penny to get that old-lady's hair dye gone bad look as well.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,196
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom