Theory & Impro Improvisation or copying?

Yes, Kev, but creative people have to get tied up in their idea's so their creativity could take on diverse results. It's the options of those who seek various levels of creativity and those involved who hold no responsibility to tradition. No one should have the burden to be responsible to anyone else regarding art.

Tradition is for those who adhere to tradition. It's not a smack in the face if the potentiality of creativity appears to over step
tradition. I too love tradition but I personally feel it's important for an artist to keep forging ahead because let's face it, tradition at one time wasn't very traditional. Evolution creates tradition.
It's not dangerous to think this way Kev. It's a profoundly healthy way to approach art, and in my opinion it's not a utilized option.

I personally do not dismiss music, or art in general, that has been documented for centuries. But I certainly would not want to stagnate in something that has been reiterated countless times. That's just a personal option. Tradition is a stepping stone and we use tradition to set parameters for growth and that keeps tradition in it's proper perspective. Wade's a proponent, like I am, for evolved teaching methods and that does not mean that teaching must stop regarding tradition. It's a matter of curriculum and music curriculum should indeed evolve into more of a focus on creativity, as in how a once non-tradition became tradition.

And we need to strike a balance between the internal obsession with being new/different all the time and acceptance that there is good in the past that's still valid today.
Yes, but you're statement of creativity being an inherent danger is not striking a balance. What I propose, as in extending music curriculum, is to include various levels of creativity, That is striking a balance.
There is nothing even remotely wrong with someone who aspires to always be new and different. It's a personal prerogative for this option to occur. The good in the past are for those who love the music of the past and I see no danger in that either. Music of all era's will always serve a viable purpose to anyone who adheres to it.

You say you enjoy new idea's. Great! But under whose guidance must those new idea's work for? It's certainly not up to you or I to prove acceptance of new idea's. They should always exist and continue to exist on their own accord. It's individual to discard which are not accepted. Anything more than that is dangerous to a free society!

Art should always be a personal assessment of the artist's surroundings/environment. Not everyone has to understand the individual who is telling their own story. If we don't appreciate the story, well, there are countless other stories that are being told and they should have every right to say them regardless if anyone finds them offensive or they find them profoundly beautiful. This is the essence of art.

Kev, I believe, from what I have read from you, that you're passionate about tradition. And through your passion you've become defensive and so you said something that maybe wasn't in your best contextual nature. It happens. Geez, your a moderator of this forum....What am I supposed to think when a mod claims freedom of expression to be dangerous? LOL...

Keep well my friend...I do respect your passion for tradition. It belongs to you and so you should embrace it!
 
Very sorry if I offended. Hopefully disagreeing was not as offensive as that naughty word "crap". I truly am sorry though as this is a topic I am passionate about and don't think it is responsible for anyone to make silly statements that infer that students have precognizance about what they will be taught and have made a conscious decision to learn that curriculum . Altissimo said it so much better without offense. I think many may not have their eyes open to what is all pervasive. Look around. What are people being told to play and study? Standards. The teaching of this type of playing, including real and fake books, play along records, and instruction is certainly a far bigger money making industry than anyone makes playing this music. This alone should be ringing some wake up bells. It is impossible to accept that students wanting to learn the sax just can't wait to learn a bunch of tunes they have never heard and none of their friends will have heard or want to hear. They are told and heavily influenced to do so. As Altissimo says most of us know and carry the knowledge of what has come before. The players of the 1050-60s knew what Dixieland sounded like and could probably play it, but didn't want or need to be repeating that style. They had moved on.

When I was in High School if you wanted to practice any number of professions you needed to have studied Latin for four years. This was seen by pedagogy as an absolute requirement. A few years later they suddenly realized they were teaching a dead language that didn't substantially improve the performance of those professionals, it in fact took up a lot of time that could have been better spent.

I guess there are some small groups of people who love Latin and correspond or meet up to speak their dead language. There is also Esperanto. There are musicians who are serious about playing Morris Dance music as well. Good on all of them for doing what they like and disregarding those of us who snicker.


If everyone who was learning to play sax had the realization that learning standards was the equivalent to learning Morris Dancing I think they would probably avoid it. Those teaching mainstream music do so probably because they can't make a living out of playing it. This is a cycle of failure that is being perpetuated. I don't think that there is any conspiracy or ill intent in this, quite the opposite. It is done with love and affection for the music and thinking that they are teaching in the best possible manner. Unfortunately this does not make it a reality.

Old saying says if it ain't broke don't fix it. Unfortunately mainstream players are broke in every sense.
 
Very sorry if I offended. Hopefully disagreeing was not as offensive as that naughty word "crap".
You can use as many naughty words as you like to me. Kev and Pete might not like it, though, for the sake of others.
What offended me was your dismissive attitude towards my opinions. It's just not a nice or productive way to conduct a debate.

I truly am sorry though as this is a topic I am passionate about and don't think it is responsible for anyone to make silly statements
Thanks again!

that infer that students have precognizance about what they will be taught and have made a conscious decision to learn that curriculum .
So it's irresponsible of me to express an opinion which differs from yours? That's a strange thing to say for an opponent of dogmatism and rigid approaches. I won't discuss the subject with you any further.
 
Yes, but you're statement of creativity being an inherent danger is not striking a balance. What I propose, as in extending music curriculum, is to include various levels of creativity, That is striking a balance.

Yes. It's the obsessive that I don't like.

You say you enjoy new idea's. Great! But under whose guidance must those new idea's work for? It's certainly not up to you or I to prove acceptance of new idea's.
Agreed

They should always exist and continue to exist on their own accord. It's individual to discard which are not accepted. Anything more than that is dangerous to a free society!
But the free society also discards.

Art should always be a personal assessment of the artist's surroundings/environment. Not everyone has to understand the individual who is telling their own story. If we don't appreciate the story, well, there are countless other stories that are being told and they should have every right to say them regardless if anyone finds them offensive or they find them profoundly beautiful. This is the essence of art.

Yes

Kev, I believe, from what I have read from you, that you're passionate about tradition. And through your passion you've become defensive and so you said something that maybe wasn't in your best contextual nature. It happens. Geez, your a moderator of this forum....What am I supposed to think when a mod claims freedom of expression to be dangerous? LOL...

Passionate about tradition - no. It has it's place, but it can stifle innovation. Against change for the sake of it - strongly yes.
But you're misunderstanding I didn't say freedom of expression was dangerous - I tried, unsuccessfully it seems, to say that there's a danger of becoming so obsessed with the new that we reject the old. Big difference.

I like to think of music as a tennis ball. Mainstream in the middle, creativity in the hairs. Those hairs, like human hairs have their roots deeper in. But they are seen only as the hair on the ball. They get beaten by the racquet, ground.... And as they survive they become subsumed into the main mass. Some people need to be one of the hairs. And it's good. But it's not the only place to be - there are many different hairs. As well as the space in the middle. I like to be on the surface, part of the rubber, exposed to the hairs - but I pick which hairs I'm exposed to. And there's an endless line around the ball, separating and linking the hairs of expression. Endless reminding us that the more obsessed we become with creativity, the more we re-invent what's gone before, and endless because we can move from one area to another, always going forwards, but with the probablity that if we move far enough forward we retrace our steps.

I believe freedom of expression is essential - but not at the cost of rudeness or unpleasantness.

I'm really enjoying this debate. But we're moving towards the usual forum problem - proving ourselves correct.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm not sure what offended Bigmartin about Wade's post. I thought Wade was talking about current students - young people. Bigmartin's admitted to being 53 so I don't think he qualifies. 🙂 :blowkiss:

I'd like to agree with much of what Wade says but <anecdote alert!> a few years ago I was playing in a horn section next to a young altoist who was about to go to college to study jazz. He wanted to play like Charlie Parker. So he was 'got at' well before his college days. Great player, actually, but I thought it was a bit sad that he was inspired by someone who'd been dead 50 odd years and not a contemporary player. When I first started (40 or so years ago) the players That inspired me were only a few years older than me and I could go and see them playing. Principally Elton Dean and John Surman but also Evan Parker, Alan Skidmore, Mike Osborne and many others. Coltrane was not long dead - the first album I heard of his was Sun Ship - only a few years old and relentlessly modern - I loved it. Anthony Braxton was a big influence too.

I suspect that what we've been seeing for the last few years is a bit of a reaction to the totally free and far out improvisation of the 60s and 70s. The establishment reasserting itself, if you like. I agree with Wade that it's a shame that music colleges promote an old way of doing stuff - but that's what they've always done. When I first went to university (next door to the RCM) the RCM wouldn't even allow saxophones in the building.

I suppose I should add that, to my chagrin, that my playing's got more boring over the years. It's what comes of doing it for a living I suppose. Not that it's anything like an actual living you understand. 🙁

To give you an idea of what I mean I'll just mention this. I was inordinately pleased that I've just persuaded one of the bands I play in to do 'Ain't No Sunshine' as an instrumental soprano feature. I couldn't imagine Anthony Braxton being happy about that.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm not sure what offended Bigmartin about Wade's post. I thought Wade was talking about current students - young people. Bigmartin's admitted to being 53 so I don't think he qualifies. 🙂 :blowkiss:
OK. What offended me was nothing to do with the the subject at hand. It was Wade's description of my comments as "crap", "silly", and not "responsible". As in "go away, little boy, you don't know what you're talking about". To me, it feels like I'm being bullied.

I've disagreed with you, Nick, about various things, but I like to think we've kept it polite and respectful (albeit with a bit of banter thrown in). No problems there; if we all agreed on everything what would be the point of discussions? But I feel this has spilled over into something else, and I want no more part in it.
 
We sound like we're reliving the sort of debates that may have gone on in the jazz world in the 60's and 70's about improvisation, egotism and similar.

Anyway, has anybody heard the new "Get the Blessing" CD (OC DC) "...With its thundering rock-bass grooves and scorching early Ornette Coleman/Don Cherry horn sound........" (Guardian - Friday 2nd March 2012).

Regards to all
Tom
 
Altissimo, thanks for painting the other side.

thanks, but if you read what I wrote you'd've noticed that I'm against "sides" and the whole dualistic, either/or, "I'm right. you're wrong" dogmatic way of thinking, which left unchecked, seems to have resulted in a whole lot of strife, suffering and warfare over the centuries
there's a difference between personal opinion and demonstrable fact. Disliking something doesn't make it bad or wrong (or "crap"). We all make value judgements, but maybe we should be aware that we're doing so and perhaps moderate our thinking to a more tolerant level. Human beings have to get along with each other despite our differences.
If you'd written "There's a potential danger in being creative - it can sometimes leads to dismissal of what's gone before" it might have seemed more reasonable. To then go on about ruthlessly discarding bad music, bad art etc makes you sound like a bit of a fanatic - it's not good for the moderator to come across as being immoderate..

sometimes the discarded ideas are the one's that turn out to be the most useful and if you've read anything of the history of science you'd find that struggling against an entrenched orthodoxy has been the norm for many of our finest minds.

we all think we know what's right or wrong for ourselves, but do any of us know what's right or wrong for other people?
Freedom to be creative in whatever way works for you could be considered to be a basic human right

As for Antonio Salieri, if you googled his name as I've just done, you'd find his work can be found on Amazon, Youtube, Myspace and many other places
I found this article -
http://www.mozartforum.com/Contemporary Pages/Anontio_Salieri_Contemp.htm
"it is very unfortunate that Salieri, such a brilliant person and composer, would be defamed as such by the likes of Pushkin and those who rumored against him. He was indeed a truly outstanding person. As a family man and a musician, balancing both demanding efforts, there were no rivals. Fortunately, Salieri’s reputation is now being cleared. More and more people are becoming aware of his works through new recordings and increasing numbers of performances of his music. Much of this revival can be credited to his being brought to the spotlight by the movie Amadeus, which while factually inaccurate, never actually directly indicts Salieri of killing Mozart. Hopefully, one day Salieri’s music will be played again worldwide in all its glory and he will receive the credit that he so rightfully deserves."

so it seems that the future is judging Salieri's music as being worthy of merit after all. It's not his fault he was the victim of narrowmindedness. Perhaps we can learn something from this..?

anyone for tennis?
 
I'm not sure what offended Bigmartin about Wade's post. I thought Wade was talking about current students - young people. Bigmartin's admitted to being 53 so I don't think he qualifies. 🙂 :blowkiss:

I'd like to agree with much of what Wade says but <anecdote alert!> a few years ago I was playing in a horn section next to a young altoist who was about to go to college to study jazz. He wanted to play like Charlie Parker. So he was 'got at' well before his college days. Great player, actually, but I thought it was a bit sad that he was inspired by someone who'd been dead 50 odd years and not a contemporary player. When I first started (40 or so years ago) the players That inspired me were only a few years older than me and I could go and see them playing. Principally Elton Dean and John Surman but also Evan Parker, Alan Skidmore, Mike Osborne and many others. Coltrane was not long dead - the first album I heard of his was Sun Ship - only a few years old and relentlessly modern - I loved it. Anthony Braxton was a big influence too.

I suspect that what we've been seeing for the last few years is a bit of a reaction to the totally free and far out improvisation of the 60s and 70s. The establishment reasserting itself, if you like. I agree with Wade that it's a shame that music colleges promote an old way of doing stuff - but that's what they've always done. When I first went to university (next door to the RCM) the RCM wouldn't even allow saxophones in the building.

I suppose I should add that, to my chagrin, that my playing's got more boring over the years. It's what comes of doing it for a living I suppose. Not that it's anything like an actual living you understand. 🙁

To give you an idea of what I mean I'll just mention this. I was inordinately pleased that I've just persuaded one of the bands I play in to do 'Ain't No Sunshine' as an instrumental soprano feature. I couldn't imagine Anthony Braxton being happy about that.

which band is featuring aint no sunshine,THAT SOUNDS GREAT!
 
Point about Salieri was that if you listen to the clasic channels, or look through the concert offerings, Mozart's works are really common. Salieri, around here at least, barely gets a mention, let alone airplay.
 
Passionate about tradition - no. It has it's place, but it can stifle innovation. Against change for the sake of it - strongly yes.
But you're misunderstanding I didn't say freedom of expression was dangerous - I tried, unsuccessfully it seems, to say that there's a danger of becoming so obsessed with the new that we reject the old. Big difference.

I like to think of music as a tennis ball. Mainstream in the middle, creativity in the hairs. Those hairs, like human hairs have their roots deeper in. But they are seen only as the hair on the ball. They get beaten by the racquet, ground.... And as they survive they become subsumed into the main mass. Some people need to be one of the hairs. And it's good. But it's not the only place to be - there are many different hairs. As well as the space in the middle. I like to be on the surface, part of the rubber, exposed to the hairs - but I pick which hairs I'm exposed to. And there's an endless line around the ball, separating and linking the hairs of expression. Endless reminding us that the more obsessed we become with creativity, the more we re-invent what's gone before, and endless because we can move from one area to another, always going forwards, but with the probablity that if we move far enough forward we retrace our steps.

I believe freedom of expression is essential - but not at the cost of rudeness or unpleasantness.

I'm really enjoying this debate. But we're moving towards the usual forum problem - proving ourselves correct.

You will have to excuse me Kev. I can only acertain so much regarding text. At times, I must try and formulate my own understanding of the passages I'm reading. There are no vocal inflections, no mannerisms to help illustrate the intent. In other words I'm trying my best. However, I did mention that I understand that your contextual intent may be under embellished. Meaning, that your true intent in the word 'dangerous' may be a tad under exemplified? So , I simply stated the word 'passion' to illustrate how I interpreted it.

I merely indicated that when the word dangerous, as in creativity is dangerous, is stated, the word freedom of thought must be included, or at least easily assumed.
But again, if I may, there is nothing dangerous in obsessions of any kind regarding art. It's perfectly fine to reject any aspect of art. You're only stating an individual perspective, and so am I Kev. I can only speak for myself. An example.....The music that I have written was not out of intentional revolt of the status quo. My approach to music has been the most natural course for me to take. In other words, it comes easy for me to think along those lines. For others who do choose to be different for different sake? Well, again, they are entitled to do that. But you disagree with that type of action and yes, you are entitled to disagree also just as long as the disagreement only takes on the form of a vocalized opinion.

In regards to your analogy Kev, I personally do not think we can become so separated in our zeal for creativity that tradition will become obsolete. That will never happen. The links will always be present no matter what it is society does. Personally, I feel your worries, or concerns, are not worth fretting over. We're speaking of a planet consisting of over 6 billion thinking minds with myriads of tastes. This forum is a profoundly small microcosm of how the world thinks. Possibly we're all being a tad over dramatic?

I would never try to prove my own philosophies of perception. I can only access my own opinions regarding the issues at hand. Forums are essentially based on personal observation. What do I know, I'm just a speck of sand who happens to have an opinion.

Let me just say that freedom of expression is essential at any cost!
You must carefully evaluate the words you are choosing Kev and what they imply! This I will be pragmatic! Rudeness or unpleasantness are individual perceptions only. They are not universal. Being offended over anything of an artistic nature is insecure and if actions regarding rudeness or unpleasantness have potential to be exercised, yes, then we're speaking of a real danger. Everyone is entitled to express themselves in any way shape or form just as long as it doesn't 'physically' harm another individual!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thank you all for your contributions. I read you all loud and clear. One thing baffles me though. If blues scales are enough to be original, if playing "Humpty Dumpty's Vast Book On Major Licks And Other Cool Stuff" is enough to be original, if, in short, playing other peoples stuff is enough to make originality then surely* playing 'Brother Jacob' (Frère Jacques, Fray Jacobo, Bruder Jakob, Mester Jacob) is enough to be original (or any other children songs for that matter). It must be. Nothing original, but by George, amazingly original...

*Anyone starting a claim using the word surely are surely not to sure about the sure facts of the surely claimed claim.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom