Theory & Impro Improvisation or copying?

Would you be happier if I put the words "and roll" in there? Maybe the "and roll" was the good stuff >:).

You may think that. Others may disagree.

I thought it got interesting after they ditched the "and roll" bit.

Anyway, back to improv.

I broadly agree with Tom. Most of my playing these days is done in a rock environment. Practising II/V/Is ain't much good to me either.
 
If you are interested in making a living out of playing music you'd have to be thinking more like Tom, or at least not trying to sound like copying someone (name your favorite jazz sax player) out of the 1950-60s. I've got to admit to being old enough to have enjoyed what was happening then, but that was then, and this is now. Forcing new players into a mold of playing standards may make sense if you are a pedagog and like your teaching formulated, but it is stifling new talent. Utilizing newer musical forms or looking ahead is more likely to give a budding musician a chance at making a living. There just aren't audiences for mainstream jazz and that's NOT going to change.

Two big problems with mainstream:
1. Standards are NOT known by the vast majority. This means that those "oh so clever" variations, don't have much meaning. The idea of a standard (in the 1950-1960s) was that everybody KNEW what you were playing, it had personal reference. This meant that those thoughts and feeling were being played with in subtle, or not so subtle ways. That reference is gone unless you are a pensioner (not the best demographic for drawing an audience).

2. Most learning to play in a strictly mainstream style are primarily concerned with technique. Yea, it's that Coltrane thing that leaves those not already into mainstream blank faced zombies after a short while. The worst aspect is that the focus is on the player who is generally showing of their technical chops. What a bore.

Think about it as a listener who isn't into mainstream jazz (99.9% of the population): a small group of players play a tune you've never heard, in a rather plain fashion. They then each takes a turn playing something sort of similar but different that isn't as tuneful or melodic and are each trying to show-off how good they can play their instrument. Then it goes back to being the original tune. How is this supposed to endear audiences? It's indulgent music played by musicians to show other musicians how good they can play technically. Audiences want something that touches them and communicates thoughts, feelings and emotions. If you can't communicate anything else, at least play something they can dance to. Mainstream continues to fail and those who teach mainstream continue to fail their students.

Take what you will from this site and other sites continuing to perpetuate the myth that mainstream jazz is anything more than a museum piece. If you are not aiming to play music that touches TODAY'S audience how and where are you ever going to be playing?

The music teachers I had in the 50s and 60s thought that the only REAL music was Big Band. This is what they had imprinted on and anything that happened after that was just crap as far as they were concerned. They were stuck and taught me to play in a style that had little to no audience/relevance by 1960. They did me no favor I assure you. Teaching today's students to play mainstream jazz is equally perverse. At least (most) Big Band music you could dance to! Wake up time.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
What do you define as TODAY'S audience.
Good question. Seems to me the majority of todays audience wants utterly flavourless music, food, movies, whatever-else-it-might-be in shiny packaging. Good luck to them, as long as they don't expect me to either listen to or play it. But a small part of today's audience (including me and, it seems several ohter people on this forum) wants something a bit more interesting. I'm not quite a pensioner yet, but the music I like tends to be quite old fashioned. I don't have a problem with that. The world will be a poorer place when people stop performing Bach and Mozart and mainstream jazz. I have no intention of trying to make a living out of music, but it has become an important part of my life again after a 20+ years break. I want to spend as much of the time that's left to me playing the kinds of music I love. If that means I'm unoriginal, so be it.
 
Those of us who are older and have no intention of suddenly (at an advanced age) becoming rich and famous via music can and should play whatever we want. We also listen to whatever we want. This is the best time ever as specialized music and audiences are more accessible than at any time in the past.

There are lots of Musics of "today". The context of that quote has to do with mainstream playing (standards) belonging to a period of the past when it was somewhat popular. Most any keen observer of the obvious would not consider mainstream music to be common or popular today, but similar to genera like ragtime, dixieland, etc. that can be heard, but had their own time and place of being "popular". There are specialized niches for players of any of those styles. If you are very accomplished and very lucky, you may even be able to make a living at it. The same is true for mainstream, it's a very small niche but there are a very large number of players being trained in that style. This is not a good situation if you are a young learner aspiring to be a professional.

The fist thing I said in my diatribe was "If you are interested in making a living out of playing music you'd have to be thinking more like Tom, or at least not trying to sound like copying someone (name your favorite jazz sax player) out of the 1950-60s".

Defending one's personal taste or trying to define "today's audience" are not relevant to this basic truth: mainstream music is a small niche and not likely to grow. Teaching emerging talent to emulate that style is not doing them any favors. Hands up those who were taught in this manner and can not make a living PLAYING mainstream music. And what are you doing if still engaged in music? My guess is teaching others to play in the same mainstream style. This is what's called a cycle of failure. I'm not advocating any particular style of playing, just that there may be some degree of responsibility to ensure that those we teach or influence are not harmed by being pushed into thinking that there is only one way to learn or play music. Look around you and think.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Think like me, and you'll be alright for money........................................;}

The Original Post seemed to highlight that a lot of improvisation tended towards the formulaic and was a little too pre-ordained to be seen as spontaneous or individualistic. I guess for me the issue became one of drawing on my musical roots to play something reasonably coherent as well as focus on what sounds meant something to me.

So, while it is fun to "copy" other players styles, it would not really be my "natural" vocabulary as a Welsh person brought up in the 60's and 70"s with the various musical styles around at the time, such as Van Morrison, Dylan, Neil Young, Marvin Gaye, Junior Walker, Average White Band, Back Door and so on.

BTW Martin, I'm 53, you know......................
 
Think like me, and you'll be alright for money........................................;}
What's your secret? Witchcraft?

The Original Post seemed to highlight that a lot of improvisation tended towards the formulaic and was a little too pre-ordained to be seen as spontaneous or individualistic. I guess for me the issue became one of drawing on my musical roots to play something reasonably coherent as well as focus on what sounds meant something to me.

So, while it is fun to "copy" other players styles, it would not really be my "natural" vocabulary as a Welsh person brought up in the 60's and 70"s with the various musical styles around at the time, such as Van Morrison, Dylan, Neil Young, Marvin Gaye, Junior Walker, Average White Band, Back Door and so on.
Well, I think that raises an imprtant question here. When does vocabluary become copying? If we all went completely our own way and didn't borrow or steal each other's music there would be no common language and everyone's music would be incomprehensible to everyone else. On the other hand, if copying was all we did, there'd be no progress. It has to be a matter of taking what you need from the past and trying to make your own statement with it, possibly even extending the language as you go, in a way which can be understood an appreciated by at least some other people.

The students in the programs Wade talks about are presumably there because they are drawn to that type of music. It's up to them to make something new out of it. Their teachers can't possibly know where they should take it next. What they're learning isn't in itself harmful to their creativity. Unfortunately most students in any field (Im mostly talking about my experiences of teaching maths here, but I've seen it with music students too) just want to jump through the hoops required to get their piece of paper at the end of the course. They never get that the main purpose of a course of study is learnning how to learn. It's sad, but I don't think there's much that can be done about it.

I believe a large part of what we call creativity is actually selection. There were other syles of music around which didn't influence you as much, like (I'm guessing here) the Supremes and the Bee Gees. Your playing style will reflect that in a unique way. Most of the music around when I (we) was young didn't interest me at all. I got hooked into Medelsssohn, Beethoven, etc. I disccovered jazz rather later, and haven't got seriously into it until quite recently. I expect that to be reflected in my playing style.

BTW Martin, I'm 53, you know......................

Snap!
 
You are two calender months older!

Really you are posing a significant philosophical question. Is everything (music, literature, poetry, art etc.) mainly some form or rehashing, out of which emerges some new discovery/truth with moves us forward in some way? rehashing what we grew up with or was drawn to may have a more significant influence than we appreciate at times,
together with whatever consciously influences us now.

Anyway off to have a blow on Tenor Sax!
 
How do we understand and access individuality if we're bombarded by ubiquitous influence?
How can we learn how to be imaginative?

Imagination is never something that is pro-institutional.
So, if the curriculum was centered around imagination, how would that type of class be conducted?
By illustrating various video's of imaginative composer's/musician's?

It's not easy to teach a class based in imagination because in order to be imaginative one has to learn
the rudiments in which eventually all that knowledge will ultimately enable the musician to be mentally agile.
The focus must be on how to get around the instrument and leave style of play remotely in the distance. Style of play is what tarnish's the imaginative process. Let the style be perpetuated by how the musician interprets their own surroundings in accordance to how they want their instrument to reflect it.
 
Influences abound but teaching seems to be still locked into mainstream. It has been hypothesized that this is because the improvisational patterns used in mainstream could be deduced and thus formulated and taught in the same way one teaches math. This is NOT normal in the flow of any art form, but makes teaching much easier than taking Mike's suggestions. That type of instruction would take being open as a teacher rather than closed minded.

There have been numerous styles of playing music, painting, writing, dancing, etc. In every case EXCEPT JAZZ you might learn about the history of what happened, learn the basics of your art, but are generally not encouraged to remain mired in a past art form. What about Classical music and dance I hear you say? Those are performance forms, not creative forms, the creators are the composers, choreographers, etc. The performers are technically trained to (at best) interpret the "master's" work.

Jazz distinguished itself as a creative art form and has been embraced as such by much of the world. How true can this be over time if the same tunes are played in a prescriptive style where only the interpretation is slightly different? That's being locked in and a museum piece. It is the death rattle of a dead art form that can't reinvent itself.

Those innovators of the 1950-60s (that mainstream players revere) were not satisfied to just play what had come before. They moved forward with new thoughts, sounds and dreams. They did NOT accept that "vocabulary" had to be only what was dictated by Dixieland or any other previous improvised musical conventions.

Art that does not grow dies a respected death in a museum or withdraws to little gatherings of the "faithful". There is an unnecessary arrogance in the idea of an orthodoxy of one "vocabulary" (that of mainstream) that defines jazz and it shall be the only language of jazz. That is not only nonsense, it is artistic death.

It has been said by some that students are drawn to mainstream jazz so have made a conscious choice. Sorry that's crap. How many of these "drawn" types know "the vocabulary", or any standards? If they did they wouldn't need teaching would they? They are taught both as though that is the only way they should play and the only material they should play. The decisions teenagers and students make has more to do with what they think is cool, will get them the attention of the opposite sex or make them money. How many students are capable of knowing or choosing to study for a vocation that will be their calling in life? Those choices are generally made without much real knowledge, they are based on guesses, a recognized aptitude, or a perception of cool, sex appeal, and/or money. Students put their trust into teachers and the system to give them the tools they will need to become successful. Mainstream teaching/thinking does not do this. Time to stop,think and look around.
 
My suggestions were tongue in cheek. In jest!
No one would ever consider my suggestions because of the heavily laden
aura of influence which circumvents our lives. However, I'll throw them out there anyhow
because I'm trying to be original.................lol
 
It has been said by some that students are drawn to mainstream jazz so have made a conscious choice. Sorry that's crap. How many of these "drawn" types know "the vocabulary", or any standards? If they did they wouldn't need teaching would they? They are taught both as though that is the only way they should play and the only material they should play. The decisions teenagers and students make has more to do with what they think is cool, will get them the attention of the opposite sex or make them money. How many students are capable of knowing or choosing to study for a vocation that will be their calling in life? Those choices are generally made without much real knowledge, they are based on guesses, a recognized aptitude, or a perception of cool, sex appeal, and/or money. Students put their trust into teachers and the system to give them the tools they will need to become successful. Mainstream teaching/thinking does not do this. Time to stop,think and look around.

I've made a few conscious choices with regards to this.

1 - Listen to music I like.
2 - Not be dictated to by anyone else
3 - Consider other people's opinions respectfully, but make my own mind up.
4 - Be prepared to admit other music into my life by keeping an open mind.

Coolness/image has nothing to do with it. I graduated from that when I turned my back on rock and discovered traditional folk music over 30 years ago. I refused to listen to Zappa all those years ago, because it didn't do anything more than offend me. I still refuse to listen to it. It's just noise to me. Some people find it accessible, I don't. And the same goes for a lot of other modern 'music'. As well as some of the sax greats like Parker, Rollins, Brecker, later Coltrane.....

There's a big danger in being creative - it leads to dismissal of what's gone before, in the pursuit of being different. Irrespective of the merit or otherwise of what's been dismissed. Also in dismissal of choices that do not re-inforce being different.

Teaching students along these lines actually moulds their thinking just as much as teaching along the lines of what's been done before. And is just as inflexible.

As an artist or composer you need to decide who you're playing for - yourself or the audience. And if you play for yourself, don't complain when the audience isn't there.

As a teacher your primary task is to develop the student's skills, and expose them to a broad variety of music. Opening their minds to new music is good. But closing their minds to what's gone before and dictating personal views about mainstream/non mainstream is not.
 
"There's a big danger in being creative - it leads to dismissal of what's gone before, in the pursuit of being different. Irrespective of the merit or otherwise of what's been dismissed. Also in dismissal of choices that do not re-inforce being different."
"Man is limited by his fears, not his imagination" - guess you answered your own statement there

many of the avant garde players I've encountered are interested in all kinds of different music and are far from dissmissive of what's gone before. They may not want to keep repeating what's already been done, but that doesn't mean they don't respect traditional musical forms or not enjoy listening to them. Frank Zappa loved the blues, doo wop, reggae and european folk music, he even invited the Chieftains to his house to jam. Free jazz musicians like Anthony Braxton and Cecil Taylor are very knowledgeable about the history of jazz and african music. These people's music may not be to your taste, but they certainly know about what's gone before them.

Being creative isn't necessarily a "pursuit of being different" nobody's the same anyway, we all speak with a slightly different voice. It's just that some people find that being creative is the only thing they're good at.
If it wasn't for innovation and change and people wanting to do something new, the earth would still be flat and we'd not be playing saxophones or using the internet
Some folks want to boldy go where no man has gone before, others like to stay at home where it's warm and cosy (I like to boldly go where it's warm and cosy..). Neither approach is good or bad, it's a matter of individual choice

"As an artist or composer you need to decide who you're playing for - yourself or the audience. And if you play for yourself, don't complain when the audience isn't there."
It's not as black and white as you appear to see it - it's not either/or, it can be both and all shades in between.
John Coltrane and Ornette Coleman never compromised or considered what would please the listener and they found an audience. Karlheinz Stockhausen wasn't exactly short of a euro or two when he died, John Cage did well for himself.
I don't suppose Pink Floyd sat around deliberately trying to write a crowd pleaser, they just created the best music they could and people liked it.
If pleasing the audience is your only consideration then playing the saxophone is probably not the best place to start.

There are all kinds of people creating all kinds of obscure music that you or I may or may not like, from minimalism to abstract noise, but they find an audience and some of them earn good money from it.
To illustrate my point here's Japanese noise artist Merzbow playing on a decent sized stage - http://youtu.be/GjYR4VRC1rA (warning - hideous noise alert)
- you wouldn't think anyone would pay to listen to this, but he's released over a hundred albums and earns a living from it. There a many more like him

Conversely there are those who set out to be commercial and have been ripped off and fallen on hard times - how many pop artists and boy bands from the last 20 years have achieved any lasting success?
I've met people with top 30 albums who were hugely in debt and had trouble paying the rent. I've also met experimental musicians who could get £1000 a gig all expenses paid and fly around the world performing to packed auditoriums. In each case they were doing exactly what they wanted to do.

Audiences aren't always as narrow minded as you might think. I've played wild free jazz to alternative indie rock audiences and they loved it. It may not be what they listen to at home, but they appreciated the energy and emotion that I was trying to express. It's a strange world.

"As a teacher your primary task is to develop the student's skills, and expose them to a broad variety of music. Opening their minds to new music is good. But closing their minds to what's gone before and dictating personal views about mainstream/non mainstream is not."
- I think the problem with some jazz education is that it's too narrow in scope and doesn't expose students to the full range of possibilities. Jazz moved on from the mid 50's hard bop methodology, but the teaching of jazz often seems stuck there. Probably because it's more difficult to teach and grade creativity - how would you devise a marking scheme for originality?
One of my friends who teaches drums dislikes the music grade system because it doesn't teach students how to play real music in real life situations, as he puts it "I only do grades for the benefit of the parents, once that's done, I teach the students how to play and read and write real music that they actually enjoy"

I'm of the opinion that we should encourage people to be true to their own nature (as long as it's not violent or destructive) If you have a burning desire to play traditional music then go for it, if you want to devote your life to exploring the limits of your own creativity, that's also a good thing. If you want to be an entertainer and have fun, that's also a good thing. Different people like different things. There's enough room for everyone.

We live on a large planet with many diverse musical and artistic styles and traditions - they're all valid in their own way, it's just a matter of personal taste which direction you decide to go in. If you don't like it, you can always do something else. The real problems begin when people start thinking they know what's best for other people, which can lead to conflict. Which is not a good thing.

music should be a positive experience for all concerned, although there's also an audience for negativity..

I think I've wandered off topic here..
now where were we, oh yes - Improvisation or copying?
 
There's a big danger in being creative - it leads to dismissal of what's gone before, in the pursuit of being different. Irrespective of the merit or otherwise of what's been dismissed. Also in dismissal of choices that do not re-inforce being different.

Kev, naturally I don't know who you are but honestly man, I can't believe you said this!

I'm sorry to hear this....

Sorry Mike, it's not what I said - I qualified it. The statement wasn't meant to stand alone.

There's a big danger in being creative - it leads to dismissal of what's gone before, in the pursuit of being different. Irrespective of the merit or otherwise of what's been dismissed. Also in dismissal of choices that do not re-inforce being different.

Because I've seen it in art, photography, writing as well as music. Creative people can get so tied up in their own ideas, they exclude all else. And that's the danger. You can't be creative, without building on what's gone before, and without moving on from it. But you can't dismiss all the earlier creations either. They are. They wil be until they fall apart - or we lose interest in them. And losing interest is a different thing to rejection or denial. And we need to strike a balance between the internal obsession with being new/different all the time and acceptance that there is good in the past that's still valid today.

Don't get me wrong, I like to see new ideas, originality. I spend most of my day finding new/better ways to do things in my job, but they have to work - otherwise they're discarded as ruthlessly as I discard bad photos, bad books, bad music. And fashion.

But who judges our work? Ourselves? Our friends? Our audiences? They've all got a role to play, but for me it's the future generations. Where's Antonio Salieri's music today? But Mozart's is alive and kicking.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom