Theory & Impro Improvisation or copying?

You definitely made my point in the blue underlined statement in your quote:

Yes, mathematically I'll agree with you that if you start fiddling with numbers to try to calculate the possible combinations of notes you will indeed end up with astronomical numbers.

But how many of those are going to sound half-way decent to the human ear?

Start tossing out all the random junk combinations, and that astronomical number may actually whittle down to something almost manageable.

So you can't go by pure mathematics without taking into consideration the fact that humans don't find random combinations to be "musical".

~~~~

Oh wow!

I just argued with a mathematician and I might have even made some sense! :thumb:

I'm not giving up that easily. Let's suppose as a conservative estimate, that there are 2 resonable choices for the next note at any stage of your 100 note sequence (usually there will be a lot more). That's Still 2^100, about 10^30. So we've got that many tunes to compose.

Even-tempered 12-tone scales were invented (oh, yes they were, and quite controversial it was, too!) about 400 years ago, but I'll give you 1000 (10^3). Suppose the human population has been steady at 10 billion (10^10) for all of that time (which is a massive over-estimate) and every one of those humans composes about 300 tunes a day (quite a tall order, I think). That's about 100,000 (10^5) tunes a year each (I'm being really generous here). Mutliply that lot together and you've got 10^18 tunes, still an infinitessimal fraction of 10^30. Take 100,000 years if you like: it won't help much.

That's quite enough maths from me, I'm sure you'll all agree, and I need to do a lot of sax-blowing and listen to a lot of jazz before I'll do any more.
 
I'm not giving up that easily.

I personally don't believe that there exists such a thing as a mathematician who gives up easily. You have to be quite tenacious just to become a mathematician in the first place. ;}

I have no desire to spoil your pi. So I'll concede that you probably know what you're talking about. :thumb:

After all, new music is coming out all the time. So I guess the proof's in the fiddling.

I'd still be interested in hearing alien music though.
 
I find that sometimes being too original isnt good when aiming a performance at the general public.. The audience hates it and cant relate to it (seeing that not many people from the non musical background understand the basics)... However it's still fun to go off on a tangent and we really need some more originality in our music.

I know what you mean with jazz, that licks tend to flow off what others have done, however this is still better than my next example of non originality:

I do also understand with modern music, that there isn't much originality from on song to the next. I was recently improving some backings to a few Korean pop songs. I found it difficult. I was expecting all the songs to be in different keys. However i found they were all the same key and switching from song to song (I had never heard these before). I had to recheck what notes I could play. I found they were all the same chord patterns (maybe in different positions of each chord), the same key, and mostly had exactly the same phrase shape, with slightly different rhythms. The lyrics, dancing and which plastic surgeon the artists used (mainly the plastic surgeon) made each song unique ...

... Thus, any improv where you change the key and mix a few licks together (and dont realy on a sugeon to make you popular) is more original than most modern pop (improv or copying other peoples licks ideas)!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Rudjarl has a very valid question that is more philosophical than mathematical. In my opinion looking strictly at mechanical aspect of playing denies the essence of music. It’s not just notes, how many, or the number of ways they can be combined. As in all the arts it’s about communication. This comes about through subtleties of expression and basically having something to “say”.

Once sufficiently experienced each of us can play the same notes as (name your favourite player or a track of theirs), but does it sound the same? Even if you could imitate that person exactly what would be the point? What makes good or great art is that spark that comes from within an individual, not the person who tries to copy it exactly.

We each have our own voice and own stories to tell. Too many approach playing an instrument or any of the other arts as a mechanical exercise. Well, yes, there is that aspect, but that’s just learning to use the tools and vocabulary for expression and not necessarily an end to itself.

Jazz has been codified to a great extent which I guess is an aid to teaching, but I have some doubts about whether this is ultimately helping or hindering a potential player who wants to make a living out of music and contribute to its future. What’s the market for mainstream (50s and 60s sounding) jazz players? Is this a good way to teach basics, well maybe, but that brings to mind a famous quote about forgetting everything you learned and just playing.

The sax is probably the closest instrument to the human voice, which gives us a potential advantage over instruments like a piano. We can “voice” our notes within a huge range of possibilities (that alone blows out all the mathematics). Timbre, pitch, attack, decay, vibrato, slurs, etc. are all there to be used. This gives us the ability to deliver something way beyond 12 notes.

I hear rudjarl's frustration and longing to see if there is somewhere else to go. Is jazz music just mechanical learning in which you memorize forms then cut and paste as appropriate? I don’t think it needs to be, but you’ve got to engage in a much more emotional and personal way that’s not just finger memory (learned licks and arpeggios). This means stepping outside of simply “playing the changes” and thinking personally about the music.

Lest be realistic, not everybody is going to be a great artist no matter how hard they try or study, but you need to grow beyond the mechanical/learning aspects and move towards having something unique or your own to say. Without taking that step you are nothing more than a technician or copyist.

As a newbie on this site I don’t know how much has been said about ear training or singing practice. If a lot, then you probably already know what’s coming: You can’t expect anything profound, artistic, or unique to come out of your horn unless you can hear it in your head first (this isn’t about happy one off accidents). Learning patterns for wiggling your fingers and making intellectually predictable noises (without knowing the sound first) isn’t being a creative musician.

Can you sing a simple tune (“happy birthday to you”, for example) and then play it in all keys? Being able to be one with your instrument so that it becomes your voice should be the goal. Whatever you can hear you should be able to play. That should be plenty challenge for most, and can take you a long way as a musician and performer.

The next step is to have the music in your head that you will play. This can be a very large library of music you know and grab bits and pieces from, or you could be one of those blessed with true creativity.

The last step that brings it together is that your playing is an honest expression. Well, honest in the same way that an actor has the skill of acting or making the lines believable and delivered with integrity. This is where you go way beyond notes and are using all of the appropriate nuances to deliver the emotions and feeling which are appropriate to the music.
The whole package comes back to communication. When you play a piece where is the art? Is it in the notes on the page and you just sound the right tone at the right time? Is it in cutting and pasting together a bunch of riffs and arpeggios that just happen to be in the right chord/mode?

Once you know your way around your instrument I think it’s about making it your voice and saying whatever it is you are capable of.
 
Rudjarl has a very valid question that is more philosophical than mathematical. In my opinion looking strictly at mechanical aspect of playing denies the essence of music. It’s not just notes, how many, or the number of ways they can be combined. As in all the arts it’s about communication. This comes about through subtleties of expression and basically having something to “say”.

To be fair, the maths stuff was meant in a tongue-in-cheek sort of way. I was just trying to say that even if you accept that there are only 12 notes, which I don't, the possibilites are still pretty much endless after a while.

The sax is probably the closest instrument to the human voice, which gives us a potential advantage over instruments like a piano. We can “voice” our notes within a huge range of possibilities (that alone blows out all the mathematics). Timbre, pitch, attack, decay, vibrato, slurs, etc. are all there to be used. This gives us the ability to deliver something way beyond 12 notes.
I did mention this at the start of my mathematical rant.

I hear rudjarl's frustration and longing to see if there is somewhere else to go. Is jazz music just mechanical learning in which you memorize forms then cut and paste as appropriate? I don’t think it needs to be, but you’ve got to engage in a much more emotional and personal way that’s not just finger memory (learned licks and arpeggios). This means stepping outside of simply “playing the changes” and thinking personally about the music.
For me the point of learning licks, scales, harmony and all the rest of it is to familiarise myself with the language of jazz before I go off and try to do my own thing. If you want to say something, you have to say it in a language your audience has some familiarity with, whether it's jazz, classical music or Urdu. And the better you know the language, the more eloquently you can express yourself. And if you're really exceptional you can extend the language in a way that others will want to go along with (or "copy"). I'll be surprised if I ever get that far, but I'm open to the idea of it.

Lest be realistic, not everybody is going to be a great artist no matter how hard they try or study, but you need to grow beyond the mechanical/learning aspects and move towards having something unique or your own to say. Without taking that step you are nothing more than a technician or copyist.
Agreed, but without the basic technical skills you're unable to communicate your ideas/feelings no matter how beautiful they may be. I think it's natural that, in a forum like this, we tend to discuss the technical side because that's the stuff which can be expressed in words. If we could express the emotional side in words we wouldn't need to go to the trouble of learning music.

As a newbie on this site I don’t know how much has been said about ear training or singing practice. If a lot, then you probably already know what’s coming: You can’t expect anything profound, artistic, or unique to come out of your horn unless you can hear it in your head first (this isn’t about happy one off accidents). Learning patterns for wiggling your fingers and making intellectually predictable noises (without knowing the sound first) isn’t being a creative musician.
I agree abiout ear training. I've done a lot of it over the last year and it's really helped my playing. I've argued elsewhere that that's one of the most important reasons for practising scales, etc.
 
Whats a lick?
Improvising is new and scary to me!

a) It's what you do to keep your reed moist.

b) It's a phrase that you can learn to use in certain harmonic contexts, possibly modified to fit into a melodic line. Someone in another thread posted a great video link of a particular lick being used in different musical situations.

Edit: Just found the link:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
HI
thanks for that !
Do people generally write their own licks or (dare I say it) is there a book of licks ?

i'm really interested now...

Probably the best thing is to hear something you like and try to copy it on your sax. There are books, but I don't own one, so can't recommend. And in any case you don't want to bore yourself to death by working through a long list of licks compiled by someone else. I've recently been going through some jazz etudes I've been working on and picking out things that that sound good to me. Then you mess around with them, change the rhythms, play them in different keys, try landing on a different note, that sort of thing. Really try to make them your own.
 
a) It's what you do to keep your reed moist.

b) It's a phrase that you can learn to use in certain harmonic contexts, possibly modified to fit into a melodic line. Someone in another thread posted a great video link of a particular lick being used in different musical situations.

Edit: Just found the link:


Such a simple one too! never heard that one but will probably hear it from now on!

HI
thanks for that !
Do people generally write their own licks or (dare I say it) is there a book of licks ?

i'm really interested now...

You can - I make up my own, but there are lots of common ones which I do variations of too. An example is something like cry me a river/careless whisper is often used over minor chords :thumb:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Glad there seems to be some stimulation, but really hoped to hear from rudjarl. The suggestions were specifically to help with what he described as his current status and frustrations. Not sure why Big Martin or anyone needs to defend their chosen path. The topic is rudjarl's dilema in which he describes himself as someone who has learned the basic skills that Big Martin (rightly) describes as necessary. Rudjarl is stuck and has reached out. I don't think the answer is to tell him to do more of the same.

There is no shortcut to learning and the hours that one needs to practice, but there can be a point where you realize (as rudjarl seems to have) that there needs to be something more to playing an instrument than technical playing. I think rudjarl was brave to face this and is wise to look for answers rather than give up or pretend that all is OK.

We all have tendencies towards establishing habits. Engaging in one mode of learning, playing, living, etc. can take you in that one direction, which may be OK for some, but growth sometimes requires pushing in new directions or breaking old habits that would otherwise keep you in the same place.

Quoting what rudjarl said "I can't help feeling that it only conforms you to the stereotype that has become Jazz. There is no real originality in playing licks and copying solos. Oh, it makes you sound cool. No doubt about it. But is it a sign of originality?" I think this describes where a lot of people learning jazz wind up if they only learn and work from a technical perspective.

It should be everyone’s choice as to how they decide to learn, but that presumes that everyone knows all the options. It may be that some who are extremely talented can grow "organically" beyond the limitations of a strictly technical musical education, the rest just might get stuck, when possibly they don't need to.

It is more than possible to develop your ear, your voice, a melodic sense, and bring your emotions into your playing without putting these off until you are (somehow at some point?) a master of technical skills.

Big Martin is right, most forums (like this one) concentrate on technical aspects. Does it have to be that way? You have the "your soundclips" section that can be used for constructive criticism of playing. When you listen to music (at any other time outside of a sax forum) do you only hear and discuss just the technical aspects? I don't think so. Everyone "gets it" when someone plays with feeling and conveys something beyond the right notes at the right time. Players like Miles Davis blew heaps of bad notes, didn't matter much did it.
 
Big Martin is right, most forums (like this one) concentrate on technical aspects. Does it have to be that way? You have the "your soundclips" section that can be used for constructive criticism of playing. When you listen to music (at any other time outside of a sax forum) do you only hear and discuss just the technical aspects? I don't think so. Everyone "gets it" when someone plays with feeling and conveys something beyond the right notes at the right time. Players like Miles Davis blew heaps of bad notes, didn't matter much did it.

Sounds like a good idea to start pushing the soundclips more. And I'd like to see it take off.

However I can't help thinking of my experience on photo forums, where feedback was mostly of the 'Well done' variety and didn't offer more than strokes. When one tried to steer it towards something more constructive, it sometimes worked, but many other problems came up. Excessive/unmerited praise, excessive/unnecessary criticism, differing expectations of the posters, perceptions of unfairness....

Sometimes people would really tear into something, which didn't really help. And you'd get guys who'd posted the shots, either being demoralised from lack of decent criticism, or from excessive/bad criticism. It was a very difficult balance to maintain and I noticed that many people would wait to see what the mod said before giving feedback - and then repeat what the mod had said with varying degrees of praise or savageness.

Some people are really good at giving good feedback, tailoring it to the poster's experience and expectations. Others...... one of the things that annoyed me the most was when someone with little talent would post a detailed, usually rules based, crit of someone's (often excellent) shot, while completely missing the point - and then the feeding frenzy would start, each trying to outdo the other in feedback. Was funny, all you had to do was point out the good points in a shot, show how the rules were not appropriate tot eh shot and the 'me toos' swould shut up. Quick. I'm gad I'm out of that. I'm very much a beginner with the sax, but there are some great players here who'd be well qualified to comment.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom