BigMartin
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 3,814
- Location
- Manchester, UK
You definitely made my point in the blue underlined statement in your quote:
Yes, mathematically I'll agree with you that if you start fiddling with numbers to try to calculate the possible combinations of notes you will indeed end up with astronomical numbers.
But how many of those are going to sound half-way decent to the human ear?
Start tossing out all the random junk combinations, and that astronomical number may actually whittle down to something almost manageable.
So you can't go by pure mathematics without taking into consideration the fact that humans don't find random combinations to be "musical".
~~~~
Oh wow!
I just argued with a mathematician and I might have even made some sense!![]()
I'm not giving up that easily. Let's suppose as a conservative estimate, that there are 2 resonable choices for the next note at any stage of your 100 note sequence (usually there will be a lot more). That's Still 2^100, about 10^30. So we've got that many tunes to compose.
Even-tempered 12-tone scales were invented (oh, yes they were, and quite controversial it was, too!) about 400 years ago, but I'll give you 1000 (10^3). Suppose the human population has been steady at 10 billion (10^10) for all of that time (which is a massive over-estimate) and every one of those humans composes about 300 tunes a day (quite a tall order, I think). That's about 100,000 (10^5) tunes a year each (I'm being really generous here). Mutliply that lot together and you've got 10^18 tunes, still an infinitessimal fraction of 10^30. Take 100,000 years if you like: it won't help much.
That's quite enough maths from me, I'm sure you'll all agree, and I need to do a lot of sax-blowing and listen to a lot of jazz before I'll do any more.
