Theory & Impro Improvisation or copying?

Interesting: I guess what we all would hope for would when posting a soundclip would be comment of the kind a good teacher would give - generally positive and encouraging but kindly pointing out one or two problems that seem within the capability of the student to address. One of the reasons I like this forum, is that is the attitude that generally comes across. Equally, no one should expect free tuition here! After all, I pay my teacher ...
 
I must admit to when i hear a sounclip and it's not my cup of tea, and that could be for a number of reasons ie :- instrument, style, ect ect i would rather not leave any feedback. One main reason for not leaving feedback is i'm not experienced enough to give constructive critisism, so would rather say nothing at all.
If i do like a soundclip i will give feedback but only how it is to my ears and tastes, having the sounclip area is a good idea if you are brave enough to upload a soundclip and brave enough to accept constructive critisism.
Iv'e just bought a H2 so you will be hearing from me sooner rather than later, and please be gentle with me. 🙂
 
Hi Wade, thank's for your inputs. There are a thing or two you need to know though. One is that I'm never overly serious about anything. Reflected at lucky moments, yes, but never to be taken serious lightly. Next thing is, that goes for Old Git to.

First off, I started this thread because I had a 'Qualis artifex pereo' moment. I want to be a genuine artist, but are not willing to spend the effort needed to become one. So, as perhaps too many do, I settle for complaining about it instead of doing something about it.

That makes Big Martin, and yourself, right. Practise and practise and a bit more practise are always the way forward. Know thy Horn and merry be thy music. So, in my case, a 'get you fat ass off the chair and start practising' is very valid indeed. I still can't help wondering if a passage or two from 'Die Zauberflöte' would be just as cool as a II-V-I lick though. Not that it's any more genuine, but something slightly different than the normal 'stereotype' way anyway.
 
Thanks rudjarl for chiming in. Yes I don't know the personalities so have no idea who is serious or sarcastic. Sounded like a call for some help from you and what you were grumbling about is unfortunately far too common. Guess I should lighten up or realize that this is just a "happy face place"?

Kevgermany is right about the potential for all sorts of personalities commenting on your playing. Some who post their playing just want to share what they are doing and collect a pat on the back. Others may want/need constructive criticism. Dividing these off might be a good idea. If someone can handle criticism, and understands that you can't control or monitor likes, dislikes or personalities, then they may gain from this.

As you point out, there are extremes are out there from the shmoozers to the haters, that's the reality of life. Doesn't mean we should live in shells only to pop out when it's safe. There is no safe and you sometimes need to be exposed and vulnerable in order to grow and learn. Performers can't be thin skinned. There are cruel people out there who will go out of their way to try and make someone else feel as badly as they do. I have a live recording of guitarist Bill Frisell (my favourite guitarist) in which he is being heckled by someone in the audience. Didn't stop him from playing or playing well at that gig, he's a pro.

I'm a newbie, so don't really know the collective mood or desires of those here. Could be just light-hearted chit chat or a place to share and learn. I have noticed that everyone feels comfortable about jumping on someone's thread and talking about something completely different. That's kind of rude, but nobody seems to care. If this is all just light-hearted fun, then I guess it doesn't matter.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hi again Wade. You have probably noticed that there often is at least two different moods in most threads up here. The light hearted one and the serious one. Not that light hearted can't be serious... That is one of the beautiful things about this place. It can be in any of the moods or any combination thereof. As are we all from time to time. And all you need to do is jump in, in you current mood... so to speak...

That said, I firmly believe that playing jazz could benefit from some fresh ways of doing it.

When it comes to putting own music up here there are a lot of considerations. We are all beginners, only at different times and places. And though I would like some criticism (in addition to the well done) myself, it is not easy to know when to do it and when not.
 
I like the idea of a soundclip area for mutual critiquing (is that a word?). Not so much a pupil-teacher situation as a kind of goup therapy for sax-players. I've been promising myself for ages to record some of my improv and the chance to get some honest feedback here would be an added incentive. I can't see any of the regulars here getting too hostile about it, and Pete and Kev have done a great job of calming the situation when things have got a bit heated (I'm thinking of one or two people who have now left) in other parts of the forum. And Wade makes a good point about performers needing to develop a thick skin.
 
If the site wanted to introduce a new category could be something like Ear Food Review (post your clips here for constructive critical comments). The soundclip section may also be adequate if those who want critical reviews specify that that's what they are after. I my experience it's easy to have people give meaningless compliments. What I want/need is honest feedback so that I become aware of areas that need work and how/if my work is communicating.

Gaining experience and helping each other grow in a relatively safe environment seems like a good thing. If those who would value and use this type of feedback are vigilant I think they can sideline the cowboys and bullies fairly quickly by supporting whoever posted their clip.

As you know I’m new (in these parts) so may seem a bit pushy. I’d rather think of myself as passionate and able to offer interesting/alternate ways to see and think about things. Doesn’t mean that my opinions are in any way better, just different. Hopefully my “upstart” tendencies don’t cause offense. Patience and diplomacy are unfortunately not my strong suits.
 
I'm a newbie, so don't really know the collective mood or desires of those here. Could be just light-hearted chit chat or a place to share and learn. I have noticed that everyone feels comfortable about jumping on someone's thread and talking about something completely different. That's kind of rude, but nobody seems to care. If this is all just light-hearted fun, then I guess it doesn't matter.

In general we're pretty relaxed here, but also serious about getting better. Threads drift a lot. But it adds to the enjoyment for most of us. And the humour often takes the barb out of a difficult comment. So please take us as you find us, but deep down, we're serious.

If the site wanted to introduce a new category could be something like Ear Food Review (post your clips here for constructive critical comments). The soundclip section may also be adequate if those who want critical reviews specify that that's what they are after. I my experience it's easy to have people give meaningless compliments. What I want/need is honest feedback so that I become aware of areas that need work and how/if my work is communicating.

Gaining experience and helping each other grow in a relatively safe environment seems like a good thing. If those who would value and use this type of feedback are vigilant I think they can sideline the cowboys and bullies fairly quickly by supporting whoever posted their clip.

As you know I’m new (in these parts) so may seem a bit pushy. I’d rather think of myself as passionate and able to offer interesting/alternate ways to see and think about things. Doesn’t mean that my opinions are in any way better, just different. Hopefully my “upstart” tendencies don’t cause offense. Patience and diplomacy are unfortunately not my strong suits.

Some good suggesions here. You're obviously one of the guys that's at the straight end of the feedback spectrum. Good thing. But some of the guys are little more sensitive.
 
Wade,
Rudjarl is very serious when consuming alcoholic beverages in CaSLM territory.:welldone

Seems to me that the problem would be that a number of us believe in the old standard's words, "If you can't say anything real nice. Don't say anything is my advice." Remember that this is the opinion of someone a fellow poster described as "Smart". ;}
 
I'm reminded of that Charles Mingus tune "If Charlie Parker was a gunslinger, there'd be a whole lot of dead copycats"

and this quote from John Stevens -
Improvisation is the basis of learning to play a musical instrument, but what usually happens? You decide you want a certain instrument. You buy the instrument and the think to yourself "I'll go and find a teacher, and who knows, in 7 or 8 years time I might be able to play this thing." And in that way you miss a mass of important musical experience. Studying formally with a teacher might be the right way to achieve certain specific aims, but to do only that is a very distorted way of approaching a musical instrument. It has to be realised that a person's own investigation of an instrument - his exploration of it - is totally valid .... Application is even more important than technical facility, because application is the key to taking part, to being involved "
(quoted in Derek Bailey's book "Improvisation - It's Nature And Practice In Music")

it seems to me that Jazz, once described as "the sound of surprise," has now become rigidised and codified into a method - play these scales over these chords etc (http://www.outsideshore.com/primer/primer/)- which makes it easier to teach, but leaves little room for originality. Jazz is stuck in the 1950's, hypnotised by the methodology of Be Bop with none of the freshness and vitalty that characterised that period.
Music education has become a big business selling tuition books and dvds etc that will teach you how to play just like your heroes - an attractive proposition for beginners - most of us picked up an instrument because we were inspired by our favourite musicians, but at what point do we ever decide to play like ourselves? Those very musicians we admire so much became so great because they had a burning desire to be original and not just play the same old stuff. You'll never be as good at being Charlie Parker as he was, so you'll always be second best unless you break out of the rut.
Some musicians seem to think that improvising involves playing a bunch of carefully practised licks and phrases in a different order every time. Personally it bores the heck out of me to hear someone reciting the contents of their CD collection. I already know what Miles Davis had to say about life, what have you got to say for yourself? Do you not have your own thoughts and feelings?

Of course it all depends on what you want to do as a musician. If you're playing in a covers band then it's necessary to play "just like the record," if you're playing wine bars and weddings then there aren't going to be any opportunities to play anything wild and free, if you're playing in a blues band then a thorough knowledge of every blues lick ever played will come in handy, just try to give it some flavour of your own.
If you're trying to be creative, then there's only so much you can learn by playing other people's music before you have to start speaking with your own voice. Be inspired by your heroes' creativity, not enslaved by it.
The only way to practise improvisation is to improvise - keep at it and you'll get better and better. Be inspired by the world around you and listen to something different. The last thing we need is another Coltrane copyist..

Breaking out of our ingrained habits is a difficult business, here's a few links that may help -
http://beingmusicalbeinghuman.com/2011/05/11/improvisation-part-1-addition-by-subtraction/

http://classicalimprov.com/?page_id=10

http://www20.brinkster.com/improarchive/tn_wisdom_part1.pdf
http://www20.brinkster.com/improarchive/tn_wisdom_part2.pdf

http://www20.brinkster.com/improarchive/jackw_essays.htm

improvisation can be a lot of things
from this - http://youtu.be/2d6E9TD0Zbs
to this - http://youtu.be/DnW4VOXKB1g
or this - http://youtu.be/780ezArv3Gs

find your own way...

to quote that Funkadelic record "free your mind and your ass will follow"
 
The last thing we need is another Coltrane copyist..

Damn I was just getting the hang of it.
Is it alright if I keep trying to be a Sonny Rollins copyist.
After watching that programme last week my wife says I already stagger round like an 80 year old man, now I just need to work on the saxophone part.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Damn I was just getting the hang of it.
Is it alright if I keep trying to be a Sonny Rollins copyist.
After watching that programme last week my wife says I already stagger round like an 80 year old man, now I just need to work on the saxophone part.

stick to the age parts - it comes naturally and is less painful for the rest of us >:)
 
I've just played a Bhouse...!

Excellent post from Altissimo. Irealised after a while that my Improvisations always seemed to have more of a Rock/Blues leaning, and thought that Aebersold and similar on Improvisation bored me to tears, as does much of what passes for improvisation. I remember sitting with a friend listening to the Blue Trane CD by John Coltrane. The task was to listen to each track and collectively decide when our attention had begun to wander. For most tracks it was up to approx 1min 15secs or so, before dear old John had gone off on one, never to return within our attention span.

I like what Matt Wates wrote about Improvisation, and the indulgent playing of much of what goes on. http://www.mattwates.com/matt_wates_sextet.html.

For me, having been born and brought up in the era of Rock & Pop it does feel appropriate to allow this to influence my playing and improvisation, and 2-5-1 is not of any major significance. If Hendrix was happy enough playing Pentatonic scales, I am happy enough to follow suit and beyond!
 
For me, having been born and brought up in the era of Rock & Pop it does feel appropriate to allow this to influence my playing and improvisation, and 2-5-1 is not of any major significance. If Hendrix was happy enough playing Pentatonic scales, I am happy enough to follow suit and beyond!
I think it's very much a matter of taste, as well as age. I imagine I was born about the same time as you but, while I agree that Coltrane does go too far out there at times, he can hold my attention much better than Hendrix. I seem to be the only person in the world who feels that rock was well past it's sell-by date in 1960.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom